Super Bowl LIX Chit Chat - Eagles vs Chiefs

[Tainthappening]

Same tier as Phillip Rivers. Only major thing separating the two is team accomplishments/rings.

So you think both are HOF worthy or neither should be in HOF.... which is it?

 

[Fountain City Blues]

So you think both are HOF worthy or neither should be in HOF.... which is it?

I think they are both fringe HOF cases. Rings are what will get Ben in, and make it very hard for Rivers.

 

[Packerpro 99]

Chiefs 27 Eagles 21

 

[Fountain City Blues]

 

[Wamu]

What about BigBen... he will be in HOF.

He's a lock for the HOF.

Same tier as Phillip Rivers. Only major thing separating the two is team accomplishments/rings.

Cola isn't totally wrong. Even with Peyton, his performance for whatever reason fell off in the playoffs. Also had that 2015 run where he was very clearly carried/washed.

QB2 of this generation, Josh Allen imo, is performing quite a bit better than Peyton did in the playoffs. Speaking of Peyton, Lamar has a very Peyton Manning-like resume going with 3 likely MVP's, no rings, and a troubled playoff resume.

The BigBen/Rivers comparison. PR has one major thing working against him. Most playoff games by a QB without reaching a Super Bowl.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

He's a lock for the HOF.



The BigBen/Rivers comparison. PR has one major thing working against him. Most playoff games by a QB without reaching a Super Bowl.

I believe that record belongs to Josh Allen now. Josh Allen is 7-6 now. Rivers was 5-7

Josh Allen holds an NFL Playoffs record that no one wants him to have

That disappointing look on Josh Allen’s face said a lot after the loss to the Chiefs.

www.buffalorumblings.com

 

[Think McFly Think]

He's a lock for the HOF.



The BigBen/Rivers comparison. PR has one major thing working against him. Most playoff games by a QB without reaching a Super Bowl.

In Rivers’ defense, 47 kids takes a toll on you during the offseason.

 

[Chief Cola]

What about BigBen... he will be in HOF.

Here's the list of AFC quarterbacks who eliminated Brady from the playoffs:

Jake Plummer, Denver Broncos
Mark Sanchez, New York Jets
Ryan Tannehill, Tennessee Titans
Joe Flacco, Baltimore Ravens (x2)
Peyton Manning, Denver Broncos/Indianapolis Colts (x3)

Not exactly the list of all-time greats most people seem to expect.

 

[Tainthappening]

Here's the list of AFC quarterbacks who eliminated Brady from the playoffs:

Jake Plummer, Denver Broncos
Mark Sanchez, New York Jets
Ryan Tannehill, Tennessee Titans
Joe Flacco, Baltimore Ravens (x2)
Peyton Manning, Denver Broncos/Indianapolis Colts (x3)

Not exactly the list of all-time greats most people seem to expect.

So this is one of those "football is not a team sport" arguments.

FWIW - Brady eliminated both Mahomes and BigBen twice in the playoffs... reason you do not see their names on the list.

 

[Chief Cola]

So this is one of those "football is not a team sport" arguments.

FWIW - Brady eliminated both Mahomes and BigBen twice in the playoffs... reason you do not see their names on the list.

Like I said before, I think Brady is the GOAT because of his passing numbers.

I think how many rings he has is a factor in his greatness but not the only measure of a quarterback.

 

[Wamu]

I believe that record belongs to Josh Allen now. Josh Allen is 7-6 now. Rivers was 5-7

Josh Allen holds an NFL Playoffs record that no one wants him to have

That disappointing look on Josh Allen’s face said a lot after the loss to the Chiefs.

www.buffalorumblings.com

Thanks for posting that. Didn't realize Allen surpassed it.

 

[Wamu]

In Rivers’ defense, 47 kids takes a toll on you during the offseason.

I was wrong about PR having the record. Josh Allen now has it.

 

[Wamu]

Like I said before, I think Brady is the GOAT because of his passing numbers.

I think how many rings he has is a factor in his greatness but not the only measure of a quarterback.

If I got one game to win I'm not going with Brady. I'm going with Montana.

 

[Battlelyon]

 

[fightinfunbags]

View attachment 387437

Show some respect to your daddy. Does he have to beat the Rams 3 times in a season for that to happen?

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Fun little comparison going on right now:

Chiefs have faced some very strong defenses in the SB.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Show some respect to your daddy. Does he have to beat the Rams 3 times in a season for that to happen?

One of the stranger things is non-Chiefs fans flexing the Chiefs on other teams hoping they lose to the Chiefs and/or clowning them for losing to the Chiefs. Granted it's the SB so that kind of talk is normal to an extent, but lol.

 

[Battlelyon]

Show some respect to your daddy. Does he have to beat the Rams 3 times in a season for that to happen?

Daddy? Hurts didn't beat the Rams, he squeaked out a win thanks to Barkley and the snow. How many rings does Hurts have anyway?

 

[fightinfunbags]

Daddy? Hurts didn't beat the Rams, he squeaked out a win thanks to Barkley and the snow. How many rings does Hurts have anyway?

He really just got started. We will see. How many rings do you have, sir?

 

[fightinfunbags]

Daddy? Hurts didn't beat the Rams, he squeaked out a win thanks to Barkley and the snow. How many rings does Hurts have anyway?

And the snow kept that game close. Snow like that benefits the lesser team. I’m not sure why it’s considered a negative for Hurts when the Eagles didn’t even need to get into the pass game because they made the Rams run defense look like a bad high school team in both of the contests that were played.