I wouldn't vote for the guy, but he does belong in the hall of very good imo
I'm not entirely sure if I'd vote for him, but I think he's easily among the best players outside of Cooperstown (at least among those non-eligible) and better than a decent portion of those in the HOF.
Regardless, he should have lasted a lot longer on the ballot. Especially when guys like Jack freaking Morris are still on the ballot.