NHL #1 Goaltender

[Cobiemonster]

I'll put up 12 choices in the poll to start off(since 12 is the maximum amount you can put on a poll)

We'll start off by voting for the number one goalie - the poll will end on Tuesday morning

Here's the schedule for the voting of each position

Number 1 - 7/11-7/15
Number 2 - 7/16-7/20
Number 3 - 7/21-7/25
Number 4 - 7/26-7/30
Number 5 - 7/31-8/4
Number 6 - 8/5-8/9
Number 7 - 8/10-8/14
Number 8 - 8/15-8/19
Number 9 - 8/20-8/24
Number 10 - 8/25-8/29

 

[Bloody Brian Burke]

Bernier should be on the list if Bishop is. Both had one hot season and both their teams collapsed when they got hurt.

 

[Cobiemonster]

Bernier should be on the list if Bishop is. Both had one hot season and both their teams collapsed when they got hurt.

True, however, Ben Bishop still got his team into the playoffs, a team that was not a playoff team the season before - and the Leafs had bigger issues than losing their goalie(bad defense, forwards not producing when it mattered) - lot more than goaltending in Toronto

 

[Canuck eh?]

Bernier should be on the list if Bishop is. Both had one hot season and both their teams collapsed when they got hurt.

Dave Clarkson just fell down.

 

[Canuck eh?]

True, however, Ben Bishop still got his team into the playoffs, a team that was not a playoff team the season before - and the Leafs had bigger issues than losing their goalie(bad defense, forwards not producing when it mattered) - lot more than goaltending in Toronto

So which one of the last dozen years are you talking about Cobie?

 

[jstewismybastardson]

what???? no Nabokov????

 

[Bloody Brian Burke]

True, however, Ben Bishop still got his team into the playoffs, a team that was not a playoff team the season before - and the Leafs had bigger issues than losing their goalie(bad defense, forwards not producing when it mattered) - lot more than goaltending in Toronto

I would argue that the fact the Leafs were 3rd in the conference when Bernier went down with a month to play and missed the playoffs entirely speaks volumes to just how good he was. Tampa was just as lost without Bishop as the Leafs were without Bernier.

 

[Bloody Brian Burke]

Dave Clarkson just fell down.

Quit stealing my bit.

 

[dash]

what???? no Nabokov????

 

[phoenixrising]

Bernier should be on the list if Bishop is. Both had one hot season and both their teams collapsed when they got hurt.

And why is Rask even on the list=loser

 

[dare2be]

what???? no Nabokov????

LMAFO!

 

[Bloody Brian Burke]

And why is Rask even on the list=loser

*calls Andrew Raycroft*

 

[dash]

Mike Smith is flopping mad about being dissed from this list...

 

[Nasty_Magician]

Let's see what he does with a full season, but on this list there are only 4 guys that I would 100% put above Schneider at this point. Queen, Quick, Rask and Price. Others are in the debate but those 4 for sure.

 

[kylezengel]

I think Jay Oriant can answer this question........

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ksb7UlwCIKQ]SERGEI BOBROVSKY! #1 COP IN TOWN! - YouTube[/ame]

 

[pixburgher66]

Hey look! 43 isn't alone anymore!

 

[forty_three]

I think Jay Oriant can answer this question........

SERGEI BOBROVSKY! #1 COP IN TOWN! - YouTube

I like the cut of your jib!

Hey look! 43 isn't alone anymore!

I will never be alone as long as Coke is forcing me to share my drinks.

 

[DWIPensFan]

And why is Rask even on the list=loser

And you know if this were FN, you would be dead by now, or at the very least a late-night drive by.

 

[Darkstone42]

Bob's on the rise, and in terms of raw talent might be the best, but Lundqvist just always seems to be in total control, so I had to pick him.

 

[CalamityX11]

Rinne is such a favorite of mine...