MLB NL Draft Championship : Nos vs 500

[Nosferatu]

NOS

LINEUP
1. Jackie Robinson (R) - 2B
2. Richie Ashburn (L) - DH
3. Duke Snider (L) - CF
4. Dick Allen (R) - 3B
5. Billy Williams (L) - LF
6. Roy Campanella (R) - C
7. Bobby Abreu - (L) - RF
8. Gil Hodges (R) - 1B
9. Maury Wills (B) - SS

BENCH
Darren Daulton (L) - C
Juan Pierre (L) - PR/CF/LF
Dave Concepcion (R) - SS/2B
Matt Williams (R) - 3B
Pedro Guerrero (R) - 1B/3B/OF

ROTATION
1. Christy Mathewson (R)
2. Clayton Kershaw (L)
3. Don Drysdale (R)
4. Carl Hubbell (L)
5. J.R. Richard (R)

BULLPEN
Randy Myers (L)
Kent Tekulve (R)
Armando Benitez (R)
Al Hrabosky (L)
Steve Bedrosian (R)

VS

500

LINEUP
1. Barry Larkin (R) - SS
2. Larry Walker (L) - DH
3. Roberto Clemente (R) - RF
4. Willie McCovey (L) - 1B
5. Moises Alou (R) - LF
6. Dale Murphy (R) - CF
7. Scott Rolen (R) - 3B
8. Ernie Lombardi (R) - C
9. Larry Doyle (L) - 2B

BENCH
Bill Terry (L) - 1B
George Foster (R) - LF
Wally Berger (R) - CF
Smoky Burgess (L) - C
Rafael Furcal (B) - SS

ROTATION
1. Tom Seaver (R)
2. Steve Carlton (L)
3. Dizzy Dean (R)
4. Steve Rogers (R)
5. Noah Syndergaard (R)

BULLPEN
Lee Smith (R)
Octavio Dotel (R)
Larry Andersen (R)
Jonathan Broxton (R)
Bill Henry (L)

 

[Nosferatu]

Nos - 6
500 - 5

Voted - EHB, Shane, UK, 500, Nos, Mebert, Femur, WLK, Milk, Ritz, Johnny

 

[ehb5]

Nos

 

[Shanemansj13]

I like 500 to take a close one. It's close

 

[UK Cowboy]

500

 

[Pack 500]

I believe that my pitching can hang in there with Nos' and that there is a greater difference between the lineups with mine coming out on top. I also really like my bench this draft. I got myself.

 

[Nosferatu]

I'm not sure I understand how 500's offense is better.

I got me.

 

[Mebert]

Nos

 

[Pack 500]

I'm not sure I understand how 500's offense is better.

I got me.

Clearly better at the 3 and 4. Despite Williams and Ashburn being HOFs Walker and Alou have the better career numbers. Campanella has the edge over Murphy. Rolen and Abreu are a wash. Lombardi, Doyle > Hodges and Willis. I think my 2-5 and bottom two are stronger

 

[femurov]

Tough call. I got 500 by a hair.

 

[wlk3]

Clearly I'm not as good as I thought I was at this lol... I thought I was better than Nos, and I got Nos better than 500... Nos

Now back to the drawing board...

 

[Nosferatu]

162 averages

Jackie Robinson - .311 avg .409 obp 16 hr 86 rbi 23 steals
Richie Ashburn - .308 avg .396 obp 2 hr 43 rbi 17 steals
Duke Snider - .295 avg .380 obp 31 hr 101 rbi 7 steals
Dick Allen - .292 avg .378 obp 33 hr 104 rbi 12 steals
Billy Williams - .290 avg .361 obp 28 hr 96 rbi 6 steals
Roy Campanella - .276 avg .360 obp 32 hr 114 rbi 3 steals
Bobby Abreu - .291 avg .395 obp 19 hr 91 rbi 27 steals
Gil Hodges - .273 avg .359 obp 29 hr 100 rbi 5 steals
Maury Wills - .281 avg .330 obp 2 hr 38 rbi 49 steals


Barry Larkin - .295 avg .371 obp 15 hr 71 rbi 28 steals
Larry Walker - .313 avg .400 obp 31 hr 107 rbi 19 steals
Roberto Clemente - .317 avg .359 obp 16 hr 87 rbi 6 steals
Willie McCovey - .270 avg .374 obp 33 hr 97 rbi 2 steals
Moises Alou - .303 avg .369 obp 28 hr 107 rbi 9 steals
Dale Murphy - .265 avg .346 obp 30 hr 94 rbi 12 steals
Scott Rolen - .281 avg .364 obp 25 hr 102 rbi 9 steals
Ernie Lombardi - .306 avg .358 obp 17 hr 87 rbi 1 steal
Larry Doyle - .290 avg .357 obp 7 hr 73 rbi 27 steals

 

[Pack 500]

162 averages

Jackie Robinson - .311 avg .409 obp 16 hr 86 rbi 23 steals
Richie Ashburn - .308 avg .396 obp 2 hr 43 rbi 17 steals
Duke Snider - .295 avg .380 obp 31 hr 101 rbi 7 steals
Dick Allen - .292 avg .378 obp 33 hr 104 rbi 12 steals
Billy Williams - .290 avg .361 obp 28 hr 96 rbi 6 steals
Roy Campanella - .276 avg .360 obp 32 hr 114 rbi 3 steals
Bobby Abreu - .291 avg .395 obp 19 hr 91 rbi 27 steals
Gil Hodges - .273 avg .359 obp 29 hr 100 rbi 5 steals
Maury Wills - .281 avg .330 obp 2 hr 38 rbi 49 steals


Barry Larkin - .295 avg .371 obp 15 hr 71 rbi 28 steals
Larry Walker - .313 avg .400 obp 31 hr 107 rbi 19 steals
Roberto Clemente - .317 avg .359 obp 16 hr 87 rbi 6 steals
Willie McCovey - .270 avg .374 obp 33 hr 97 rbi 2 steals
Moises Alou - .303 avg .369 obp 28 hr 107 rbi 9 steals
Dale Murphy - .265 avg .346 obp 30 hr 94 rbi 12 steals
Scott Rolen - .281 avg .364 obp 25 hr 102 rbi 9 steals
Ernie Lombardi - .306 avg .358 obp 17 hr 87 rbi 1 steal
Larry Doyle - .290 avg .357 obp 7 hr 73 rbi 27 steals

So my point remains?

 

[Nosferatu]

Clearly better at the 3 and 4. Despite Williams and Ashburn being HOFs Walker and Alou have the better career numbers. Campanella has the edge over Murphy. Rolen and Abreu are a wash. Lombardi, Doyle > Hodges and Willis. I think my 2-5 and bottom two are stronger

I stopped reading after you said you were clearly better at 3 and 4 you clearly are not better.

 

[Pack 500]

I stopped reading after you said you were clearly better at 3 and 4 you clearly are not better.

In what draft do Allen and Snyder ever get drafted closely to Clemente and McCovey?

 

[Nosferatu]

Duke Snider - .295 avg .380 obp 31 hr 101 rbi 7 steals
Dick Allen - .292 avg .378 obp 33 hr 104 rbi 12 steals

VS

Roberto Clemente - .317 avg .359 obp 16 hr 87 rbi 6 steals
Willie McCovey - .270 avg .374 obp 33 hr 97 rbi 2 steals


Explain please. Clementes BA is .22 points higher than Snider, Allens is .22 points higher than McCoveys.
I got you in OBP, HR's, RBI's, Steals...

 

[Nosferatu]

In what draft do Allen and Snyder ever get drafted closely to Clemente and McCovey?

HAHA, yeah that's what makes them better. McCovey ended up with 500 HR's and Clemente had a shit ton of GG's and died tragically.

I just showed you the numbers, maybe now people will start drafting Allen and Snyder earlier...

 

[Pack 500]

HAHA, yeah that's what makes them better. McCovey ended up with 500 HR's and Clemente had a shit ton of GG's and died tragically.

I just showed you the numbers, maybe now people will start drafting Allen and Snyder earlier...

Look at this man dissing the voters!

 

[Nosferatu]

That was fucking funny...

 

[Pack 500]

Duke Snider - .295 avg .380 obp 31 hr 101 rbi 7 steals
Dick Allen - .292 avg .378 obp 33 hr 104 rbi 12 steals

VS

Roberto Clemente - .317 avg .359 obp 16 hr 87 rbi 6 steals
Willie McCovey - .270 avg .374 obp 33 hr 97 rbi 2 steals


Explain please. Clementes BA is .22 points higher than Snider, Allens is .22 points higher than McCoveys.
I got you in OBP, HR's, RBI's, Steals...

MVPs 2 to 0 and Clemente and McCovey had more longevity. Also Allen and Snider were quite bad defensively.