Wentz or Mayfield: who would you rather have?

[Manster7588]

Let's fast forward to next offseason.

For augments sake Baker plays at to 5 to 10 level, he's looking at a new LTD, does he give Carolina a thankyou team friendly deal or move on?

 

[fastforward]

Let's fast forward to next offseason.

For augments sake Baker plays at to 5 to 10 level, he's looking at a new LTD, does he give Carolina a thankyou team friendly deal or move on?

The Von Miller approach is what i'd recommend. Say nice things to all the interested teams, tease them, and then grab the best offer.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Let's fast forward to next offseason.

For augments sake Baker plays at to 5 to 10 level, he's looking at a new LTD, does he give Carolina a thankyou team friendly deal or move on?

First I don't think Mayfield plays that well.

But I'll play the game.

BM just gave that billionaire in Cleveland back $3.5M so he'll be looking to get paid.

You'd have to factor in what other teams and offers he may get. That could influence his decision. But no I don't see him giving them a hometown discount. He may stay in Carolina but they'll have to pay fair market price or higher.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Let's fast forward to next offseason.

For augments sake Baker plays at to 5 to 10 level, he's looking at a new LTD, does he give Carolina a thankyou team friendly deal or move on?

How about this……Mayfield doesn’t play very well but better then the other QBs on the roster, do the Panthers resign him?

 

[Manster7588]

First I don't think Mayfield plays that well.

But I'll play the game.

BM just gave that billionaire in Cleveland back $3.5M so he'll be looking to get paid.

You'd have to factor in what other teams and offers he may get. That could influence his decision. But no I don't see him giving them a hometown discount. He may stay in Carolina but they'll have to pay fair market price or higher.

Fair, I just think he may thank you to the team.

Of course him playing that well is a big IF.

 

[Manster7588]

How about this……Mayfield doesn’t play very well but better then the other QBs on the roster, do the Panthers resign him?

Good question. I guess it depends on how much he wants.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

How about this……Mayfield doesn’t play very well but better then the other QBs on the roster, do the Panthers resign him?

I think that would depend on Carolinas draft picks next season. Will they be able to draft a starter? With the thought of keeping the current bsck ups in place?

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Good question. I guess it depends on how much he wants.

See I say don’t waste much when you know the end results are failure on a meh QB

 

[Manster7588]

See I say don’t waste much when you know the end results are failure on a meh QB

What if he realizes he's better off as a BU, tells the team he'll sign cheap, and help develop a rookie.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

What if he realizes he's better off as a BU, tells the team he'll sign cheap, and help develop a rookie.

Think he will realizes he’s a back up?

 

[Manster7588]

Think he will realizes he’s a back up?

Unlikely but possible.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

No matter what happens the panthers scored.
They will be paying their starting QB 5 mil. = Win
On the other hand they will be paying their back up 18 mil or so = Loss
but
If they get even average quarterbacking from them. Paying 23 mil to the position is still winning.

 

[LambeauLegs]

 

[Iggloo]

No matter what happens the panthers scored.
They will be paying their starting QB 5 mil. = Win
On the other hand they will be paying their back up 18 mil or so = Loss
but
If they get even average quarterbacking from them. Paying 23 mil to the position is still winning.

Jalen Hurts: $1.6 million

Gardner Minshew: $2.5 million

Eagles invested a second rounder and a sixth rounder for these players, less than Carolina spent on Darnold and Mayfield.

Are they significantly better? I don't know, but paying 23 million to mediocre QBs is not winning. You could have found guys on the scrap heap of similar value. And of course if they could draft even a little Carolina would not be in this situation.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

 

[Clayton]

Let's fast forward to next offseason.

For augments sake Baker plays at to 5 to 10 level, he's looking at a new LTD, does he give Carolina a thankyou team friendly deal or move on?

Ryan Tannehill 2.0 imo. Panthers desperate for a QB back up the truck and overpay Baker.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Ryan Tannehill 2.0 imo. Panthers desperate for a QB back up the truck and overpay Baker.

I don't think it's an overpay. $5.5M w/ possible incentives, and a conditional 5th. I don't think Baker will qualify for either unless he really balls out. But that Oline is suspect.

 

[Clayton]

I don't think it's an overpay. $5.5M w/ possible incentives, and a conditional 5th. I don't think Baker will qualify for either unless he really balls out. But that Oline is suspect.

I'm kinda with you that he won't 'ball out'. I think Baker is basically a journeyman right now unless his INTs go way down.

But Carolina is clearly pretty desperate for a QB

 

[Wamu]

Calm down groomer. Nobody wanted him including the Panthers. That is why they only gave up a 5th round pick. Taking someone for literally nearly as close to nothing as possible is much different than actually wanting someone.

Lebron was just a point to your teams want him but his salary was too high. Baker could be on a minimum contract and still nobody would want him other than as a backup. He sucks, go cry about it somewhere else.

Why am I not surprised you don't know what you're talking about? You're also the same person that said OBJ's a HOFer. You said that in the is baker mayfield a bust thread.

If the Panthers didn't want him why did they trade for him in the first place? It doesn't matter what it took to get him, they still went after him.

And the proof that you're kinda clueless is how you brought up LeBron, an NBA player, when this discussion is about about football.

"He sucks, go cry about it somewhere else."

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Who's crying? I'm not a Mayfield fan and I'm glad he's finally gone.

 

[PDay8810]

Funny...I not only remain unsure if Mayfield is what he thinks he is as a NFL QB and I'm even less sure Watson is this top 5 NFL so many fans seem assured of.