The state of Eli Manning

[Gman]

hold on...Eli is absolutely part of the problem. The main problem? No, not IMO. I still think Eli is fine at QB, but he needs to be better than he has been lately.

Yes, Eli has looked mediocre overall.

But how do you disentangle that from the O-line play? Or the drops?... (there were a few key ones last night)

With an O-line playing so poorly... it's really tough to isolate the QB play and judge it solely. Even in the minority of plays where Eli has time... you have to think his internal clock is off because he always has to suspect heat is coming.

 

[megalodon30]

So Beckham played and Eli still sucked?

 

[starbigd]

But but but Odell is the most important player on the field according to some Giants fans on this board.

I mean, he absolutely is the difference in scoring 3, or 10 points vs 20+, amirite????

 

[broncosmitty]

With that OL, I'd give up too....man's gotta eat tomorrow.

It's hard to believe how awful they are.

Hiloti Ngata got a sack and he's about as quick as an elephant.

 

[broncosmitty]

What I took from last nights game was that the NFL needs to take MNF away from ESPN.

That'll be the only time all year I watch their pregame. It just continues to get more awful.

 

[jarntt]

So Beckham played and Eli still sucked?

Fake News...I read on here just last week that the Giants only lost because of OBJ week 1 and will be undefeated once his royal "heinous" returns...

 

[starbigd]

Fake News...I read on here just last week that the Giants only lost because of OBJ week 1 and will be undefeated once his royal "heinous" returns...

The most "important offensive player" in the league from what I was told

He supposedly means 20+ points a game according to this board

 

[chappee11]

Yeah


Just shut up, you're a fucking idiot

Damn! Paydirt still has that fastball!

 

[Iggloo]

Eli is scurred, and he is facing a veritable rogues gallery of defensive linemen in weeks to come--Fletcher Cox, Von Miller, Michael Bennett, Aaron Donald--time to eat!

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Take you advice and shove it up your ass. How many more Giants losses until you run and hide?

Yeah, me.....Says the guy that couldnt be found yesterday

 

[soxfan1468927]

no callers. just hosts.

and they were right too.

hard to put a guy like that in the hall. led the NFL in picks (over 20) 3 times. never led in TD's or anything meaningful. was never even considered the best QB in his division (unless by default) let alone of his time. STILL sub 60% completion.

barely above .500 (108-93)

83.7 rating

321 TD's
217 picks

yeah yeah he beat the pats twice. whoopedy doo. other side of the coin is how many 2 time SB MVP's arent in?

Rich was right on this, Toucher and Wallach were wrong. He's gonna get in.

Toucher also said that Ken Stabler isn't in the HOF.

 

[Rock Strongo]

Rich was right on this, Toucher and Wallach were wrong. He's gonna get in.

Toucher also said that Ken Stabler isn't in the HOF.

yeah i laughed at that.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Rich was right on this, Toucher and Wallach were wrong. He's gonna get in.

Toucher also said that Ken Stabler isn't in the HOF.

LMAO

Bawstun

 

[soxfan1468927]

LMAO

Bawstun

Toucher and Rich aren't from Boston

 

[megalodon30]

local radio had a long discussion about how he cant be a HOFer at this point.

They make it sound like he was ever in the HOF conversation to begin with.

 

[Yam]

What happened

I own rock. Nothing to see here.

 

[soxfan1468927]

They make it sound like he was ever in the HOF conversation to begin with.

He is...

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Toucher and Rich aren't from Boston

Doesnt matter, they all talk like fans up there, zero objectivity on sports, especially NY Sports

"Cant wait for Scott Zolaks' take on Tom Brady"

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Fake News...I read on here just last week that the Giants only lost because of OBJ week 1 and will be undefeated once his royal "heinous" returns...

Who said that?

How was the Cowboys SB parade last week?

 

[Rock Strongo]

They make it sound like he was ever in the HOF conversation to begin with.

no modern day QB should be allowed to even visit the HOF with a sub 60% completion rate.