Top NJ/NY Defensemen

[DevilishWon]

Where's Wade Redden?


Potvin at #1. That had to piss some people off. Legit pick, but the Rangers and Devils will disagree.

I have no problem with that. Only diff I would have nade would be to put Nieds ahead of Leetch. IMO Potvin is in the Larry Robinson level.

Of course he gets extra credit in my book for the hate he still generates from rag$ fans...the enemy of my enemy and all that.

 

[DevilishWon]

I can't argue with that list. I just can't believe they rated Daneyko 6th. All 4 of the guys behind him on the list were better defenseman.

Ken Morrow 4 Stanley Cups & an Olympic Gold Medalist from 1980 & he's 9th? BLASPHEMY!!

I think you're just bitter that they left Richie Pilon off the list.

 

[DaBoltsNIsles]

I think you're just bitter that they left Richie Pilon off the list.

Pilon has no business being on the list.

So you think Daneyko belongs at 6th because of longevity? He didn't even average 17:30 of ice time during his career & had 2519 PIM's. He's not in the same class as the guys behind him on the list. Daneyko was a goon more than anything else.

 

[dash]

Dale Rolfe was a top Rangers defenseman...

/Well, he tops the list at getting pummeled by Dave Schultz.

 

[sbb122]

Dale Rolfe was a top Rangers defenseman...

/Well, he tops the list at getting pummeled by Dave Schultz.

Is that the vid where Schultz pulls Rolfe's hair?


/20 seconds in...

 

[dash]

Is that the vid where Schultz pulls Rolfe's hair?

It could be - Don't tell me Schultz pulled a Kunitz (lol)

/Edit - Schultz did grab a mittful didn't he.

 

[sbb122]

It could be - Don't tell me Schultz pulled a Kunitz (lol)

/Edit - Schultz did grab a mittful didn't he.

He was just trying to regain his balance...

 

[DevilishWon]

Pilon has no business being on the list.

So you think Daneyko belongs at 6th because of longevity? He didn't even average 17:30 of ice time during his career & had 2519 PIM's. He's not in the same class as the guys behind him on the list. Daneyko was a goon more than anything else.

Not only bitter, but apprently unable to recognize obvious sarcasm.....

 

[DaBoltsNIsles]

Not only bitter, but apprently unable to recognize obvious sarcasm.....

I'm not bitter at all. I just don't think Daneyko belongs at 6th on the list.