how can it not be influenced by numbers.
if you had the option to set your teams schedule which set would you pick?
Oregon, LSU, Oklahoma State, Nebraska
Fresno State, East Carolina, Ball State, Louisiana Lafayette
Which 4 would you rather your team play? based on SOS W/L record they are the same. but I bet your biasedness would tell you the second set would be easier to play than the first.
If I'm going to be completely honest. As a fan, I want the first 4 on your list. Those are "must see" games. Those are the games that you have your buddies over for a BBQ or you circle as games that you want to attend.
If I'm most AD's around the country, I want the 2nd 4 on your list because I'm looking at going in to conference play only needing 2-3 wins to become bowl eligible or I'm much more likely to finish unbeaten or with only 1-2 losses and a possible playoff berth or BCS bowl.