Is Baker Mayfield a Bust?

[Stakesarehigh]

that includes "on the Ravens" lol

 

[broncosmitty]

just thought of this

playoff wins

Baker 2
Lamar 1

@broncosmitty

Baker also more arrests, if we’re keeping score.

And has played for three more teams. And gotten a lot more coaches fired.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Baker also more arrests, if we’re keeping score.

And has played for three more teams. And gotten a lot more coaches fired.

yeah, but that is for street cred!

 

[Schmoopy1000]

I don't know what the future will be for BM, but I know this at the present time.

the Browns lost to the team that they mortgaged their future to get their sexual predator QB Watson. The QB that they ran out of town the season after leading them to their first playoff road win in decades just destroyed last year SB runner up.

Congrats Browns keep up the good work.

 

[wilwhite]

Is Mayfield really the best QB in franchise history like the tweet is saying? No way! Otto Graham and Bernie Kosar are better. Otto Graham is certifiably great.

The franchise that had Kosar and Graham is now the Ravens.

Somehow the new Browns get to credit the old Browns as the same team but it's not.

Of the new Browns, Mayfield is the best.

 

[Stakesarehigh]

The franchise that had Kosar and Graham is now the Ravens.

Somehow the new Browns get to credit the old Browns as the same team but it's not.

Of the new Browns, Mayfield is the best.

its not somehow. That was part of the deal at the time. That the Browns retained their history.

I understand it makes no sense and is unprecedented but it comes to be when your dirty fuck owner destroys the franchise of what is basically an original team.

 

[wilwhite]

its not somehow. That was part of the deal at the time. That the Browns retained their history.

I understand it makes no sense and is unprecedented but it comes to be when your dirty fuck owner destroys the franchise of what is basically an original team.

The city got to retain the team history and bestow it on an entirely new team, which didn't even exist yet and certainly hadn't earned it.

The Browns leaving is up there with the Brooklyn Dodgers leaving for awful sports stories.

 

[PDay8810]

Tenn. playing Houston in Oiler throwbacks was cold.

 

[Wamu]

The franchise that had Kosar and Graham is now the Ravens. <--

Somehow the new Browns get to credit the old Browns as the same team but it's not.

Of the new Browns, Mayfield is the best.

No the Ravens aren't the Browns. Here's why. Gonna start with the Baltimore Colts.

When the Irsay's moved them outta town in the middle of night all of the teams record went with them to Indy. When Peyton set all the career passing marks for the franchise he broke all of Johnny U's records.

If the Ravens are really the Browns then Jim Brown would be the teams all time leading rusher (it's actually Jamal Lewis) and Paul Brown would be the teams winningest coach (Harbaugh is the franchises winningest coach).

The Browns were in the unique position that when the franchise moved all the teams records stayed in Cleveland.

 

[Moab]

As it stands right now, does Baker have more playoff wins than Lamar?

 

[Wamu]

As it stands right now, does Baker have more playoff wins than Lamar?

Oh that's mean. But funny as hell!

 

[msgkings322]

As it stands right now, does Baker have more playoff wins than Lamar?

Jimmy G has more than both of them combined

Wins are not a QB stat

 

[psaboy]

His commercials really sucked though. Glad they stopped that crap.

 

[Stlducks]

Baker is a tier 3 QB imo. Would that be considered a bust based on where he was drafted?

QBs drafted number 1 overall since 2010
Young
Lawrence
Burrow
Murray
Mayfield
Goff
Winston
Luck
Newton
Bradford

Based on where he was drafted, he's average imo.

 

[Stakesarehigh]

Baker is a tier 3 QB imo. Would that be considered a bust based on where he was drafted?

QBs drafted number 1 overall since 2010
Young
Lawrence
Burrow
Murray
Mayfield
Goff
Winston
Luck
Newton
Bradford

Based on where he was drafted, he's average imo.

anyone arguing differently would be lying. Some opportunity he improves... but unlikely he's ever more than 10 to 15

 

[Stakesarehigh]

Jimmy G has more than both of them combined

Wins are not a QB stat

you do realize that is just me fucking with smitty right

clearly Lamar has had a better career

 

[Schmoopy1000]

anyone arguing differently would be lying. Some opportunity he improves... but unlikely he's ever more than 10 to 15

Agreed.
he is a starting QB & he even has an "IT" factor. Players like playing for him.
but as a QB he isnt gonna ever be some great player. But he will be a gamer.

 

[msgkings322]

Agreed.
he is a starting QB & he even has an "IT" factor. Players like playing for him.
but as a QB he isnt gonna ever be some great player. But he will be a gamer.

I think we can close the thread with this. Baker is not a bust.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I think we can close the thread with this. Baker is not a bust.

I don't know, if Mayfield has a terrible game today the talk of him being a bust will continue.

 

[msgkings322]

I don't know, if Mayfield has a terrible game today the talk of him being a bust will continue.

Well sure. Stupid people will always be with us.