Tony Romo wins a championship

[Oldschool739]

The argument isn't about the team around Romo or Eli. The argument is, on an individual level, who is the better player. And it is clear to anyone that knows anything about football that Romo was far and away the better individual QB.

The fact that you feel the need to bring up the teams they played on shows the weakness of your argument. You bring up the SBs as if an individual player is responsible for winning a SB, which is fallacious at best and ignorant at worst.

They are very responsible when they are named MVP, that's Most Valuable Player for idiots like you that don't know.....
If Romo was in fact a better qb than Eli, then explain why he was such a failure as one, and especially in important games.....2 playoff wins in his whole 12 yr career, Kapernick had more in his 1st yr and didn't start the whole season and he was a total bum........Romo was an expensive bust for a team that was used to great qb's and winning on a consistent basis...He never accomplished that for them and eventually was dumped for a rookie....Eli has for his team and is still the starter.....
Let me help you with this Goober, "it's about winning in the NFL, losers get replaced" Hello !!!!

 

[SteelersPride]

The argument isn't about the team around Romo or Eli. The argument is, on an individual level, who is the better player. And it is clear to anyone that knows anything about football that Romo was far and away the better individual QB.

The fact that you feel the need to bring up the teams they played on shows the weakness of your argument. You bring up the SBs as if an individual player is responsible for winning a SB, which is fallacious at best and ignorant at worst.

i want a qb with the IT factor

 

[megalodon30]

They are very responsible when they are named MVP, that's Most Valuable Player for idiots like you that don't know.....
If Romo was in fact a better qb than Eli, then explain why he was such a failure as one, and especially in important games.....2 playoff wins in his whole 12 yr career, Kapernick had more in his 1st yr and didn't start the whole season and he was a total bum........Romo was an expensive bust for a team that was used to great qb's and winning on a consistent basis...He never accomplished that for them and eventually was dumped for a rookie....Eli has for his team and is still the starter.....
Let me help you with this Goober, "it's about winning in the NFL, losers get replaced" Hello !!!!

Eli Manning has been in the league since 2005 and has only won at least one playoff game in just 2 seasons.

Anyone that doesn't recognize that Eli Manning is a horrible QB doesn't know anything about football.

 

[SteelersPride]

Eli Manning has been in the league since 2005 and has only won at least one playoff game in just 2 seasons.

Anyone that doesn't recognize that Eli Manning is a horrible QB doesn't know anything about football.

his rings and mvps are shiny.............IT factor

 

[megalodon30]

his rings and mvps are shiny.............IT factor

Yeah, so are Trevor Siemian and Brock Osweiler's rings. Doesn't mean jack if you're a terrible QB.

And Tim Tebow undeniably had the IT factor. Didn't do much for him.

As for his SB MVP award, great. He was good in one game. But one game does not make a career. Anybody can be good in one game.

Eli has also been one and done 4 times in his career.

 

[SteelersPride]

Yeah, so are Trevor Siemian and Brock Osweiler's rings. Doesn't mean jack if you're a terrible QB.

And Tim Tebow undeniably had the IT factor. Didn't do much for him.

As for his SB MVP award, great. He was good in one game. But one game does not make a career. Anybody can be good in one game.

Eli has also been one and done 4 times in his career.

no those rings are nothing alike those are back up rings.......tebow did not have the IT factor to get it done when it mattered............

 

[megalodon30]

tebow did not have the IT factor to get it done when it mattered.

Says a Steelers fan.

 

[SteelersPride]

Says a Steelers fan.

great comeback............he beat us on a hugely blown covereage...........but he did find the open guy...........

anything else?

 

[megalodon30]

great comeback............he beat us on a hugely blown covereage...........but he did find the open guy...........

anything else?

But he couldn't get IT done when it mattered...

 

[SteelersPride]

But he couldn't get IT done when it mattered...

did he win a super bowl? did he win a conference title? no, come again now

 

[megalodon30]

did he win a super bowl? did he win a conference title? no, come again now

Dude started one season and took a terrible team to the playoffs.

Contrast that with Eli, who's missed the playoffs more often than not and has been one and done twice as much as he's had a postseason where he actually won a game.

 

[SteelersPride]

Dude started one season and took a terrible team to the playoffs.

Contrast that with Eli, who's missed the playoffs more often than not and has been one and done twice as much as he's had a postseason where he actually won a game.

ugh its like talking to a wall, have a good night

 

[Pure Steel]

did he win a super bowl? did he win a conference title? no, come again now

He is sharpening his football skills in AA baseball with the Mets.....

 

[megalodon30]

ugh its like talking to a wall, have a good night

It's what happens when you take up the cause of Eli Manning. You get rekt.

 

[SteelersPride]

He is sharpening his football skills in AA baseball with the Mets.....

pretty much

 

[Oldschool739]

Anyone that doesn't recognize that Eli Manning is a horrible QB doesn't know anything about football.[/QUOTE]

Man you must be on crack or something, looks like your last screw just came loose....
Eli was drafted #1 over all in 05 and and has won 2 SB's and still playing.
Romo signed as an UFA in 03 with the Boys and has never won anything in 14 yrs and is done....
How you can equate better out of a qb that has played longer and won far less is a total wonder....
It never ceases to amaze me, the stupidity of stat lovers and the ignorance that won't let them go.....

 

[Manster7588]

his rings and mvps are shiny.............IT factor

So I'll put you on the list who says Troy Aikman is the FOURTH best QB all time.
Got it.

 

[Oldschool739]

great comeback............he beat us on a hugely blown covereage...........but he did find the open guy...........

anything else?

Yeah, he's playing baseball now and still looking for a championship....But hey according to megadope, anybody can be great once....Guess Romo didn't get the memo....

 

[SteelersPride]

ye

So I'll put you on the list who says Troy Aikman is the FOURTH best QB all time.
Got it.

yes

 

[SteelersPride]

Yeah, he's playing baseball now and still looking for a championship....But hey according to megadope, anybody can be great once....Guess Romo didn't get the memo....

lololo