POLL Is Brady the GOAT with a SB win this year?

[tedman2012]

Sorry but AFC is going to win it. Ne/Pitt has been to SB 9 times and GB/Atl once last 15 years

the hottest qb is rogers . I was shocked not a single wildcard team won a game .

 

[sonnyblack65]

the hottest qb is rogers . I was shocked not a single wildcard team won a game .

Rogers is great, Ryan has been and of Brady is ok

 

[Ricky Roma]

You and Purguy are cool and Roma hangs on to the past.

Translation: I post opinions/facts that have yet to be refuted? I'll consider that a compliment.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Translation: I post opinions/facts that have yet to be refuted? I'll consider that a compliment.

Translation you prove dog shit, but it's all good

 

[Hank Kingsley]

Rogers is great, Ryan has been and of Brady is ok

Sounds like you are preparing for a Pats loss sonnyb.

I say Brady has been winning. Which is all that one can ask. Just win baby and all that.

I honestly smell a 5th SB coming up. It's a team game, top to bottom.

Bill, Tom and the rest. All have done their jobs and then some.

Tomorrow I look forward to Brown vs Butler. And what Bill does to stop Bell and Ben.

But Brady is going to have a superb game, just watch.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Sounds like you are preparing for a Pats loss sonnyb.

I say Brady has been winning. Which is all that one can ask. Just win baby and all that.

I honestly smell a 5th SB coming up. It's a team game, top to bottom.

Bill, Tom and the rest. All have done their jobs and then some.

Tomorrow I look forward to Brown vs Butler. And what Bill does to stop Bell and Ben.

But Brady is going to have a superb game, just watch.

Ahhh no just giving the good QBs props

 

[NEhomer]

I think the Pats got their clunker out of the way and still covered a ridiculous spread.

* Brock is not Ben. Still.

 

[NEPatsfan]

I think the Pats got their clunker out of the way and still covered a ridiculous spread.

* Brock is not Ben. Still.

Why is the spread ridiculous? It's exactly where it should be, and isn't about what the outcome will be, but about getting as close to a 50/50 split on what people think the outcome will be.

 

[Ricky Roma]

Translation you prove dog shit

No...Brady isn't dog shit....but I have shown that his overall playoff performance doesn't match the mindless groupthink, and certainly isn't on the same level as....well you know.

 

[NEPatsfan]

No...Brady isn't dog shit....but I have shown that his overall playoff performance doesn't match the mindless groupthink, and certainly isn't on the same level as....well you know.

You haven't shown anything. He leads or is near the top in every category. You simply just love Joe more, it's OK to say that, but that won't change the stats.

 

[Ricky Roma]

....'says' the guy who thinks Johnny Unitas' stats weren't all that great.

 

[NEPatsfan]

....'says' the guy who thinks Johnny Unitas' stats weren't all that great.

Except that isn't what I said. They were for his time, but not when compared to the greats that have come after him.

 

[Ricky Roma]

Except that isn't what I said. They were for his time, but not when compared to the greats that have come after him.

....and this is where your credibility, or lack thereof, is full on display. The amount of games played/rules adjusting said passing game/total amount of passes attempted, has completely changed. Your inability to grasp what is painfully obvious is stunning, as the only way to make any comparison of stats from guys 20, 30, 40, 50+ years ago, is to those in his own era....

...unless he somehow actually outperforms the current generation. You know...like a guy about 30 years ago and how he raised his overall playoff performances to another level while a guy today doesn't even come close?

 

[NEPatsfan]

....and this is where your credibility, or lack thereof, is full on display. The amount of games played/rules adjusting said passing game/total amount of passes attempted, has completely changed. Your inability to grasp what is painfully obvious is stunning, as the only way to make any comparison of stats from guys 20, 30, 40, 50+ years ago, is to those in his own era....

...unless he somehow actually outperforms the current generation. You know...like a guy about 30 years ago and how he raised his overall playoff performances to another level while a guy today doesn't even come close?

So if he played a couple more games a season his avg yards per game & completion % would go up, and his int % would go down?

And as for comparing him in his era, I already stated he was the greatest, now when you move on from that era he doesn't hold up and since been surpassed by the likes of Joe, and now Tom.

Could you be anymore desperate to try and undermine reality?

 

[Ricky Roma]

So if he played a couple more games a season his avg yards per game & completion % would go up, and his int % would go down?


Could be anymore desperate to try and undermine reality?

...while conveniently IGNORING the FACT the rule changes? You know...the tiny little thing that fully, completely and factually rips you apart? You're the desperate one trying undermine reality. You just said Unitas' numbers were good for their time.

 

[NEPatsfan]

...while conveniently IGNORING the FACT the rule changes? You know...the tiny little thing that fully, completely and factually rips you apart? You're the desperate one trying undermine reality. You just said Unitas' numbers were good for their time.

Not ignoring them at all. The disparity between them is so great it negates it from the statistical argument.

 

[Ricky Roma]

Not ignoring them at all. The disparity between them is so great it negates it from the statistical argument.

Yet, you had no trouble posting a link that led to a bunch of bulk numbers at face value to 'prove' your point? It's funny watching you fully torpedo your own argument with every post....

 

[NEPatsfan]

Yet, you had no trouble posting a link that led to a bunch of bulk numbers at face value to 'prove' your point? It's funny watching you fully torpedo your own argument with every post....

The cognitive dissonance you show during this discussion is comical, all in an attempt to protect your beloved Joe.

Which link by the way, I post lots of them?

 

[Ricky Roma]

The cognitive dissonance you show during this discussion is comical, all in an attempt to protect your beloved Joe.

...'says' the guy who destroys his own arguments, provides links to stats at bulk/face value, flops around Unitas' numbers, etc. etc. If you find it funny that you can't keep up with basic common sense, then that is on you. The link in question? Post #118. You know...authored by a Patriot fanboi? The one I laughed at, exposed as flawed at best, and undercut his hero with his own logic.

A point that still basically remains unchallenged.

 

[NEPatsfan]

...'says' the guy who destroys his own arguments, provides links to stats at bulk/face value, flops around Unitas' numbers, etc. etc. If you find it funny that you can't keep up with basic common sense, then that is on you. The link in question? Post #118. You know...authored by a Patriot fanboi? The one I laughed at, exposed as flawed at best, and undercut his hero with his own logic.

A point that still basically remains unchallenged.

You didn't expose anything.

Unitas was great for his time, he however is not the GOAT, nor is Joe. It's now Tom.

You just can't seem to come to terms with it.