Golden Tate or Cecil Shorts more worthy of a roster spot?

[ZepTepi]

I don't usually find myself this stumped but I just can't come to a decision so I'll solicit for your opinions.

Who would you rather have as your WR5 Golden Tate or Cecil Shorts? This is a PPR league.


My current WRs are:

WR1 Julio Jones
WR2 Demaryius Thomas
WR3 Michael Floyd
WR4 Justin Hunter
WR5 Golden Tate

Thanks for your thoughts.

 

[SteelersPride]

golden tate, high powered offense

cecil shorts, horrid offense, horrid oline, rookie qb

easy for me

 

[ZepTepi]

golden tate, high powered offense

cecil shorts, horrid offense, horrid oline, rookie qb

easy for me

Those were my initial thoughts as well but if Bortles can just be a passable QB the rest of the season, which isn't outside the realm of possibility, Shorts could put up great #s because Jax will be playing from behind most of the season and should be passing alot. That coupled with the fact that I have had a hard time seeing the potential Tate since he came into the league makes me question his ability to put up big #s even in a high powered offense. All that being said, I can't dismiss him yet which is why I'm on the fence.

 

[SteelersPride]

trust me im no tate fan, but even with jax passing alot, they still suck

 

[ZepTepi]

trust me im no tate fan, but even with jax passing alot, they still suck

Dually noted! Thanks SP

 

[jeffro151]

Tate easily