Which of these stats justify an MVP QB

[Wolverine830872]

QB A
QB rating - 3rd in league
Completion Percentage - 16th in league
Passing Yards - 4th in league
Passing TD - tied for 2nd

QB B
QB rating - 4th
Completion Percentage - 12th
Passing Yards - 3rd
Passing TD - 1st

QB C
QB rating - 1st
Completion Percentage - 3rd
Passing Yards - 12th
Passing TD - 6th

QB D
QB rating - 8th
Completion Percentage - 28th
Passing Yards - 16th
Passing TD - tied for 2nd

 

[Wolverine830872]

and their running stats:

QB A: 25 attempts/24 yards; 1 TD; 6 fumbles
QB B: 34 attempts/53 yards; 3 TD; 6 fumbles
QB C: 103 attempts/553 yards; 1 TD; 7 fumbles
QB D: 132 attempts/636 yards; 10 TD; 5 fumbles

 

[Broncos6482]

MVP is about more than just stats, so it's impossible to vote without more context. How many games did each team win? What kind of talent surrounds all the players? How did injuries to other players affect their numbers? Etc, etc.

All that said, based strictly on your stats, qb D produced the most touchdowns, so I'll go with him.

 

[Wolverine830872]

MVP is about more than just stats, so it's impossible to vote without more context. How many games did each team win? What kind of talent surrounds all the players? How did injuries to other players affect their numbers? Etc, etc.

All that said, based strictly on your stats, qb D produced the most touchdowns, so I'll go with him.

Ok I'll bite, QB D had the easiest schedule in the NFL this year, and played a divisional opponent that many say had the worst defense in NFL modern history

 

[Bolts]

I know who each one is, but assuming this is supposed to be a blind vote I won't say. I'm choosing QB D for MVP.

 

[dkmightyhammer]

I'm choosing QB "C" and since this is a blind vote it doesn't make me a homer.

 

[flyerhawk]

Stats are helpful but MVP is about results. Hard to argue that the the Panthers would be pretty far from 15-1 without Cam.

 

[kramer1]

I chose B before seeing the running stats which gave it away. Who is B?

 

[The Q]

Ok I'll bite, QB D had the easiest schedule in the NFL this year, and played a divisional opponent that many say had the worst defense in NFL modern history

QB D played in the AFC South?

 

[Wolverine830872]

QB D played in the AFC South?

No... which defense are you thinking about?

 

[jarntt]

Seahawk thread...Screw it, I'll go with QB "E":

884 yards passing; 13 yards rushing; 5 TDs and 7 INTs...MVP; 15 wins versus 10 or 4??? Who cares...

 

[The Q]

No... which defense are you thinking about?

you said the worst division this era.

for the last 4 or 5 years that's easily been the AFC South.

For example, The only reason they didn't have 3 top 5 draft picks in the 2013 draft is becuase they all had to play each other.

 

[eaglesnut]

QB A
QB rating - 3rd in league
Completion Percentage - 16th in league
Passing Yards - 4th in league
Passing TD - tied for 2nd

QB B
QB rating - 4th
Completion Percentage - 12th
Passing Yards - 3rd
Passing TD - 1st

QB C
QB rating - 1st
Completion Percentage - 3rd
Passing Yards - 12th
Passing TD - 6th

QB D
QB rating - 8th
Completion Percentage - 28th
Passing Yards - 16th
Passing TD - tied for 2nd

None of the above. Total yards, total touchdowns and total turnovers is what matters for a whole year.

 

[Money]

I will use stats to compare QBs when the QBs themselves are the only variable. Until then, I'll consider all factors and pick QB D as the hands down MVP winner.

 

[The Q]

None of the above. Total yards, total touchdowns and total turnovers is what matters for a whole year.

BS. YPA is very importnat. Otherwise you get those QBs with low YPAs but way too high attempts who just compilers.

 

[Gatorchip]

Which one is Alex Smith? That's the one I vote for.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

I vote for the guy throwing to Ted Ginn and Philly Brown all season

 

[eaglesnut]

BS. YPA is very importnat. Otherwise you get those QBs with low YPAs but way too high attempts who just compilers.

BS. Total yards captures how much he helped his team move the football. Total touchdowns captures how much he helped his team score. And total turnovers captures how much he hurt his team. This is a game of moving the football, scoring, and possession. A guy with high YPA and low total yardage is very efficient at letting the rest of his team do the dirty work.

 

[Money]

I vote for the guy throwing to Ted Ginn and Philly Brown all season

He didn't throw to Philly Brown all season. It was Corey Brown for part of it.

 

[The Q]

no true.

Give me YPA and air yards and you see who is doing heavy lifting and who is letting someone else do the lifting for them.