John Farrell or Joe Girardi Who'd Win In A Fight?

[redseat]

With the recent dust up between the Red Sox and Yankees. Dempster v A-Rod the question arises..... If the two managers were to get into a fight who would win? Farrell or Girardi?

Both managers are big and would put up a good fight but I might give the slight edge to Girardi

So what say you....

 

[redseat]

And does anyone think they would even fight or just let the players have at it?

 

[redseat]

 

[redseat]

 

[BF4L]

Farrell or Girardi?

Humm thats a tough call. Farrell has the size advantage but I think Girardi is borderline lunatic so I guess I am gonna go with Girardi

 

[BF4L]

Tale of the tape

Farrell 6'4 210

Girardi 5'11 195

Course that may have been their playing weight

 

[redseat]

Farrell or Girardi?

Humm thats a tough call. Farrell has the size advantage but I think Girardi is borderline lunatic so I guess I am gonna go with Girardi

yEAH, GIRARDI EVENTHOUGH POSSIBLY SMALLER THAN FARRELL I THINK IS MORE OF A LUNATIC

 

[redseat]

Tale of the tape

Farrell 6'4 210

Girardi 5'11 195

Course that may have been their playing weight

I thought Girardi was bigger than 195 but I guess not. Though in a fight sometimes the skinnier guy wins

 

[steveringo]

A fine question.

Farrell has the size advantage, but Girardi is a little bit younger. John was a pitcher and Joe, a catcher. Girardi also has the ‘roid rage on top of his lunatic demeanor.

Advantage, JOE.

 

[ImSmartherThanYou]

My dad could beat up your dad.

But if I were to approach this topic seriously, I don't see how the answer isn't Joe. He is in incredible shape. He was a catcher, so he's obviously got a tolerance for pain and is a little crazy (and I say this as a former pitcher). He's obviously got a big temper. He's also probably got some Little Man Syndrome going on. He was the son of a veteran and grew up in a blue collar home (vs. Farrell growing up a surfer in an affluent Jersey Shore town a couple towns over from mine), and probably got his ass whipped on the regular. The only advantage Farrell has is size.

 

[redseat]

yeah I went the catcher root as well and I picked Girardi

 

[Omar 382]

girardi probably. i wish he had stood 4 inches closer to that umpire when he threw his arm... if he made good contact he might have gotten a 50 game suspension

 

[redseat]

I tried to post a poll at the top to start this thread but it didn't work

 

[Craig Anderson]

Heh heh heh.... that's a good one! I could see Girardi fighting dirty. He'd probably try to bite Farrell or poke him in the eyes.

 

[ImSmartherThanYou]

Heh heh heh.... that's a good one! I could see Girardi fighting dirty. He'd probably try to bite Farrell or poke him in the eyes.

If he had to resort to that, I have no doubt he'd punch him in the nuts. Like I said... Little Man Syndrome. Anything to beat the bigger guy.

 

[$500 Million]

An Irishman and an Italian.


It would be a hell of a fight, that's for sure.

 

[redseat]

An Irishman and an Italian.


It would be a hell of a fight, that's for sure.

HBO Special coming soon!

 

[Chef99]

Farrell's got the reach. He'd bonk Girardi on top of his head like he was in a Bugs Bunny cartoon.

 

[redseat]

Farrell's got the reach. He'd bonk Girardi on top of his head like he was in a Bugs Bunny cartoon.

Yeah he does. I still see Girardi coming back with a nasty right hook and knocking Farrell out however.

 

[ImSmartherThanYou]

Farrell's got the reach. He'd bonk Girardi on top of his head like he was in a Bugs Bunny cartoon.

Two words: Cock Punch

It's already been mentioned that Girardi would likely fight dirty. If Farrell's height and reach advantage looked like a real obstacle, Girardi would go low, literally and figuratively.