No 1st Rounders NFL Draft Playoff : WLK vs 500

[Nosferatu]

WLK
QB - Joe Montana
RB - Tiki Barber
RB - Tom Rathman
WR - Fred Biletnikoff
WR - Chad Johnson
WR - Wes Welker
TE - Dave Casper
LT - Joe Jacoby
LG - Russ Grimm
C - Dwight Stephenson
RG - Steve Wisniewski
RT - Bob St. Claire
LDE - Mark Gastineau
LDT - Curley Culp
RDT - Michael Dean Perry
RDE - Charles Haley
LLB - Jack Ham
ILB - Mike Singletary
RLB - Chad Brown
LCB - Emmitt Thomas
RCB - Mel Renfro
NCB - Sam Madison
SS - Leroy Butler
FS - John Lynch

VS

500
QB - Roger Staubach
RB - Terrell Davis
FB - William Andrews
WR - Raymond Berry
WR - Charlie Joiner
WR - John Stallworth
TE - Shannon Sharpe
LT - Roosevelt Brown
OG - Marco Rivera
C - Jim Ringo
OG - Josh Sitton
RT - Dan Dierdorf
LDE - Willie Davis
LDT - Shaun Rogers
RDT - Darnell Dockett
LDE - Deacon Jones
RLB - Lavonte David
MLB - Ray Nitschke
RLB - Chris Hanburger
LCB - Lemar Parrish
RCB - Aeneas Williams
NCB - Frank Minnifield
SS - Tim McDonald
FS - Brian Dawkins

 

[Nosferatu]

WLK = 5
500 = 3

VOTED = Jeffro, Milk, Ritz, 500, Gold, Nos, UK, WLK

 

[Ritzarmy]

My vote goes to Wlk. This will be a very close battle. I didn't like how 500 took two guards that played dominantly at RG. Yes they both played a little LG but majority was at RG. I believe it shouldn't really matter but when every other positions are so close I went the one negative I saw it's nick picking on a really good team but forced to vote for someone. Sorry 500 you had several guys I wanted on your team and suck voting against you.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I am going WLK here too... His offensive line is better, and that helps out his offense...

 

[jeffro151]

WLK.
I feel like he is better than 500 at every unit except for 500's secondary.

 

[Pack 500]

My vote goes to Wlk. This will be a very close battle. I didn't like how 500 took two guards that played dominantly at RG. Yes they both played a little LG but majority was at RG. I believe it shouldn't really matter but when every other positions are so close I went the one negative I saw it's nick picking on a really good team but forced to vote for someone. Sorry 500 you had several guys I wanted on your team and suck voting against you.

Josh Sitton is the best guard in the NFL today and plays LG. Switched over two years ago and has continued to be one of if not the best guard in the NFL. I don't care if you don't vote for me but this should not be a reason.

 

[Pack 500]

WLK.
I feel like he is better than 500 at every unit except for 500's secondary.

Uhm in what world is Tiki Barber better than Terrell Davis? I have 3 HOF WRs to his one. And my DE's are also better IMO. Can also be argued my OTs are better if not at least equal

 

[Pack 500]

500

 

[Gold Rush 86]

I'm going with WLK in this one.

 

[Nosferatu]

500 is better at every position on offense aside from QB and OG
DE's = 500 easily
DT's = WLK
LB's = WLK
Secondary = 500

I gotta say I like WLK's team but not even Montana can save him in this one. I wonder what you guys are seeing here that i'm not...

500

 

[Pack 500]

500 is better at every position on offense aside from QB and OG
DE's = 500 eaily
DT's = WLK
LB's = WLK
Secondary = 500

I gotta say I like WLK's team but not even Montana can save him in this one. I wonder what you guys are seeing here that i'm not...

500

All of this. No offense to Jeffro but his post was a stunner

 

[Pack 500]

WLK.
I feel like he is better than 500 at every unit except for 500's secondary.

I forgot to mention Dave Casper > Shannon Sharpe??????

 

[jeffro151]

All of this. No offense to Jeffro but his post was a stunner

Apparently I'm not the only one that feels the way I do......

 

[UK Cowboy]

I think this is a super close matchup. The passing game is excellent both ways. Biggest advantage on offense to me is TD over Tiki, TD was truly great. The D's are also real close, but Deacon is the biggest difference maker, and I'm not sure WLK could get him blocked

500 21-20

 

[Pack 500]

Apparently I'm not the only one that feels the way I do......

Again no offense bro but you're the only one saying it isn't close. Milk always votes on o-line. Ritz said it was close although his reason was wrong too. Again exlplain How Tiki, Fred, Ocho, Wes Casper, > davis, BErry, Joiner, Stallworth, Sharpe? And Haley, Gastineu > Deacon, Davis?

 

[wlk3]

I got me... I'll give more explanation later...

 

[Nosferatu]

Congrats to WLK who moves on...