Trivia!!!!

[shopson67]

Much smaller sample size makes him look better than he is. If he had as many playoff starts as Brady, that number would be lower.

Are you so sure? That would mean he was playing well enough to get to the playoffs more often, even if that means his team of better players is dragging him there.

 

[rmilia1]

Bart Starr at number 1 overall was surprising. Kurt Warner At 2 was not

 

[Judge Fudge]

1. Matt Ryan
2. Drew Brees
3. Aaron Rodgers
4. Alex Smith
5. Mark Sanchez

That's your list

That still suprises me

 

[jarntt]

No cheating you cheating fucks!!!

List the top 5 active QBs in the NFL by their playoff QB rating. Minimum 5 starts

If anyone gets all 5 without cheating I'll be shocked. List in order

Not sure, but if you posted it Ryan has gotta be right up there. As a Cowboy fan I'll say Dak because I know he was over 100 for his one game. I think Romo is in the high 90s. I doubt that can make top 5. Foles was really good so I'll say him. I guess you have to throw Brady in there. Can't think of another guy. I know Flacco and Big Ben had some stinkers so doubt it's them. I'll guess Russell Wilson, but no clue.

Bigger guess is the order:
Foles
Ryan
Brady
RW
Dak

 

[rmilia1]

Not sure, but if you posted it Ryan has gotta be right up there. As a Cowboy fan I'll say Dak because I know he was over 100 for his one game. I think Romo is in the high 90s. I doubt that can make top 5. Foles was really good so I'll say him. I guess you have to throw Brady in there. Can't think of another guy. I know Flacco and Big Ben had some stinkers so doubt it's them. I'll guess Russell Wilson, but no clue.

Bigger guess is the order:
Foles
Ryan
Brady
RW
Dak

Minimum 5 starts

 

[rmilia1]

Not sure, but if you posted it Ryan has gotta be right up there. As a Cowboy fan I'll say Dak because I know he was over 100 for his one game. I think Romo is in the high 90s. I doubt that can make top 5. Foles was really good so I'll say him. I guess you have to throw Brady in there. Can't think of another guy. I know Flacco and Big Ben had some stinkers so doubt it's them. I'll guess Russell Wilson, but no clue.

Bigger guess is the order:
Foles
Ryan
Brady
RW
Dak

I actually looked it up because of the Ben VS Eli thread lol. But as it turns out you are still right on Ryan

 

[packfancjh]

1. Matt Ryan
2. Drew Brees
3. Aaron Rodgers
4. Alex Smith
5. Mark Sanchez

That's your list

Is Sanchez currently on an active roster? I don't think he is

 

[rmilia1]

Is Sanchez currently on an active roster? I don't think he is

The site had him listed as active

 

[packfancjh]

The site had him listed as active

I think he was on Chicago's roster last year but they don't have him listed anymore and I think his contract with them ended at the end of the 2017 season

 

[rmilia1]

I think he was on Chicago's roster last year but they don't have him listed anymore and I think his contract with them ended at the end of the 2017 season

Could be. I think by a give they probably just mean not retired but not sure

 

[iowajerms]

No cheating you cheating fucks!!!

List the top 5 active QBs in the NFL by their playoff QB rating. Minimum 5 starts

If anyone gets all 5 without cheating I'll be shocked. List in order

My logic is too many starts will backfire. So those that have been in NFL forever and are on team(s) that consistently make playoffs won't be on.

Eli Manning - seems like every time they make playoff, they win SB.

Russell Wilson - almost reaching too many playoff games.

Matt Ryan - he tends to play good in the playoffs, even when they lose.

Alex Smith - he wasn't the reason SF lost any of the games he started.

Tom Brady - I can't think of a 5th one.

 

[rmilia1]

My logic is too many starts will backfire. So those that have been in NFL forever and are on team(s) that consistently make playoffs won't be on.

Eli Manning - seems like every time they make playoff, they win SB.

Russell Wilson - almost reaching too many playoff games.

Matt Ryan - he tends to play good in the playoffs, even when they lose.

Alex Smith - he wasn't the reason SF lost any of the games he started.

Tom Brady - I can't think of a 5th one.

2 for 5

 

[megalodon30]

Eli Manning - seems like every time they make playoff, they win SB.

Only twice. They've made the playoffs 4 other times with Eli and they were one and done each time. He has a 52.7 QB rating in those four games. Definitely not top 5.

Tom Brady - I can't think of a 5th one.

The 5th one is hard to think of because he only ever made the playoffs with the Jets.