SportsHooplas Greatest BCS Heisman Winning Performance v.2 - Rd 1 - 3 Tim Tebow v 14 Jameis Winston

[iowajerms]

This is solely based on their Heisman winning season+post season.

Round 1 - Week 3

Matchup #5 - #3 2007 Tim Tebow (Florida, QB) vs #14 2013 Jameis Winston (Florida State, QB)
Matchup #6 - #6 2011 Robert Griffin III (Baylor, QB) vs #11 2002 Carson Palmer (USC, QB)

Spoiler: Round 1

Matchup #1 - SportsHoopla's Greatest BCS Heisman Winning Performance v.2 - Rd 1 - 1 Cam Newton vs 16 Mark Ingram
Matchup #2 - SportsHoopla's Greatest BCS Heisman Winning Performance v.2 - Rd 1 - 8 Ron Dayne vs 9 Matt Lienart
Matchup #3 - SportsHooplas Greatest BCS Heisman Winning Performance v.2 - Rd 1 - 5 James White vs 12 Sam Bradford
Matchup #4 - SportsHooplas Greatest BCS Heisman Winning Performance v.2 - Rd 1 - 4 Ricky WIlliams v 13 Troy Smith

 

[jwolt92]

Probably Tebow due to the rushing numbers, but the fact that Winston had a 10% TD% and a 2% Int% coupled with the fact that he rarely played into the 4th quarter should say a lot about his numbers here

 

[iowajerms]

Tebow



Winston

 

[iowajerms]

Outside TDs and Rushing, Winston owns Tebow in other stats.

 

[jwolt92]

Outside TDs and Rushing, Winston owns Tebow in other stats.

Winston has the ring and was only a RS-Freshman. Tebow carried the ball more times than anyone on his team. I still think it's a close vote in the end

 

[iowajerms]

Both broke new grounds as Heisman. Tebow was the first underclassman to win Heisman and Winston was the first freshman. Both did not win another Heisman. Both were, or could've been, dual-threat QBs.

I would guess Winston was more natural where Tebow was probably a harder worker.

 

[jwolt92]

Both broke new grounds as Heisman. Tebow was the first underclassman to win Heisman and Winston was the second freshman. Both did not win another Heisman. Both were, or could've been, dual-threat QBs.

I would guess Winston was more natural where Tebow was probably a harder worker.

FIFY

 

[iowajerms]

FIFY

Forgot about Johnny.