Six Hall of Famers MLB Draft : CHAT

[UK Cowboy]

500 is up for 2

 

[Nosferatu]

ROUND 16
16.1.121 : Bums : Mel Harder - SP - 1920
16.2.122 : WLK : Dave Righetti - RP -1970
16.3.123 : Gold : Mickey Vernon - 1B - 1930
16.4.124 : Milk : Jack Clark - RF - 1970
16.5.125 : Ritz : Harvey Kuenn - SS/OF - 1950
16.6.126 : Nos : Sal Maglie - SP - 1940
16.7.127 : UK : Bobby Shantz - 1940
16.8.128 : 500 :

 

[Ritzarmy]

500 is up for 2

And already pm'd

 

[Nosferatu]

No trades surprises me...

 

[Ritzarmy]

UK picked twice in a row he should be disqualified

 

[Ritzarmy]

Waiting on Nos like usual. :bored:

 

[MilkSpiller22]

UK i want Bobby shantz... I will trade you my next 3 picks for your last 2 picks and shanty

 

[Ritzarmy]

I can't believe Babe Harman wasn't taken sooner. I swear he was taken because I had him on my list but erased it because I thought he was taken. Great pick by 500.

 

[Ritzarmy]

Nos says to skip him so I just picked. He won't be online till 5pm.

 

[UK Cowboy]

UK i want Bobby shantz... I will trade you my next 3 picks for your last 2 picks and shanty

Not interested in picks for Shantz, he was my top player available. I'll look over your roster and see if there's a player deal that fits

 

[UK Cowboy]

UK i want Bobby shantz... I will trade you my next 3 picks for your last 2 picks and shanty

Trades are tough in this format. Here's one

Milk gives UK gives
Seaver SP 60 Bench C 60
Simmons C 60 Shantz RP 40
Orasco RP 70 Stieb SP 70
Next pick. Foster LF 60

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Trades are tough in this format. Here's one

Milk gives UK gives
Seaver SP 60 Bench C 60
Simmons C 60 Shantz RP 40
Orasco RP 70 Stieb SP 70
Next pick. Foster LF 60

That is way too much for me to give... I really need seaver...

 

[UK Cowboy]

That is way too much for me to give... I really need seaver...

Gotta give to get. I don't blame ya. Tom's a stud

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Gotta give to get. I don't blame ya. Tom's a stud

I agree that you gotta give to get, but when you are only asking for a 16th round player, i am not going to give up my 2nd rounder to get him...

 

[UK Cowboy]

I agree that you gotta give to get, but when you are only asking for a 16th round player, i am not going to give up my 2nd rounder to get him...

Lets look at that offer closer

I get the best player in Seaver, you get a solid SP in Stieb, certainly my favor there

Rest of deal
You get the greatest Catcher ever for Simmons- edge you
You get Shantz for Orasco-edge you
You get Former MVP Foster for your next pick- edge you

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Lets look at that offer closer

I get the best player in Seaver, you get a solid SP in Stieb, certainly my favor there

Rest of deal
You get the greatest Catcher ever for Simmons- edge you
You get Shantz for Orasco-edge you
You get Former MVP Foster for your next pick- edge you

I dont agree that Shantz is better than Orosco at all... But if you are that high on him i guess i wouldn't have gotten him anyway... He is only the best available at his decade...

 

[da55bums]

Lets look at that offer closer

I get the best player in Seaver, you get a solid SP in Stieb, certainly my favor there

Rest of deal
You get the greatest Catcher ever for Simmons- edge you
You get Shantz for Orasco-edge you
You get Former MVP Foster for your next pick- edge you

Yogi Berra says "Hi', well at least according to most experts, strange part out of the 3 best catchers ever, 1 is still available.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Yogi Berra says "Hi', well at least according to most experts, strange part out of the 3 best catchers ever, 1 is still available.

Have to agree to disagree. In my opinion, it's Bench, Pudge, Yogi(Josh Gibson would be #1 if eligible)

 

[UK Cowboy]

I dont agree that Shantz is better than Orosco at all... But if you are that high on him i guess i wouldn't have gotten him anyway... He is only the best available at his decade...

Yeah, I'd take Shantz over Orasco all day

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Yeah, I'd take Shantz over Orasco all day

and i disagree... But to each their own...