Evaluate This Trade

[redseat]

12 team keeper league h2h points (I'm not involved)

Miguel Cabrera and Steven Wright

FOR

Trevor Story
Jose Abreu
Miguel Sano

 

[obxyankeefan]

In a keeper league, I like the team getting Abreu and Story.

Cabrera will start sliding in the next few years. Wright will not keep up with the numbers he has now.

Abreu can get you close to Cabrerra numbers. Story gives you a slightly above average SS for years to come. Sano I am not as high on as others.

 

[redseat]

In a keeper league, I like the team getting Abreu and Story.

Cabrera will start sliding in the next few years. Wright will not keep up with the numbers he has now.

Abreu can get you close to Cabrerra numbers. Story gives you a slightly above average SS for years to come. Sano I am not as high on as others.

Do you think it's a fair trade?

 

[obxyankeefan]

Do you think it's a fair trade?

Yes.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Its fair enough. But it is not a good trade.

 

[obxyankeefan]

Its fair enough. But it is not a good trade.

Just interested Milk, but why would you not like it.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Just interested Milk, but why would you not like it.

Jose Abreu and miggy play the same position. At this point they are already close enough that in w keeper league you want Abreu more.

Steven wright is a knuckle ball pitcher. The one thing we have learned about the knuckleball is that it is inconsistent some seasons he may be good while others he won't be. So he is far from a good keeper


Story, he is certainly over valued at this point but he does play SS. You are willing to gamble with his bad to keep his good.

Then you have sano, he has not yet become what is expected of him but he is an elite talent.

So for the future it is no contest the story,sano, Abreu side wins
For now miggy might be the best player but Abreu is close enough that the extreme future loss makes this a bad trade.

Not to mention story is having a pretty good start of season

 

[MilkSpiller22]

And if Steven wright falls apart this season would anyone be surprised??? That's knuckleball for you.

 

[redseat]

And if Steven wright falls apart this season would anyone be surprised??? That's knuckleball for you.

Yeah knuckleballers are a hit or miss thing... Look at Wakefield

 

[Chef99]

Seriously, who even cares about Steven Wright? In a keeper, gimme those 3 guys.

 

[buster]

Story, Abreu & Sano side wins hands down.
Miggy's best days are behind him; if either Sano or Story reach full potential, this will be lopsided.
Wright is a non-factor, IMO.

 

[tlance]

This is a pretty bad trade in a keeper league. Not vetoable, but pretty bad. Give me Abreu over Miggy all day, Story over Wright all day and then you get Sano for free.

 

[redseat]

This is a pretty bad trade in a keeper league. Not vetoable, but pretty bad. Give me Abreu over Miggy all day, Story over Wright all day and then you get Sano for free.

I couldn't even veto if I wanted too. Only the commissioner has that power.