Is Philip Rivers currently the best QB in the NFL?

[Lemon Harang Pie]

No.

 

[LooseChange]

No.

 

[TDs3nOut]

I guess being only QB that has 3 5k seasons and setting the most games with a td record ( Brady 2nd) is pedestrian, I'll take it

Pretty sure that the thread title includes the word "current". Doesn't that mean that we're only talking about this week's games?

 

[HammerDown]

I guess being only QB that has 3 5k seasons and setting the most games with a td record ( Brady 2nd) is pedestrian, I'll take it

Translation: Brady GOAT

Good morning, Sonny.

 

[flyerhawk]

Certainly one of the most talented QBs of the last 10 years but his consistency has been the one thing that has prevented him from being a truly elite QB.

 

[Wazmankg]

We're basing this on 2 games ? I think I'm having a disney flashback. There were several bolts fans that were always swinging from his nuts over there. He's marginally better Tony Romo until he proves otherwise.

 

[HammerDown]

We're basing this on 2 games ? I think I'm having a disney flashback. There were several bolts fans that were always swinging from his nuts over there. He's marginally better Tony Romo until he proves otherwise.

Your act is getting very old, Waz. I keep telling you, you're nearing your expiration date here.

 

[Dolemite censored]

No.

Even Mike Vick had a lights out game against the Redskins a few years back and everyone thought he could walk on water. They were barking up the wrong tree then, and they are barking up the wrong tree now with Rivers.

That dog won't hunt.

 

[gandydancer]

Cool you take them and I'll take Brady,Rodgers and Brees

You take Brady I get Brees and Rodgers

 

[gandydancer]

Translation: Brady GOAT

Good morning, Sonny.

Hammer always good at reading between the lines.

Brady will be retired 3 years and still be mentioned as current elite

 

[Wazmankg]

Your act is getting very old, Waz. I keep telling you, you're nearing your expiration date here.

Honestly Hammer aside from the ad thing which I immediately fixed as you asked I don't recall you warning me about anything, ever. I think Rivers has always been overrated by Bolts fans. Is that some sort of TOS violation ? It's your world, obviously, but you could at least give me the courtesy of letting me know where the lines are and how I've run afoul here.

 

[Clayton]

We're basing this on 2 games ?

And last year. Remember at the beginning of last year when everyone wrote off the Chargers because their entire WR corp got injured and they didnt have a defense? They still made the playoffs and that because Rivers played really well throughout the year.

His body of work is pretty inconsistent but Im not sure Id take any other QB in one playoff game right now. Maybe Big Ben.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

We're basing this on 2 games ? I think I'm having a disney flashback. There were several bolts fans that were always swinging from his nuts over there. He's marginally better Tony Romo until he proves otherwise.

Your act is getting very old, Waz. I keep telling you, you're nearing your expiration date here.

Honestly this post by wazmankg is pretty accurate. Not sure what the offense here would be?

 

[Clayton]

Honestly this post by wazmankg is pretty accurate.

It completely ignores an entire year of football but yeah...accurate

 

[flyerhawk]

Like I said I think that Rivers has elite talent but not elite consistency. But man was he good last Sunday. This article shows how good he really was, although with Gates...

FOOTBALL OUTSIDERS: Innovative Statistics, Intelligent Analysis | Film Room: Philip Rivers

 

[flyerhawk]

Regardless of its accuracy, I don't see how it was any different than just about every other post here.

 

[sonnyblack65]

You take Brady I get Brees and Rodgers

I'm good with that but Rodgers has more shelf life left. Brady only has about 3 more years, but 3 AFCG games in a row and 8 in 12 years not too shabby

 

[sonnyblack65]

Pretty sure that the thread title includes the word "current". Doesn't that mean that we're only talking about this week's games?

Miss your point talking about current QB's playing ?

 

[HammerDown]

Hammer always good at reading between the lines.

Brady will be hanging out in gay clubs in Hollywood and still be mentioned as current elite

 

[sonnyblack65]

Translation: Brady GOAT

Good morning, Sonny.

Morning/Afternoon my friend Hammer no Brady isnt GOAT that belongs to Montana. If Brady's team won the SB last 2 times then he would have been