Which side of the deal would you rather have?

[Hambombs]

Team 1 - Andre Ellington, Ray rice

Team 2 - Alfred morris, Trent Richardson


Help. Thanks

 

[fordman84]

much rather be getting the Team 1 players.

 

[SteelersPride]

team 2 for me, i think rice is done, and ellington is hurt and fragile

morris gets his, and richardson, well hes gonna get work in high powered offense lots of oppurtunity

 

[fordman84]

team 2 for me, i think rice is done, and ellington is hurt and fragile

morris gets his, and richardson, well hes gonna get work in high powered offense lots of oppurtunity

While I think morris will get touches, he won't be as good as Rice is since Rice has teh better Oline. Richardson is nothing. I would never trust having him in my lineup. Had him last year when he was supposed to have many more chances in Indy and he never did a thing.

 

[SteelersPride]

While I think morris will get touches, he won't be as good as Rice is since Rice has teh better Oline. Richardson is nothing. I would never trust having him in my lineup. Had him last year when he was supposed to have many more chances in Indy and he never did a thing.

rice line was horrible last year.........not much upgrade there........

no he didnt, but hes gonna play but rice still has to worry about pierce too

 

[Hambombs]

Lol so 1 or 2?

 

[fordman84]

Lol so 1 or 2?

LOL, well at least you got some reasoning for both teams

 

[SteelersPride]

thats the beauty about the beginning of the season. two people can have completely valid reasons for two different sides.....
i see fordmans logic, although i disagree...........

maybe wait and get some more input.......i posted in the who should i start part "pick 3" gimme some help guys

 

[TREFF]

Geesh... that's an all star lineup of RB's I want no part of. I guess I'd rather have the Ellington side only because he is the one in the bunch who I feel can be better than he has been

 

[Hambombs]

Geesh... that's an all star lineup of RB's I want no part of. I guess I'd rather have the Ellington side only because he is the one in the bunch who I feel can be better than he has been

Who rice and ellington? LOl

 

[TREFF]

Who rice and ellington? LOl

Truthfully I don't want any of the four, but yea if I have to I want the side which includes Ellington

 

[Hambombs]

Truthfully I don't want any of the four, but yea if I have to I want the side which includes Ellington

Not a morris fan?

 

[TREFF]

Not a morris fan?

Helu is a superior back in every way except getting three yards and falling down..how he's the "backup" is beyond me

 

[Hambombs]

Helu is a superior back in every way except getting three yards and falling down..how he's the "backup" is beyond me

Most sites have morris>Ellington

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I would go with team 2 , health wise Ellington is a gamble, same with a Rice. Give me the guys that will stay healthy, even if they got less talent.

 

[TREFF]

Most sites have morris>Ellington

I have 'em " = "..lol don't want either of them..but that ranking on most sites could be because Ellington is questionable to even play, let alone be %100 if he does play. All things being equal and Healthy, I'd start Ellington over Alf every week, except the two weeks he plays Seattle

Joking aside though, with Ellington there's potential to be better than he was last year, Alfred Morris is exactly what he is, a younger BJGE, nothing more, never will be more. Some games that might be better than Ellington, but over the course of the year, I highly doubt it

 

[Hambombs]

I guess Ellington is the best in the deal but it's to risky now