Is Aaron Rodgers Overrated?

[DJ]

Fucking stupid attention whoring thread. Of course, he isn't.

He and Brady are the 2 best QB's in the NFL.

 

[CowboyB]

Yes it is a dumb question. So, by your analysis, Eli Manning is a better QB than Aaron Rodgers because Eli has 2 SB rings, right?

And stop getting so emotional? You gotta be trolling now. You've been calling people names throughout this WHOLE thread because they disagree with you. Get the fuck outta here.

No, I never said Eli was better. I just said Rodgers should have won more.

I've tried to stick to only calling people names that call me names. I bet you think I called you names too... Don't ya??

 

[CowboyB]

Fucking stupid attention whoring thread. Of course, he isn't.

He and Brady are the 2 best QB's in the NFL.

When someone says this it proves me right.

Aaron Rodgers is no longer a top 2 QB.

 

[DJ]

He should probably be more concerned with the ass whooping his Cowboys received yesterday.

 

[DJ]

This thread wreaks of bitterness... So I'll just leave this here

 

[DJ]

Reading through the comments is always fun.

 

[CowboyB]

He should probably be more concerned with the ass whooping his Cowboys received yesterday.

I was not happy with the loss but the Broncos look really good on both sides of the ball.

The Cowboys are still 1-3 years from putting it all together.

 

[Yo Tee]

No, I never said Eli was better. I just said Rodgers should have won more.

I've tried to stick to only calling people names that call me names. I bet you think I called you names too... Don't ya??

All you've said is that Aaron Rodgers has only won 1 Super Bowl. You haven't provided any other facts to backup your opinion.

• Super Bowl champion (XLV)

• Super Bowl MVP (XLV)

• 2× NFL Most Valuable Player (2011, 2014)

• 6× Pro Bowl (2009, 2011, 2012, 2014–2016)

NFL records

• 104.1 passer rating, career
• 122.5 passer rating, season (2011)
• 4.13:1 touchdown-to-interception ratio, career

Those aren't accomplishments of an overrated QB.

 

[NEhomer]

Some of you are amazingly ignorant. Aaron Rodgers is playing without his two starting OTs, without his best WR, with a defense missing several starters, and he is the problem?

No, the problem, if you want to say there is one, is probably the front office, for not doing a better job building depth and talent on this team. Switch Rodgers and Ryan in this game--what do you think the score is?

Apparently, excuses land for any QB not wearing #12. That's not Brady ball washing because I have laid losses directly on Brady many times but it's uncanny how the Rodgers and Lucks of the NFL get a free pass.

 

[RP-29]

 

[DJ]

As someone who hates Rodgers simply because he has embarrassed the Vikings defense on multiple occasions, I can say that Rodgers is the greatest QB of my lifetime. If he had a Oline that was worth a damn, he would simply be untouchable.

Like say, the OL Brady has enjoyed throughout most of his career?

 

[Yo Tee]

When someone says this it proves me right.

Aaron Rodgers is no longer a top 2 QB.

I was not happy with the loss but the Broncos look really good on both sides of the ball.

The Cowboys are still 1-3 years from putting it all together.

When someone says this, it proves their team still sucks.

 

[CowboyB]

When someone says this, it proves their team still sucks.

Your entitled to that opinion but you're not going to get me to have grand expectations for a 2nd year QB.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Apparently, excuses land for any QB not wearing #12. That's not Brady ball washing because I have laid losses directly on Brady many times but it's uncanny how the Rodgers and Lucks of the NFL get a free pass.

LMAO

The balls

 

[Yo Tee]

Your entitled to that opinion but you're not going to get me to have grand expectations for a 2nd year QB.

Did you have grand expectations for a rookie QB last year?

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Your entitled to that opinion but you're not going to get me to have grand expectations for a 2nd year QB.

He does need to prove he can win when all else fails

He has not been able to do that, but he will, I think he has a solid future

 

[Yo Tee]

Apparently, excuses land for any QB not wearing #12. That's not Brady ball washing because I have laid losses directly on Brady many times but it's uncanny how the Rodgers and Lucks of the NFL get a free pass.

How does Andrew Luck get added in this? Dude is made of freaking glass. He'll never be the same QB. Put him on the same shelf with RG3.

 

[gkekoa]

For a long time Aaron Rodgers has been labeled as elite but in reality, he has only won 1 Super Bowl and that was with the 2nd best defense in the league and while having many really good to great weapons at wide receiver.

Lately, Rogers has been falling flat on his face and has averaged only 9.5 wins over the last 4 years.

With all of the QB's who have won more than 1 SB you'd think Aaron Rogers would have if he weren't so overrated.

Damn I hate agreeing with you. You would also think he would have been to more. There are certain attributes he has that are truly elite but I think he lacks certain mental parts to the game.

I suggest you look at most QBs who win the SB. They usually have a top defense. BRady has had the 1 or 2 scoring defense in three of his SBs and never lower than six I believe.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Damn I hate agreeing with you. You would also think he would have been to more. There are certain attributes he has that are truly elite but I think he lacks certain mental parts to the game.

I suggest you look at most QBs who win the SB. They usually have a top defense. BRady has had the 1 or 2 scoring defense in three of his SBs and never lower than six I believe.

So youre not really agreeing? The Packers have had a Saints like defense through most of Rodgers career, not to mention a mostly absent running game, and some awful Olines

Now we can call those excuses, but in order to do so, just tell me the QB's that have won Super Bowls while dealing with the same

 

[Yo Tee]

For a long time Aaron Rodgers has been labeled as elite but in reality, he has only won 1 Super Bowl and that was with the 2nd best defense in the league and while having many really good to great weapons at wide receiver.

Lately, Rogers has been falling flat on his face and has averaged only 9.5 wins over the last 4 years.

With all of the QB's who have won more than 1 SB you'd think Aaron Rogers would have if he weren't so overrated.

Rodgers has been falling flat with only 9.5 wins in the last 4 years? Have you actually done any statistical research before you posted this stupid ass thread? 8, 12, 10 and 10. That's 40 wins in 4 years. That's an average of 10 wins per season. I also like how you failed to include the 2 years prior where he won 10 and 15. He's averaging 10.83 wins in the last 6 years. In Brett Favre's last 6 years with Green Bay, he averaged 9.5 wins. Also, to use your guy, Matt Ryan, as the BEST QB in the league...He's averaged 8.6 wins in the last 6 years. Tom Brady has averaged 12.5 wins in the last 6 years. Rodgers should have more than 1 SB but that doesn't make him overrated.