Name your top 4

[Boglodyte]

lol, that's cute.

You disagree?

Same way with your boys…at least the ones not transferring…what good is it to play?

 

[Fountain City Blues]

FSU was and is not the same team without their QB. barely made it past their last two games. sorry.

committee got it right.

if GA had won, I would've put Texas in at 4 probably.

My only beef with leaving out FSU because "best team" is it's actually pretty much impossible to leave out Georgia doing that without going into resume arguments, which isn't the same thing.

This is more evidence of a 4 team format just being a bad idea in general and that expansion is justified, imo. A shitshow selection like this year was inevitable

 

[Boglodyte]

*Sees McCord*

Not even top 6 for me.

Since McCord is leaving does that change up or down

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Since McCord is leaving does that change up or down

No idea. We'll see what Ohio State comes up with. tOSU should be doing a lot better than McCord put out with all the talent they have.

 

[PIBuckeye]

My only beef with leaving out FSU because "best team" is it's actually pretty much impossible to leave out Georgia doing that without going into resume arguments, which isn't the same thing.

This is more evidence of a 4 team format just being a bad idea in general and that expansion is justified, imo. A shitshow selection like this year was inevitable

GA lost their CCG. that has to matter. bama beat the #1 team in the nation, and won the SEC CCG.

when we went from 2 to 4, should have gone to 8. I'm wondering if 12 is too many.

someone was going to get left out. IMHO, they left out the weakest power 5 winner. honestly thought Lville was going to have a better showing, and hoped they beat fsu to take care of this argument. but with how bad lville did, just amplified more how bad the ACC is.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

GA lost their CCG. that has to matter. bama beat the #1 team in the nation, and won the SEC CCG.

when we went from 2 to 4, should have gone to 8. I'm wondering if 12 is too many.

someone was going to get left out. IMHO, they left out the weakest power 5 winner. honestly thought Lville was going to have a better showing, and hoped they beat fsu to take care of this argument. but with how bad lville did, just amplified more how bad the ACC is.

No it doesn't. You can't say it matters anymore than "being undefeated in a power conference has to matter."

It's either false, or you need to start making threads how the current ACC is a G5 conference.

 

[foster4prez]

Yesterday was a dark day for college football. There's really no other way to frame it. The games are pointless now and ESPN via the "committee" has made that clear.

We're now all pro wrestling fans.

 

[bamagrad75]

Clutch em if you have rm

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Yesterday was a dark day for college football. There's really no other way to frame it. The games are pointless now and ESPN via the "committee" has made that clear.

We're now all pro wrestling fans.

 

[Nat Mann]

FSU should pull a UCF and claim the title for going undefeated.

Let's see how they do with their second string QB vs Georgia first.

 

[PIBuckeye]

Let's see how they do with their second string QB vs Georgia first.

exactly. sorry, but didn't see anything to back up the outrage after watching their last two games without their star, against much lesser teams. Wait until they square up with GA.

 

[foster4prez]

exactly. sorry, but didn't see anything to back up the outrage after watching their last two games without their star, against much lesser teams. Wait until they square up with GA.

Ironic coming from the fan of a team who got a free bye from the committee when they were down to their 3rd string QB.

 

[foster4prez]

Just going to leave this here.

 

[PIBuckeye]

Ironic coming from the fan of a team who got a free bye from the committee when they were down to their 3rd string QB.

lol. A free bye?

Well. Our 3rd string QB finished the michigan game, that wasn't over, when JT Barrett went down, and did it in stellar fashion. Then he went to the Big Ten CCG and went up against a very good Wisconsin team and good defense, and whooped their ass 59-0. They made a statement. FSU didn't. sorry. no comparison. FSU didn't look good at all eeking out those last two wins. If FSU went out there and won 59-0 over Lville, then it would've given the committee more to think about. But they did not do that.

 

[Wolvie]

Here is a legitimate question: if Georgia would have beat Alabama in the championship game, then would FSU been chosen over Texas? The committee's top for teams would have all won.

 

[redskinsfan1963]

well in truth,they picked the best teams for tv ratings.nobody wants to se fsu michigan when bama/michigan will be the better game.

 

[10HtownRebs]

UW is gonna make you respect them.. Make sure to come back and eat your humble pie …

You have no faith in them... I can tell.. LOLOL

 

[10HtownRebs]

You do realize UW beat Texas last year in the Alamo Bowl right ?

Want to bet on this year?

 

[10HtownRebs]

My argument the entire time has been based on who deserved to be in based on the season, not who is the best team. I was also clear early that Georgia and Alabama are the only thing about the SEC that props them up as the elite conference.

However, I will put all of my fake money up, I had no idea I had any because it means nothing.

Who props your conference up?

Let's here your top 5 teams in your conference...

Go

 

[foster4prez]

lol. A free bye?

Well. Our 3rd string QB finished the michigan game, that wasn't over, when JT Barrett went down, and did it in stellar fashion. Then he went to the Big Ten CCG and went up against a very good Wisconsin team and good defense, and whooped their ass 59-0. They made a statement. FSU didn't. sorry. no comparison. FSU didn't look good at all eeking out those last two wins. If FSU went out there and won 59-0 over Lville, then it would've given the committee more to think about. But they did not do that.

Bama needed an absolute miracle to beat a shit ass Auburn team with their #1 QB.