The 8-8-8 NFL Draft SF2 : Hall vs 500

[Nosferatu]

HALL

OFFENSE
QB - Peyton Manning - Colts - 2008
RB - Tony Dorsett - Cowboys - 1988
FB - Bill Brown - Vikings - 1968
WR - Steve Smith - Panthers - 2008
WR - Andre Reed - Bills - 1988
WR - Isaac Bruce - Rams - 2008
TE - Keith Jackson - Eagles - 1988
LT - Gary Zimmerman - Vikings - 1988
LG - Gene Upshaw - Raiders - 1968
C - Olin Kreutz - Bears - 2008
RG - Ralph Sweeney - Chargers - 1968
RT - Forrest Gregg - Packers - 1968

DEFENSE
DE - Howie Long - Raiders - 1988
NT - Curley Culp - Titans - 1968
DE - Leonard Marshall - Giants - 1988
OLB - DeMarcus Ware - Cowboys - 2008
ILB - Dick Butkus - Bears - 1968
ILB - Patrick Willis - 49ers - 2008
OLB - Lawrence Taylor - Giants - 1988
CB - Darrelle Revis - Jets - 2008
CB - Emmitt Thomas - Chiefs - 1968
CB - Hanford Dixon - Browns - 1988
SS - Rodney Harrison - Chargers - 2008
FS - Rick Volk - Colts - 1968

VS

500

OFFENSE
QB - Aaron Rodgers - Packers - 2008
RB - Chris Johnson - Titans - 2008
FB - John Williams - Seahawks - 1988
WR - Cris Carter - Vikings - 1988
WR - Michael Irvin - Cowboys - 1988
WR - Tommy McDonald - Eagles - 1968
TE - Bob Trumpy - Bengals - 1968
LT - Art Shell - Raiders - 1968
LG - Brian Waters - Chiefs - 2008
C - Bart Oates - Giants - 1988
RG - Gene Hickerson - Browns - 1968
RT - Bob Brown - Eagles - 1968

DEFENSE
DE - John Abraham - Falcons - 2008
DT - Alex Karras - Lions - 1968
DT - Joe Klecko - Jets - 1988
DE - Jason Taylor - Dolphins - 2008
LB - Mike Stratton - Bills - 1968
MLB - Ray Lewis - Ravens - 2008
LB - Mike Curtis - Colts - 1968
CB - Darrell Green - Redskins - 1988
CB - Asante Samuel - Patriots - 2008
NCB - Charles Tillman - Bears - 2008
SS - Dennis Smith - Broncos - 1988
FS - Ronnie Lott - 49ers - 1988

 

[Nosferatu]

HALL - 4
500 - 6

VOTED - Ritz, Mookie, UK, 500, Shane, Femur, Sushi, Stoke

Race to Six

 

[Ritzarmy]

Hall

 

[Mookie]

Well damn this is close...
-Passing game Hall close by the strength of his 3rd WR and TE. Like 500s top 2 WR better and better receiving options out of backfield (*Hall should have his Gator card revoked for drafting big head)
-run game about a draw but Dorsett is best RB in matchup
-OL sliiiiight edge to Hall
-front 7 Hall (love JT and Ray but this prob where I see the biggest advantage)
-secondary edge to 500

Overall Im gonna go with Hall's ability to get to the passer as being the reason he wins this. A-Rod feet are great but I just don't see him escaping all game. Great teams for both

 

[UK Cowboy]

500

 

[Pack 500]

Well damn this is close...
-Passing game Hall close by the strength of his 3rd WR and TE. Like 500s top 2 WR better and better receiving options out of backfield (*Hall should have his Gator card revoked for drafting big head)
-run game about a draw but Dorsett is best RB in matchup
-OL sliiiiight edge to Hall
-front 7 Hall (love JT and Ray but this prob where I see the biggest advantage)
-secondary edge to 500

Overall Im gonna go with Hall's ability to get to the passer as being the reason he wins this. A-Rod feet are great but I just don't see him escaping all game. Great teams for both

Comparing third WRs Tommy McDonald is a HOF receiver who put up pretty unprecedented stats for his era. I don't think Steve Smith is a HOF player. I don't think Hall has the secondary to contain all my weapons or a matchup for Johnson out of the backfield. His secondary being the weakest position group on both teams wins it for me IMO.

 

[Shanemansj13]

ARodg's ability to scramble is pretty big in this particular matchup with Hall's great LB's. I also like 500's secondary more which could definitely help 500's pass rush and getting to Manning.

I got 500

 

[Mookie]

Comparing third WRs Tommy McDonald is a HOF receiver who put up pretty unprecedented stats for his era. I don't think Steve Smith is a HOF player. I don't think Hall has the secondary to contain all my weapons or a matchup for Johnson out of the backfield. His secondary being the weakest position group on both teams wins it for me IMO.

Fair - was just offering some supporting reasoning which is obviously all straight opinion. I think that front 7 rush will help his secondary. It's very close as I previously stated

 

[Pack 500]

Random: John Abraham is one of the most underrated players in these mocks.

 

[Jtrain80]

Hall

Comparing third WRs Tommy McDonald is a HOF receiver who put up pretty unprecedented stats for his era. I don't think Steve Smith is a HOF player. I don't think Hall has the secondary to contain all my weapons or a matchup for Johnson out of the backfield. His secondary being the weakest position group on both teams wins it for me IMO.

And he is a Sooner!

 

[Nosferatu]

Random: John Abraham is one of the most underrated players in these mocks.

Never heard of her!

 

[femurov]

500

 

[CitySushi]

Man super tough but I give the edge to 500. I think his pass game helps win him the game.

 

[blstoker]

500

 

[Nosferatu]

Great teams fellas!

 

[Stakesarehigh]

Hall

 

[Hall]

Hall