Uhsplit
Well-Known Member
[/B]
Ok, so the first bolded makes no sense to me unless your team plans on spending a major quantity of draft picks this year on OL. Based on what you said, it is automatically addition by subtraction by letting McQ and Glac walk because you assume that those players coming in are automatically better, which will have to be seen.
The second bolded makes it so that you are putting MORE pressure on Wilson to not only do his job, but severely compensate for another's lack of ability to do theirs. Based on this season and RW's stats in games against decent opponents without Okung, you cannot be serious. I get it, you view your team through the same rose colored glasses that we see our team with, but that is a farce to think that your team can function well without a solid LT and discount it by simply saying that you have RW. Remember the beating RW took towards the middle of this season and the fact that he had to more or less run for his life? Your statement sounds as if you are ok with that for a full 16-game schedule.
You may not need an All-Pro LT but you at least need a SOLID LT in order for your offense to function. A SOLID LT is both difficult to find and, if bought in FA, expensive.
Lastly, Unger and Okung are far and away the best OL you have. You know this better then I do. Sweezy is good in run blocking but IMO average at best in pass protection. That leaves two holes that you are looking to fill with Carp, who has been a bust up to this point, and Bowie, who showed some flashes but is consistently unimpressive. And that's BEFORE talking about Okung leaving. This will either pose a problem in making cap room to re-sign Okung or finding his replacement that isn't a severe downgrade from the production you got from Okung when he was healthy.
dred, you have me playing defense but I suppose I asked for it. All in good fun.
With the cap in mind we let McQ and Giac leave. They would command roughly $7-$8 Million to keep both.
McQ is a career backup who is very versatile and can play all OL positions except C.
Giac is a nasty tuff type road grader who is not well rounded as a RT. Good run blocker. So is Bailey.
In another thread you said the 9ers had Justin Smiths replacement in Tank. Right now we have Bailey for that and he got a little play time in the regular season and more in the playoffs including the SB.
Replacing Giac is not as big a task compared to replacing JS, but you took a stab at it anyway.
Carp is in his contract year. I don't expect him to play at a lower level than he played at last year. A similar performance will get him his walking papers and cost him millions. I say he plays at = or > last year.
We will draft OL. I am not saying we fixed our OL problem. It is very possible we have not downgraded, maybe maintained, and saved about $6 Mill off the cap.
Regarding Okung, I am not the 1st Hawk fan in this thread that thinks Okung might become a cap casualty. He is outstanding when healthy and plays about 10-12 games a year for a bout a million a game. I would love to replace him next year (as I said earlier-not this year) for a reliable LT who can play at about80- 90% of Okungs effectiveness for a rookie contract at a cap savings of millions.
We have other fish to fry.