The SportsHoopla WR Rankings: Pt. 3

[MHSL82]

The best WR in the league is A.J. Green.

Same concept as the QB Rankings.

Assume each WR is paid the same, has a QB who fits the system he plays best in, and that age is only a factor in production - NOT in length of career.

Example: Don't vote for a younger guy than Larry Fitzgerald because Fitzgerald has a few years left only and the younger guy may have more years. DO vote for the younger guy if you think his skills are better THIS year or is a better WR at this stage. Got it?

I don't know WRs as well as QBs, so I'm guessing on who is in the discussion - but am putting the maximum options out there because I'm not that familiar. I realize this first poll isn't likely to be more than a three or four man race. I think I know who's going to win, but can't be sure.

I am not sure how far this series will go, but it will not be the full 32. Please give your real opinion. Thanks.

 

[BloodType49]

B. Marshall

 

[Xponentialchaos]

Mistake in the title.

 

[MHSL82]

Mistake in the title.

Yes, and now even fewer will click on it. I will ask a mod to change it.

Thanks.

 

[MHSL82]

Mistake in the title.

Force of habit after making so many of these. I made the mistake at the beginning titling it first and then I did the body of the thread and then the poll. By that time, I forgot to go back to check.

Thanks for the heads up. I should always assume that I made a mistake and just look through. Toby Romo, Matt Schsub...

 

[RoboticDreams]

Went with Fitzy. I thought about Thomas or Gordon but ultimately, Larry is still a top tier receiver. It's a crap shoot in any case.

 

[Excel]

write in Julio Jones

 

[Wolverine830872]

Shouldn't Percy Harvin at least be in the discussion?

 

[PDay8810]

Shouldn't Percy Harvin at least be in the discussion?

only because Decker & Jackson seem to be

 

[MHSL82]

Shouldn't Percy Harvin at least be in the discussion?

only because Decker & Jackson seem to be

Sorry about the list of receivers, I just compiled rankings of total yards (durability), YPG (impact per game), YAC (escapabilty or speed), TDs, and YPC. I weighed them all the same and got a list. I listed them in their order on the first poll, but switched a few outside the Top 12 for some inside just based upon familiarity (knowing Calvin Johnson would win). Then, I added in players I knew or were mentioned.

Harvin wasn't on the ESPN list I was looking at (yards) because he didn't play enough games. Decker had Manning and Jackson is a big name with a good past season(s).