Least favorite Giant

[ColinCoby]

I believe we discussed this topic some months ago. Now SFGATE is taking up the topic. Who is your least favorite Giant of all time?

Time to vote.

Who is your least favorite Giant? | San Francisco Giants: The Splash | an SFGate.com blog

 

[calsnowskier]

I almost voted for someone else just so the vote would not be unanimous...

I was surprised that Weezy was on the list. I was never a huge fan of his shtick, but he was a great Giant. I do not think he belonged on the list.

 

[SFGRTB]

How is RayRay on this list? I know he had one bad year with us, but we weren't going anywhere with that team. He was one of my favorite old guys, besides Randy Winn. I still miss that guy :/

And why the F*ck are Bonds and B-Weez on this list? And how are they both ahead of Miguel Tejada? And why is Jeff Kent so high?! Jesus people!

 

[SFGRTB]

I didn't like Blownitez, but it's not like we were a winning team when he was here so it's not as bad IMO. But he was so terrible.

 

[SFAnthem]

I didn't like Blownitez, but it's not like we were a winning team when he was here so it's not as bad IMO. But he was so terrible.

nothing redeemable about Blownitez, remember when he tried to give himself the nickname "Big Papi"?

 

[SFGRTB]

nothing redeemable about Blownitez, remember when he tried to give himself the nickname "Big Papi"?

The memory that sticks in my mind is the time he blew the save bucause he balked Jose Reyes all the way home and lost the game on a Delgado home run, all in extra innings in Shea stadium.

 

[tzill]

Blownitez was bad, but nobody can top AJ Crotchpunch.

Nobody.

/thread

 

[SF11704]

Blownitez was bad, but nobody can top AJ Crotchpunch.

Nobody.

/thread

1,000,000 times yes!
There have been quite a few Giants that I thought sucked while they played for us but I can't say I disliked them as a person. It was about their contribution.

AJ Crotchpunch was that one exception. I thought, and still think that he is a good talent with the most disturbing fucking attitude that ever graced a Giant roster. He was like a cancer to our team.

 

[BigDDude]

1,000,000 times yes!
There have been quite a few Giants that I thought sucked while they played for us but I can't say I disliked them as a person. It was about their contribution.

AJ Crotchpunch was that one exception. I thought, and still think that he is a good talent with the most disturbing fucking attitude that ever graced a Giant roster. He was like a cancer to our team.

To say nothing of the fact that, to get him for that one bad year, you had to give up both Joe Nathan & Francisco Liriano.

 

[BigDDude]

And why the F*ck are Bonds and B-Weez on this list? And how are they both ahead of Miguel Tejada? And why is Jeff Kent so high?! Jesus people!

Is this sarcasm? Or, do you not know how much these guys are hated outside of Giants fans? Hell, I liked what Kent did for the Dodgers why he was there, but I still always thought he was a blowhard D-bag.

 

[Mays-Fan]

Is this sarcasm? Or, do you not know how much these guys are hated outside of Giants fans? Hell, I liked what Kent did for the Dodgers why he was there, but I still always thought he was a blowhard D-bag.

Probably Kent voting for Bonds, and Bonds voting for Kent - lots of times.

 

[Mays-Fan]

Blownitez was bad, but nobody can top AJ Crotchpunch.

Nobody.

/thread

Michael Barrett agrees, and casts his ballot:

 

[Heathbar012]

Michael Barrett agrees, and casts his ballot:

... and immediately becomes the Bay Area's favorite Cub of All-Time.

 

[calsnowskier]

I loved it during the World Series, when AJ was working with FOX during the broadcast, Eric Karros said he felt safe in the stand with AJ because all the hatred that would normally be directed at him (Karros) was instead directed at AJ.

That prompted AJs famous "Once a Giant, always a Giant" comment.

 

[BigDDude]

I loved it during the World Series, when AJ was working with FOX during the broadcast, Eric Karros said he felt safe in the stand with AJ because all the hatred that would normally be directed at him (Karros) was instead directed at AJ.

That prompted AJs famous "Once a Giant, always a Giant" comment.

He said that? Really? Wow. Just,........wow.

 

[Mays-Fan]

... and immediately becomes the Bay Area's favorite Cub of All-Time.

Perhaps I should have said that Barrett punched in his candidate.

 

[Heathbar012]

Perhaps I should have said that Barrett punched in his candidate.

Hey-yo!

 

[Heathbar012]

He said that? Really? Wow. Just,........wow.

Yeah. Douche. So douchey he almost made Karros look cool.

 

[SFGRTB]

Is this sarcasm? Or, do you not know how much these guys are hated outside of Giants fans? Hell, I liked what Kent did for the Dodgers why he was there, but I still always thought he was a blowhard D-bag.

Oh yeah, I understand how hated these guys are outside of the Giants fan base- but that is a Giants paper asking the question, so Giants fans are answering that question. I kinda understand Kent, since he went to teh Dodgers, but last time he appearing in SF he was given a warm welcome back. And Bonds to Giants fans I thought would be a no brainier, but evidently not.

I'll have to agree with Mays here, Kent voting for Bonds and Bonds voting for Kent

 

[ColinCoby]

Is this sarcasm? Or, do you not know how much these guys are hated outside of Giants fans? Hell, I liked what Kent did for the Dodgers why he was there, but I still always thought he was a blowhard D-bag.

Yep...but he was our D-Bag! (both of them!)

I look back fondly at both Bonds and Kent in a Giants uni, despite the douchey behavior and roid use.