Rodgers and Brady are the two best QBs of all time...

[purguy12]

Look Im not a Pats fan and I'm telling you this. Its not like Im being a Homer fan here. I actually don't like Brady because I hate Mich but I do respect his talent and he is great. Trust me I don't want him to Pass Montana but its looking like he is about to do that. A win here and We have 1A and 1B in my mind and another super trip he passes Montana.

 

[Oldschool739]

Either is anyone who golfs, half a fag imo

Is anything more g@y looking than a golf clap ??
It's a wimp game......

 

[packerzrule]

Will you stop it he has had some suck games and lost, like Seattle game where the defense picks off Wilson 4 times and all they get is FG's and up 16-0 and lose. Brady has had stinkers and lost games.

You remind me of the Peyton fanboys he won by himself and lost because of the teams

thanks for the reminder

 

[purguy12]

We agree to disagree, its all good. Look Both are QBs I wish my team had. Both are great but facts are he isn't in the Greatest of all time talk yet. I don't even think he has broke the Top 10 yet. Brady has. He is in the Top 3 right now.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

We agree to disagree, its all good. Look Both are QBs I wish my team had. Both are great but facts are he isn't in the Greatest of all time talk yet. I don't even think he has broke the Top 10 yet. Brady has. He is in the Top 3 right now.

Agree
To
Dis-agree

 

[purguy12]

I actually wanted Rodgers and Smith in the Superbowl. Then I could bash my front office for passing on a Great QB and a super bowl winning QB in Rodgers and traded away another super bowl QB in Smith. LOL

 

[Lions=TeHsUcKs]

Look Im not a Pats fan and I'm telling you this. Its not like Im being a Homer fan here. I actually don't like Brady because I hate Mich but I do respect his talent and he is great. Trust me I don't want him to Pass Montana but its looking like he is about to do that. A win here and We have 1A and 1B in my mind and another super trip he passes Montana.

I think he is already on par with Montana. He wins this year, Brady is the GOAT.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Agree
To
Dis-agree

You have my respect being in the 10% minority and still battling kudos

 

[packerzrule]

Is anything more g@y looking than a golf clap ??
It's a wimp game......

yeah, how wimpy

PGA Tour Money List Leaders - ESPN

 

[purguy12]

Agree
To
Dis-agree

Rodgers has time to advance his career. He is getting close to the Top 10. A super bowl win here gets him in the Top 10.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

You have my respect being in the 10% minority and still battling kudos

I'm a die hard Yankee fan that doesn't hold Jeter in the same regard as most

So I call it like I see it

 

[packerzrule]

I actually wanted Rodgers and Smith in the Superbowl. Then I could bash my front office for passing on a Great QB and a super bowl winning QB in Rodgers and traded away another super bowl QB in Smith. LOL

a 50th anniversary of the SB would have been classic

 

[sonnyblack65]

I'm a die hard Yankee fan that doesn't hold Jeter in the same regard as most

So I call it like I see it

Its all good but 1 last comment from me. You mention Belichick. He missed the playoffs the 2 years Brady didn't play, took over an 5-13 team and won SB that year and 2 more in 3 years. Now nobody considered Brady top 10, I know I didn't because it was more of the D. But guy has done it for so long and taken my team to his 11 AFCG in 15 years.

 

[purguy12]

I think he is already on par with Montana. He wins this year, Brady is the GOAT.

He might be. I have no argument here. In my mind a super bowl win gets him to 1A or 1B talk. Another trip after this he passes it. I just think being 4-0 in the super bowl is really impressive and the QBs he beat in those Super bowls, Marino(17-0), Elway, Boomer and Anderson(who was MVP that year).

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Its all good but 1 last comment from me. You mention Belichick. He missed the playoffs the 2 years Brady didn't play, took over an 5-13 team and won SB that year and 2 more in 3 years. Now nobody considered Brady top 10, I know I didn't because it was more of the D. But guys has done it for so long and taken my team to his 11 AFCG in 15 years.

He did win 11 games with Matt Cassell, to be fair, and 11 games and not getting into the postseason may never happen again in our lifetimes

Now about that Pasta Fagialo?

 

[sonnyblack65]

a 50th anniversary of the SB would have been classic

He might be. I have no argument here. In my mind a super bowl win gets him to 1A or 1B talk. Another trip after this he passes it. I just think being 4-0 in the super bowl is really impressive and the QBs he beat in those Super bowls, Marino(17-0), Elway, Boomer and Anderson(who was MVP that year).

I feel the same way and take no offense to someone saying Montana or Unitas are the GOAT. I actually always had Montana as no#1 until the last SB vs Seattle

 

[sonnyblack65]

He did win 11 games with Matt Cassell, to be fair, and 11 games and not getting into the postseason may never happen again in our lifetimes

Now about that Pasta Fagialo?

That's 7 less wins then the year before, throwing 29 less TDs. over 200 less points scored with a much easier schedule. Bad comparison my friend. Pasta Fagiolo sounds good

 

[purguy12]

I feel the same way and take no offense to someone saying Montana or Unitas are the GOAT. I actually always had Montana as no#1 until the last SB vs Seattle

The only negative on his resume is the L's in the super bowl and 1 Big loss in the super bowl being 18-0 and losing to a wildcard Giants team. But again. I have no argument with people that think he is above Montana. I can only give my reasons why i would pick Montana, and Pats fans and Brady fans can give their reasons and making it to 6 straight AFC championship games is a good one to start with.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

That's 7 less wins then the year before, throwing 29 less TDs. over 200 less points scored with a much easier schedule. Bad comparison my friend. Pasta Fagiolo sounds good

Its also more wins than they had the following year with Tom Brady

Just sayin

 

[purguy12]

All I know for a Fact Rodgers isn't there yet. He has a ways to go.