Scherzer For Harper

[redseat]

Well this trade was just approved and upheld (granted the one person in this trade is the commissioner)


Max Scherzer

For

Bryce Harper

14th Round for 20th Round also involved.

What say you?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

no problems with it... and I am the VETO police here...

although, I will ask if this is a redraft, who was pick first, and who got the higher draft pick

 

[redseat]

no problems with it... and I am the VETO police here...

although, I will ask if this is a redraft, who was pick first, and who got the higher draft pick

Granted Pitching is more covided in our league.

First pick this year (out of those two members of my league) will be the guy who traded Harper
and the higher draft pick in this trade goes to the guy who traded away Scherzer

 

[TKOSpikes]

Even Steven.

I'll take Max all day

 

[redseat]

Even Steven.

I'll take Max all day

assuming he doesn't blow out his arm this season.... But Harper might get pitched around more now so yeah Max has more value.

 

[Mike A. S.]

If it's a single season league I think it's ok. If it's a dynasty-keeper league then I'm not so sure. Still probably not bad enough to actually veto, but not perfectly even IMO.

 

[redseat]

If it's a single season league I think it's ok. If it's a dynasty-keeper league then I'm not so sure. Still probably not bad enough to actually veto, but not perfectly even IMO.

Keeper League

Got Tillman

 

[Mike A. S.]

Keeper League

Got Tillman

Then I definitely don't think it's perfectly fair. But I also don't think I'd make a big stink about it or actually veto it.

 

[redseat]

Then I definitely don't think it's perfectly fair. But I also don't think I'd make a big stink about it or actually veto it.

sadly I can't even veto in this league and one of the people involved is the actual League Comish.

 

[TKOSpikes]

This isn't close to being vetoable.

Max Scherzer is at worst a top five pitcher. Number 1 for me this year.

Elite arm for "elite" bat. Max's elite is consistent. Harper's elite is streaky.

 

[redseat]

This isn't close to being vetoable.

Max Scherzer is at worst a top five pitcher. Number 1 for me this year.

Elite arm for "elite" bat. Max's elite is consistent. Harper's elite is streaky.

True.. Just since this is such a pitcher reliant league I was thinking about it

 

[Chef99]

Not even worth talking about as far as "vetoable" goes. Dynasty, keeper, redraft or whatever. Perfectly fine trade.