POLL Toughest P5 Division?

[Across The Field]

People are entitled to their opinion. It can be wrong but everyone can have one. SEC West has been the best division for a while now.

It wasn't two years ago.

 

[ericd7633]

It wasn't two years ago.

Lol. Yes it was.

 

[Across The Field]

Lol. Yes it was.

Nope.

And there's a very good chance the B1G East is better again this year. It's pretty much just these two divisions duking it out at this point.

 

[ericd7633]

Nope.

And there's a very good chance the B1G East is better again this year. It's pretty much just these two divisions duking it out at this point.

Wait you're trying to say the B1G East was better than the SEC West in 2014?

 

[Across The Field]

Wait you're trying to say the B1G East was better than the SEC West in 2014?

National champs plus another top 5 team, not to mention the B1G East champ beating the SEC West champ in the heart of SEC country. Did the SEC West have that?

 

[ericd7633]

National champs plus another top 5 team, not to mention the B1G East champ beating the SEC West champ in the heart of SEC country. Did the SEC West have that?

The B1G East in 2014 is what the ACC Atlantic was in 2013. One great team, another elite team and a bunch of garbage. You certainly wouldn't say the ACC Atlantic was the best division in 2013, would you? No.

 

[rmilia1]

Based on last year....

1. SEC WEST

2. BIG 10 EAST
3. P12 NORTH

4. ACC COASTAL
5. BIG 10 WEST
6. ACC ATLANTIC

7. P12 SOUTH

8. SEC EAST

The SEC WEST is 1 by far. The next 2 are close but I'll go B10E because of more depth at top. After that the next 3 are all pretty similar. The last 2 were pretty bad but the SEC EAST was horrendous by year end

 

[Innermind]

The division which plays against the most FCS opponents should get the top spot.

 

[HuskerinBig10]

Toughest Conference Division SEC West
Pillow Fight Conference Division ACC Coastal


Tossup for me, B1G East or SEC West.

Since the B1G has a possible worst division and the SEC doesn't, SEC will have tougher cross division games.

As for the worst
B1G West or ACC Coastal

I am biased here, since the ACC Coastal went 2-3 in their bowl games, with only one win against a P5 and the B1G West went 3-2 in their bowl games with 2 wins against P5, ACC Coastal is the worst. Not to mention that both cheating schools Miami and North Carolina are in the ACC Coastal.

 

[Across The Field]

The B1G East in 2014 is what the ACC Atlantic was in 2013. One great team, another elite team and a bunch of garbage. You certainly wouldn't say the ACC Atlantic was the best division in 2013, would you? No.

And in 2014 the SEC West was one elite team in Alabama and then a bunch of overrated shit that was beaten in their bowl games, several by blowouts (except for Arkansas who beat an even shittier Texas team). Not impressive at all. B1G East was simply better.

 

[ericd7633]

And in 2014 the SEC West was one elite team in Alabama and then a bunch of overrated shit that was beaten in their bowl games, several by blowouts (except for Arkansas who beat an even shittier Texas team). Not impressive at all. B1G East was simply better.

How can they be overrated when they went undefeated in OOC play? Maybe they were rated high because they didn't lose? What a concept. So, I guess you're okay with calling the 2013 ACC Atlantic the best division?

 

[Across The Field]

How can they be overrated when they went undefeated in OOC play? Maybe they were rated high because they didn't lose? What a concept. So, I guess you're okay with calling the 2013 ACC Atlantic the best division?

I saw them all get beaten in bowl season, something that many people have held against the B1G in the past. I know you're biased against the B1G in general, but come on already.

 

[rmilia1]

Toughest Conference Division SEC West
Pillow Fight Conference Division ACC Coastal


Tossup for me, B1G East or SEC West.

Since the B1G has a possible worst division and the SEC doesn't, SEC will have tougher cross division games.

As for the worst
B1G West or ACC Coastal

I am biased here, since the ACC Coastal went 2-3 in their bowl games, with only one win against a P5 and the B1G West went 3-2 in their bowl games with 2 wins against P5, ACC Coastal is the worst. Not to mention that both cheating schools Miami and North Carolina are in the ACC Coastal.

The SEC EAST was atrocious. By years end Tennessee was the only decent team in the entire division.

 

[ericd7633]

I saw them all get beaten in bowl season, something that many people have held against the B1G in the past. I know you're biased against the B1G in general, but come on already.

lol. Yes I'm biased saying that the SEC West was the best division in 2014, when everyone else would agree with me. You can call me biased, but I just think you're a B1G homer.

 

[Across The Field]

lol. Yes I'm biased saying that the SEC West was the best division in 2014, when everyone else would agree with me. You can call me biased, but I just think you're a B1G homer.

Forgive me for not fawning over a bunch of teams that "beat each other up" in the regular season only to get beat down in bowl season, mostly as the favorite in those matchups as well. At the end of the season, when it matters, they simply didn't measure up. Simple as that.

 

[4down20]

@ Big10 dumbasses.

Your conference has been the joke of college football for years.

 

[KingKoolKat75]

@ Big10 dumbasses.

Your conference has been the joke of college football for years.

If Alabama played half as hard as you talk they might have made a game of it against Ohio State.

 

[Across The Field]

@ Big10 dumbasses.

Your conference has been the joke of college football for years.

This isn't even remotely accurate. If having 6 teams ranked, including 4 in the top 11, is a joke, then the rest of college football outside of the SEC is a tragedy.

 

[4down20]

If Alabama played half as hard as you talk they might have made a game of it against Ohio State.

That you hold onto a single game pretty much makes my case.

 

[4down20]

This isn't even remotely accurate. If having 6 teams ranked, including 4 in the top 11, is a joke, then the rest of college football outside of the SEC is a tragedy.

Hyped up on easy schedules.