Is Aaron Rodgers Overrated?

[NWPATSFAN]

I wouldn't consi. r him overrated but he does need to win some more superbowls. he came out hot and now has kind of cooled off as of late

Super Bowls? How about we start with playoff games. Now I'll give him a little credit based on Mike McMuffins play calling. Regardless AR is still a very good QB. Over rated based solely on the 1000s of @Great Dayne posts telling us how great he is.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Super Bowls are a team accomplishment

At least that what I'm told when someone brings up Eli Mannings 2 rings

 

[NEhomer]

Super Bowls are a team accomplishment

At least that what I'm told when someone brings up Eli Mannings 2 rings

On the contrary, those two SB wins are all Eli gets credit for.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

On the contrary, those two SB wins are all Eli gets credit for.

Not here

And here is where we are

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Super Bowls are a team accomplishment

At least that what I'm told when someone brings up Eli Mannings 2 rings

No most people call that luck

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

No most people call that luck

Most people where you live

We understand

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Most people where you live

We understand

Hee and I didn't think Seattlelites cared about anything.

 

[CowboyB]

There is no way in hell you could ever keep up in an intellectual conversation with anybody here. Because of that I'm not going to have any kind of discussion about it with you.

Here is some free advice, step by step, so even a dimwit like you can understand.

1) Cross your arms in front of your chest and grab your ears
2) Pull on your ears with an extreme and sudden force
3) Wipe all of the shit off your head and face from having it stuck up your ass.

Good luck.

It's funny how in your long winded whiny rant all you did was prove you're a whiny bitch incapable of having an intellectual conversation.

BTW - sports are Is not an intellectual topic.

As you can see my simple questions sent you into an emotional tirade.

 

[CowboyB]

Best QB in the game, surrounded by generally an inferior cast of talent and coaching. When that cast starts getting injured, it only compounds the issue - a one-man team isn't gonna be lifting lombardis. I'll keep watching his already HOF-bound career because of how good he truly is.

Here is proof he is overrated.

Aaron Rodgers is not the best QB in the game.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Here is proof he is overrated.

Aaron Rodgers is not the best QB in the game.

Who is?

 

[CowboyB]

Who is?

Right now it's pretty clear Matt Ryan is the best.

 

[Yo Tee]

Clearly, even A -Rodge feels like he has something to prove as he is still trying now like a dumbass.

Or he is just not happy with just 1 Super Bowl ring. I'd imagine that winning a Super Bowl is like a tattoo. Once you get one, you keep wanting more.

 

[Yo Tee]

Right now it's pretty clear Matt Ryan is the best.

Wait....How is Matt Ryan the best QB in the game?

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Right now it's pretty clear Matt Ryan is the best.

Regular season, I can't argue, but he is surrounded by more than any QB in football

I'll never be able to shake off the choke

 

[jeffro151]

As someone who hates Rodgers simply because he has embarrassed the Vikings defense on multiple occasions, I can say that Rodgers is the greatest QB of my lifetime. If he had a Oline that was worth a damn, he would simply be untouchable.

 

[CowboyB]

In 2014 when the packers lost to the Seahawks by 1 score in the playoffs and Rodgers threw 2 interceptions, who's fault was that?

In 2015 when the packers lost to the Cardinals by 1 score in the playoffs and threw an interception, whose fault was that?

 

[CowboyB]

As someone who hates Rodgers simply because he has embarrassed the Vikings defense on multiple occasions, I can say that Rodgers is the greatest QB of my lifetime. If he had a Oline that was worth a damn, he would simply be untouchable.

Yeah but you're clearly dumb since Peyton and Brady has played in your lifetime.

 

[CowboyB]

Regular season, I can't argue, but he is surrounded by more than any QB in football

I'll never be able to shake off the choke

That choke is on the coaching staff.

Aaron Rodgers has lost with more.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

In 2014 when the packers lost to the Seahawks by 1 score in the playoffs and Rodgers threw 2 interceptions, who's fault was that?

In 2015 when the packers lost to the Cardinals by 1 score in the playoffs and threw an interception, whose fault was that?

Obviously in Seattle it was the onside kick

In Arizona, Jeff Janis was his number one and he still sent it to OT

My opinion is that there are excuses and than there are reasons

Having Jeff Janis as your best option is more of a reason a QB could struggle than an excuse in my humble opinion

 

[CowboyB]

Or he is just not happy with just 1 Super Bowl ring. I'd imagine that winning a Super Bowl is like a tattoo. Once you get one, you keep wanting more.

They were down by like 40 points and that dumbass was still going No huddle.

He clearly knows he has more to prove.