Kaepernick/Julius Thomas or Rodgers

[The Foot]

This is a full keeper IDP league.

Who would you guys rather have?

 

[Trudem]

That one is actually pretty tough. Im not a huge fan of Kaep but his legs make him better tha average in fantasy and Thomas will be second at TE as long as he has Manning, which is at most two seasons.

For me it would hinge on who you currently have at TE.

 

[The Foot]

clay and gates plus the young atl tiolo, oak rivera.

 

[TKOSpikes]

Sorry Foot, I still don't think it's enough. Maybe if Rodgers was Brady's age. He still has elite production ability for another five years or so.

 

[Trudem]

I would keep Rodgers

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Sorry Foot, I still don't think it's enough. Maybe if Rodgers was Brady's age. He still has elite production ability for another five years or so.

yup - it'd be too hard for me to let Rodgers go in a dynasty league. I'd probably rank him or Luck as the #1 QB in that format right now, just cause it won't matter who is WRs are in 5 years, he will still be a stud, imo.

Also - that gives you at least 3-4 more seasons of trying to lock down your next franchise QB that will take over for Rodgers, and I think you'll be able to do better than Kaepernick in that time frame. Same goes for TE - you should be able to find one this season or next while Clay bridges you through.

 

[HammerDown]

I would keep Rodgers

Absolutely this.

 

[Barilko]

yup - it'd be too hard for me to let Rodgers go in a dynasty league. I'd probably rank him or Luck as the #1 QB in that format right now, just cause it won't matter who is WRs are in 5 years, he will still be a stud, imo.

Also - that gives you at least 3-4 more seasons of trying to lock down your next franchise QB that will take over for Rodgers, and I think you'll be able to do better than Kaepernick in that time frame. Same goes for TE - you should be able to find one this season or next while Clay bridges you through.

Im With Monkey and the rest Rodgers to valuable...

 

[averagejoe]

Ok, I'll be the opposing view. I like Rodgers. I do. But as good as the guy is, he takes a beating behind a horrible O-line. He's been concussed twice and had a broken collarbone. 2014 will be his 10th season.

Kaps and JT are much younger. Kaps could have had a softmore slump last year (as the starter - even though it was his 3rd year). And JT is generally the 2nd or 3rd TE off the board (before/after Gronk).

Rodgers is tempting alone, but the pairing of Kaps and JT would have me leaning toward them.

 

[SteelersPride]

safe bet me and keep rodgers