MLB Dynasty Draft III SF1A : Femur vs Shane

[Nosferatu]

FEMUR

LINEUP
1. Wade Boggs (L) - 3B
2. Frankie Frisch (B) - 2B
3. Stan Musial (L) - 1B
4. Duke Snider (L) - CF
5. Ivan Rodriguez (R) - C
6. Al Kaline (R) - RF
7. Willie Stargell (L) - LF
8. Dave Winfield (R) - DH
9. Luke Appling (R) - SS

BENCH
Todd Helton (L) - 1B
Sam Rice (L) - RF
Pee Wee Reese (R) - SS
Ryan Braun (R) - 3B/LF
Smoky Burgess (L) - C

ROTATION
1. Greg Maddux (R)
2. Whitey Ford (L)
3. Jim Palmer (R)
4. Eppa Rixey (L)
5. Bret Saberhagen (R)

BULLPEN
Jesse Orosco (L)
John Wetteland (R)
Gary Lavelle (L)
Jose Valverde (R)
Bryan Harvey (R)

VS

SHANE

LINEUP
1. Eddie Collins (L) - 2B
2. Larry Walker (L) - RF
3. Lou Gehrig (L) - 1B
4. Mike Piazza (R) - C
5. Ralph Kiner (R) - LF
6. Carlos Delgado (L) - DH
7. Carlos Beltran (B) - CF
8. Al Rosen (R) - 3B
9. Nomar Garciaparra (R) - SS

BENCH
Victor Martinez (B) - C
Joe Cronin (R) - SS
Gil Hodges (R) - 1B
Chuck Knoblauch (R) - 2B/PR
Brian Giles (L) - OF

ROTATION
1. Christy Mathewson (R)
2. Bob Feller (R)
3. Mordecai “Three Finger” Brown (R)
4. David Price (L)
5. Kevin Brown (R)

BULLPEN
Craig Kimbrel (R)
Sparky Lyle (L)
Kent Tekulve (R)
Willie Hernandez (L)
Tony Watson (L)

 

[Nosferatu]

Femur - 7
Shane - 1

Voted - Shane, Femur, Bums, Ducey, Devil, Ritz, Milk, Hall

Race to 8

 

[Shanemansj13]

Teams are pretty even tbh. I like my lineup and BP and his rotation a tad more. Me

 

[femurov]

Me

 

[da55bums]

got to keep the standard line - better rotation wins - Femur

 

[TheRobotDevil]

bones

 

[tducey]

Femur

 

[Ritzarmy]

Femal

 

[MilkSpiller22]

femur

 

[Hall]

Femur brcause I have a mancrush on Maddux

 

[blstoker]

Shane

 

[da55bums]

Shane

still picking the small ones aren't ya, little fella.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Fem

 

[Mebert]

Shane

 

[Nosferatu]

Congrats @femurov

 

[Shanemansj13]

got to keep the standard line - better rotation wins - Femur

1. Greg Maddux (R) - 106.7 WAR 56.3 WAR7 3.16 ERA 132 ERA+ 3.26 FIP 1.143 WHIP 8.5 H9 0.6 HR9 1.8 BB9 6.1 SO9
VS
1. Christy Mathewson (R) - 104.0 WAR 68.5 WAR7 2.13 ERA 136 ERA+ 2.26 FIP 1.058 WHIP 7.9 H9 0.2 HR9 1.6 BB9 4.7 SO9



2. Whitey Ford (L) - 56.9 WAR 34.6 WAR7 2.75 ERA 133 ERA+ 3.26 FIP 1.215 WHIP 7.9 H9 0.6 HR9 3.1 BB9 5.6 SO9
VS
2. Bob Feller (R) - 63.9 WAR 52.0 WAR7 3.25 ERA 122 ERA+ 3.48 FIP 1.316 WHIP 7.7 H9 0.5 HR9 4.1 BB9 6.1 SO9



3. Jim Palmer (R) - 68.9 WAR 47.7 WAR7 2.86 ERA 125 ERA+ 3.50 FIP 1.180 WHIP 7.6 H9 0.7 HR9 3.0 BB9 5.0 SO9
VS
3. Mordecai “Three Finger” Brown (R) - 58.3 WAR 43.8 WAR7 2.06 ERA 139 ERA+ 2.41 FIP 1.066 WHIP 7.7 H9 0.1 HR9 1.9 BB9 3.9 SO9



4. Eppa Rixey (L) - 55.4 WAR 33.7 WAR7 3.15 ERA 115 ERA+ 3.29 FIP 1.272 WHIP 9.3 H9 0.2 HR9 2.2 BB9 2.7 SO9
VS
4. David Price (L) - 37.9 WAR 32.2 WAR7 3.25 ERA 124 ERA+ 3.34 FIP 1.144 WHIP 8.0 H9 0.9 HR9 2.3 BB9 8.7 SO9



5. Bret Saberhagen (R) - 59.0 WAR 43.3 WAR7 3.34 ERA 126 ERA+ 3.27 FIP 1.141 WHIP 8.6 H9 0.8 HR9 1.7 BB9 6.0 SO9
VS
5. Kevin Brown (R) - 68.0 WAR 45.2 WAR7 3.28 ERA 127 ERA+ 3.33 FIP 1.222 WHIP 8.5 H9 0.6 HR9 2.5 BB9 6.6 SO9

Just was curious about the numbers and it was pretty close. Obviously you could compare more numbers but I just did a quick comparison.

Femur has edge on #2 and #3 but I had the advantage on my #1 and #5. #4 starters were pretty even, I think Rixey is pretty overrated though.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

1. Greg Maddux (R) - 106.7 WAR 56.3 WAR7 3.16 ERA 132 ERA+ 3.26 FIP 1.143 WHIP 8.5 H9 0.6 HR9 1.8 BB9 6.1 SO9
VS
1. Christy Mathewson (R) - 104.0 WAR 68.5 WAR7 2.13 ERA 136 ERA+ 2.26 FIP 1.058 WHIP 7.9 H9 0.2 HR9 1.6 BB9 4.7 SO9



2. Whitey Ford (L) - 56.9 WAR 34.6 WAR7 2.75 ERA 133 ERA+ 3.26 FIP 1.215 WHIP 7.9 H9 0.6 HR9 3.1 BB9 5.6 SO9
VS
2. Bob Feller (R) - 63.9 WAR 52.0 WAR7 3.25 ERA 122 ERA+ 3.48 FIP 1.316 WHIP 7.7 H9 0.5 HR9 4.1 BB9 6.1 SO9



3. Jim Palmer (R) - 68.9 WAR 47.7 WAR7 2.86 ERA 125 ERA+ 3.50 FIP 1.180 WHIP 7.6 H9 0.7 HR9 3.0 BB9 5.0 SO9
VS
3. Mordecai “Three Finger” Brown (R) - 58.3 WAR 43.8 WAR7 2.06 ERA 139 ERA+ 2.41 FIP 1.066 WHIP 7.7 H9 0.1 HR9 1.9 BB9 3.9 SO9



4. Eppa Rixey (L) - 55.4 WAR 33.7 WAR7 3.15 ERA 115 ERA+ 3.29 FIP 1.272 WHIP 9.3 H9 0.2 HR9 2.2 BB9 2.7 SO9
VS
4. David Price (L) - 37.9 WAR 32.2 WAR7 3.25 ERA 124 ERA+ 3.34 FIP 1.144 WHIP 8.0 H9 0.9 HR9 2.3 BB9 8.7 SO9



5. Bret Saberhagen (R) - 59.0 WAR 43.3 WAR7 3.34 ERA 126 ERA+ 3.27 FIP 1.141 WHIP 8.6 H9 0.8 HR9 1.7 BB9 6.0 SO9
VS
5. Kevin Brown (R) - 68.0 WAR 45.2 WAR7 3.28 ERA 127 ERA+ 3.33 FIP 1.222 WHIP 8.5 H9 0.6 HR9 2.5 BB9 6.6 SO9

Just was curious about the numbers and it was pretty close. Obviously you could compare more numbers but I just did a quick comparison.

Femur has edge on #2 and #3 but I had the advantage on my #1 and #5. #4 starters were pretty even, I think Rixey is pretty overrated though.

the winner of each IMO

Maddux
Feller
Palmer
Rixey
Brown

 

[Shanemansj13]

the winner of each IMO

Maddux
Feller
Palmer
Rixey
Brown

Nope but close.

Rixey was overrated man. Either way, the rotations are VERY CLOSE.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Nope but close.

Rixey was overrated man. Either way, the rotations are VERY CLOSE.

Rixey was definitely over-rated... But he is facing David Price in the comparison... David Price had some good years, but he is far from a HOFer... Eppa Rixey is a HOF, and deservedly so...

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Nope but close.

Rixey was overrated man. Either way, the rotations are VERY CLOSE.

and absolutely Maddux is better than Matthewson... I would say that that is almost NOT close...