Top 10 CFB QBs entering 2013

[WhiteMamba]

So I am going off of their college game. Not their potential at the next level.

1 Johnny Football Texas A&M
2 Tajh Boyd Clemson
3 Teddy Bridgewater Louisville
4 Marcus Super Mario-TA Oregon
5 Braxton Miller Ohio State
6 AJ McCarron Alabama
7 Aaron Murray Georgia
8 Brett Hundley UCLA
9 Taylor Martinez Nebraska
10 Kevin Hogan Stanford

HM: David Fales San Jose ST, Derrick Carr Fresno, Joe Southwick Boise, Devin Gardner Michigan, Connor Shaw South Carolina, Logan Thomas VA Tech, Chuckie Keaton Utah ST, Jordan Lynch N. Illionois, Keith Price Washington, Bryn Renner North Carolina, Casey Pachall TCU, Jeff Driskell Florida, Zack Mettenburger LSU,Cody Fajardo Nevada, Taylor Kelly Arizona State.

Thoughts... Whatch yall got?

Sorry if this is a

 

[757Hokie83]

Logan Thomas is iffy...if we get 2011 Logan Thomas, he will be one of the top QBs....if we get 2012 Logan Thomas....ehhhh not so much

 

[TonyTheGator]

I think Braxton Miller is sooooo over-rated, and even though I hate the Dawgs, Murray should be at #3, at least.

 

[iruletheskool]

Murray, Bridgewater, Martinez, and Miller are Co-1's for me

 

[rolltide14_0]

The rest of them deserve to be ahead of AJ, because they combine good arms with good running ability, but don't you fucking put Braxton Miller ahead of him.

 

[WhiteMamba]

Murray, Bridgewater, Martinez, and Miller are Co-1's for me

But the reigning Heisman winner is not one of you co #1s?

Explain

 

[Brasky]

I think Braxton Miller is sooooo over-rated, and even though I hate the Dawgs, Murray should be at #3, at least.

 

[WhiteMamba]

The rest of them deserve to be ahead of AJ, because they combine good arms with good running ability, but don't you fucking put Braxton Miller ahead of him.

Well as far as a Pro I am sure McCarron will make a hell of an NFL QB.

But how I see it is if you take McCarron off of Bama they still have minimum 10 wins (probably more).

Not convinced that is the case with Ohio State and Miller.

 

[rolltide14_0]

1. Bridgewater
2. Manziel
3. Tahj Boyd
4. AJ
5. Murray

 

[WhiteMamba]

1. Bridgewater
2. Manziel
3. Tahj Boyd
4. AJ
5. Murray

All guys from the South... Hmm Ok

 

[Brasky]

I wonder how this list would look if you went off of career production.

 

[rolltide14_0]

Well as far as a Pro I am sure McCarron will make a hell of an NFL QB.

But how I see it is if you take McCarron off of Bama they still have minimum 10 wins (probably more).

Not convinced that is the case with Ohio State and Miller.

Miller is a good runner with a mediocre arm, I'm sure Ohio st. can find plenty of guys like that.

We're all entitled to our opinions though, I just don't put Miller in the same group with those other duel-threats.

 

[WhiteMamba]

I wonder how this list would look if you went off of career production.

top 5 in no order

Johnny
Boyd
Martinez
Super Mario-TA
Hundley

 

[Brasky]

Taylor Martinez is the 4th player in FBS history with 6,000 pass yards and 2,500 rush yards before his senior season. Who are the other three?

 

[WhiteMamba]

Mario-TA had better numbers than Johnny per minute played. But Oregon was winning by such a large margin in 9 games that he didnt play in 4th qrtr. Played after halftime in only 8 games.

System thing? Maybe. But he seems to be the best the Ducks have had since the Bellotti era

 

[rolltide14_0]

All guys from the South... Hmm Ok

Lol...you think I intentionally put all Southern guys in there?

 

[Brasky]

top 5 in no order

Johnny
Boyd
Martinez
Super Mario-TA
Hundley

...Hundley and Mariota have only played one season a piece, no?

 

[TonyTheGator]

Miller is a good runner with a mediocre arm, I'm sure Ohio st. can find plenty of guys like that.

We're all entitled to our opinions though, I just don't put Miller in the same group with those other duel-threats.

Agree, COMPLETELY, with this statement.

 

[Brasky]

Taylor Martinez is the 4th player in FBS history with 6,000 pass yards and 2,500 rush yards before his senior season. Who are the other three?

I'll answer it for you:

-Vince Young

-Colin Kaepernick

-Tim Tebow

 

[iruletheskool]

But the reigning Heisman winner is not one of you co #1s?

Explain

I don't like TAMU's team next year, and think he'll lose to many games.. also he seems like an arrogant douche, so he'll probly have a sophomore slump