MBBRL dynasty main page

[Shanemansj13]

Done! @MilkSpiller22 , please approve.

Btw, why do you have to approve every trade?

I hope we can get it approved before 5 Et when the games start

@MilkSpiller22

 

[Chef99]

It's a blockbuster!

Buster gets:
Kevin Gausman
Andrew Benintendi
2023 first rounder from Soggy

Soggy gets:
Mookie Betts
Nestor Cortes
2023 2nd rounder from Buster.

Pleasure, @Shanemansj13!

 

[bksballer89]

Was the schedule fixed? Just noticed i am playing league avg again

 

[Chef99]

Woo Hoo, a new-look hitting lineup for the Boyz!

Watch out y'all, I'm comin' for ya!

 

[Chef99]

Um, not for nothin' @Yellow Fuzzies , but your roster seems to be totally illegal for this week.

 

[Chef99]

As a matter of fact, there a few teams with illegal rosters. Who is Stakes?

@MilkSpiller22

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

Um, not for nothin' @Yellow Fuzzies , but your roster seems to be totally illegal for this week.

I just looked.
My roster seems OK to me. why illegal?
@Chef99

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

On another note- I am playing league average twice this period. Is this right?

 

[Chef99]

I just looked.
My roster seems OK to me. why illegal?
@Chef99

Maybe it's the crazy settings. It says you have a buncha guys in the minors who shouldn't be.

 

[TKOSpikes]

Maybe it's the crazy settings. It says you have a buncha guys in the minors who shouldn't be.

Any minor leaguers that get promoted are able to stay in the minor league roster. If you promote them in fantasy, they cannot be returned to minors unless demoted in real life.

It shows illegal on the lineup page, but it isn’t illegal as per our league rules.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Any minor leaguers that get promoted are able to stay in the minor league roster. If you promote them in fantasy, they cannot be returned to minors unless demoted in real life.

It shows illegal on the lineup page, but it isn’t illegal as per our league rules.

its illegal... but i have always found it stupid to give ZERO points to the illegal lineup... problem is without the ZERO lineup, it is very hard to police it...

 

[TKOSpikes]

its illegal... but i have always found it stupid to give ZERO points to the illegal lineup... problem is without the ZERO lineup, it is very hard to police it...

I’ve read back through the thread and can’t find where the ruling was made clear.

Page 30 seems to claim the contrary without rebuttal.

 

[Chef99]

Any minor leaguers that get promoted are able to stay in the minor league roster. If you promote them in fantasy, they cannot be returned to minors unless demoted in real life.

It shows illegal on the lineup page, but it isn’t illegal as per our league rules.

I've promoted Lodolo and returned him to the minors and then promoted him again. Not sure what you mean.

 

[TKOSpikes]

its illegal... but i have always found it stupid to give ZERO points to the illegal lineup... problem is without the ZERO lineup, it is very hard to police it...

Your post #595 says the opposite

 

[Chef99]

its illegal... but i have always found it stupid to give ZERO points to the illegal lineup... problem is without the ZERO lineup, it is very hard to police it...

You've got one team that has six roster violations.

So...what you're saying is, it's ok for teams not to police themselves?

 

[TKOSpikes]

I've promoted Lodolo and returned him to the minors and then promoted him again. Not sure what you mean.

It’s quite the clusterphuck

I see no clear answer in this thread.

 

[Chef99]

Your post #595 says the opposite

League rules on Fantrax pretty much spell it out.

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

League rules on Fantrax pretty much spell it out.

Well let's clarify. I was under the assumption that if you did not promote a minors then he could stay a minors. I am OK either way let's just get it straight and I will adjust my thinking and lineup in the future.
@Chef99 @TKOSpikes @MilkSpiller22

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

League rules on Fantrax pretty much spell it out.

So does your lineup become illegal for the week if a guy is promoted during the period and you don't move him? That makes no sense.

 

[Chef99]

Well let's clarify. I was under the assumption that if you did not promote a minors then he could stay a minors. I am OK either way let's just get it straight and I will adjust my thinking and lineup in the future.
@Chef99 @TKOSpikes @MilkSpiller22

Not trying to throw you under the bus, Fuzzy. It's just that I've adjusted my roster, dropped and promoted people every time I get a notification. If I'd known I didn't need to do that, it would be a whole different ballgame.