Trade advice need it quick got a half hour to decide.

[The Foot]

Team A gets:

Aaron Rodgers
Kyle Rudolph

Team B get:

Gronk
Aldon Smith

Which side wins!?

 

[RobBase]

Team A gets:

Aaron Rodgers
Kyle Rudolph

Team B get:

Gronk
Aldon Smith

Which side wins!?

A obviously. Is this a keeper?

 

[The Foot]

yes

 

[The Foot]

oh and Team B gets Tannehill too!

 

[Sox33OSU]

Team A and it's really not close. Gronk still isn't healthy, Aldon Smith is in rehab and Tanny is no Rodgers.

 

[RobBase]

I have Gronk in my keeper and wouldn't trade him, but having Rogers would be nice. That's a tough one being a keeper. All the best teams in my league have stud QB's.

I wouldn't trade away Rogers if you are team A. If you're team B, do it.

 

[The Foot]

base would u trade gronk for rodgers?

 

[TREFF]

A.. without a doubt.
If team B is getting THill.. you've gotta be B right? Can't see you dealing Thill away, although it's equally surprising that you wouldn't own him already. ...hmm

Regardless, team A wins. . If all we're looking at is those players and not the entire rosters.

 

[geneh_33]

Team A.

I wouldn't trade anyone but maybe Andrian Petersen for Rodgers. Rodgers is an ace in the hole. If you trade him you're crazy and if GB ever trades him a lynch mob will commit mass murder within 5 minutes of the press conference.

 

[The Foot]

yea Treff Im team B I will be getting Rodgers in this deal. I have kaeps too and Gates who has been awesome. I have peterson so if i do this i will be pairing AP with Rodgers but the Oline scares me a little. Still I think Rodgers will out do Kaeps and gronk is no gaurentee to stay healthy. So I am leaning towards Rodgers.

 

[Sox33OSU]

yea Treff Im team B I will be getting Rodgers in this deal. I have kaeps too and Gates who has been awesome. I have peterson so if i do this i will be pairing AP with Rodgers but the Oline scares me a little. Still I think Rodgers will out do Kaeps and gronk is no gaurentee to stay healthy. So I am leaning towards Rodgers.

I thought you said team A gets Rodgers?

 

[The Foot]

id be giving team b and getting team A

 

[The Foot]

id give Tannehill, Smith and Gronk for Radgers and Rudolph

 

[Chef99]

yea Treff Im team B I will be getting Rodgers in this deal. I have kaeps too and Gates who has been awesome. I have peterson so if i do this i will be pairing AP with Rodgers but the Oline scares me a little. Still I think Rodgers will out do Kaeps and gronk is no gaurentee to stay healthy. So I am leaning towards Rodgers.

I'm confused...you're getting or giving Rodgers?

 

[Sox33OSU]

id be giving team b and getting team A

id give Tannehill, Smith and Gronk for Radgers and Rudolph

Dude, pull the trigger. I'd do this as soon as possible lest he changes his mind.

 

[Chef99]

Dude, pull the trigger. I'd do this as soon as possible lest he changes his mind.

 

[geneh_33]

Dude, pull the trigger. I'd do this as soon as possible lest he changes his mind.

No doubt. Aaron Rodgers can win you a championship all by himself! Do it already dude!

 

[redseat]

Team A gets:

Aaron Rodgers
Kyle Rudolph

Team B get:

Gronk
Aldon Smith

Which side wins!?

Team A

Gronk can't stay on the field and has yet to play and who knows how well and when he will play... Smith is gone and is in trouble..... Rodgers alone is better than those two

 

[The Foot]

It's a done Deal. I just traded away Gronk, Tannehill, and Aldon Smith for Aaron Rodgers and Kyle Rudolph!

 

[The Foot]

Thanks Guys for the push I needed. I am happy to have Rodgers and happy to have cool guys like you to bounce these ideas off of. Thanks!