Do I do this trade?

[redseat]

6 Team League

PPR

I TRADE:

Alvin Kamara

I GET:

Kenneth Walker III
Deebo Samuel SR

MY CURRENT TEAM:

QB - Daniels, Mayfield, Richardson
RB - Kamara, B Robinson, Etienne Jr, Najee
WR - Devonta Smith, St. Brown, Jefferson, Harrison Jr, Olave

 

[redseat]

Also - I should add that I am in LAST place

 

[redseat]

@averagejoe
@TREFF
@MilkSpiller22

I always draw a blank at people I need to tag

 

[redseat]

@Chef99
@Wild Turkey

 

[redseat]

I guess

He sent 2 trade offers:

Other was:

Kamara

For

B Robinson Jr and Deboo

 

[MilkSpiller22]

6 Team League

PPR

I TRADE:

Alvin Kamara

I GET:

Kenneth Walker III
Deebo Samuel SR

MY CURRENT TEAM:

QB - Daniels, Mayfield, Richardson
RB - Kamara, B Robinson, Etienne Jr, Najee
WR - Devonta Smith, St. Brown, Jefferson, Harrison Jr, Olave

tricky question as your WRs are disgustingly good... even with Harrison and Olave potentially missing games...

your running situation is your weakness...

i have Kamara slightly ahead of Walker, and the fact that Walker seems to get hurt more often makes that a little bit larger of a discrepency...

i guess it all depends on how many WRs you can start... i would not want to push Smith to the bench to make this trade...

if it was face value, you would win this trade hands down...

but in a 6 team league, and with your WRs... i would probably pass...

 

[redseat]

tricky question as your WRs are disgustingly good... even with Harrison and Olave potentially missing games...

your running situation is your weakness...

i have Kamara slightly ahead of Walker, and the fact that Walker seems to get hurt more often makes that a little bit larger of a discrepency...

i guess it all depends on how many WRs you can start... i would not want to push Smith to the bench to make this trade...

if it was face value, you would win this trade hands down...

but in a 6 team league, and with your WRs... i would probably pass...

Thank you!

He also offered me

Bijon Robinson Jr and Deebo for Kamara

As far as how many WR you can start = 2 and a FLEX

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Thank you!

He also offered me

Bijon Robinson Jr and Deebo for Kamara

As far as how many WR you can start = 2 and a FLEX

''dont you have bijon??

did he offer brian robinson?? if it is Bijon, then make the deal... he is better than Kamara...

but i am pretty sure you mean Brian....

 

[redseat]

''dont you have bijon??

did he offer brian robinson?? if it is Bijon, then make the deal... he is better than Kamara...

but i am pretty sure you mean Brian....

Sorry yes I mean he is offering me Brian Robinson

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Sorry yes I mean he is offering me Brian Robinson

walker is better than robinson... so if you are to do either you should take the walker trade...

but again, i would probably pass... but it really is close... as walker is close to Kamara...

generally speaking in these trades, i would only be looking at my starting roster.... if my roster is not getting better because of a trade, there is no reason to do it... improving your bench is only going to make you make the wrong decisions week to week.....

and you are never going to bench Jefferson and St Brown... other than their bye weeks or injured weeks...

 

[TREFF]

6 Team League

PPR

I TRADE:

Alvin Kamara

I GET:

Kenneth Walker III
Deebo Samuel SR

MY CURRENT TEAM:

QB - Daniels, Mayfield, Richardson
RB - Kamara, B Robinson, Etienne Jr, Najee
WR - Devonta Smith, St. Brown, Jefferson, Harrison Jr, Olave

I do it

 

[redseat]

walker is better than robinson... so if you are to do either you should take the walker trade...

but again, i would probably pass... but it really is close... as walker is close to Kamara...

generally speaking in these trades, i would only be looking at my starting roster.... if my roster is not getting better because of a trade, there is no reason to do it... improving your bench is only going to make you make the wrong decisions week to week.....

and you are never going to bench Jefferson and St Brown... other than their bye weeks or injured weeks...

Very valid points!

I am considering since I am in last place so it doesn't hurt that much if I do it

 

[redseat]

I do it

and get rid of Kamara?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Very valid points!

I am considering since I am in last place so it doesn't hurt that much if I do it

Definitely doesn’t hurt that much. The downgrade from kamara to walker is not that big. And with the saints struggling like they are walker is likely to score more than kamara in many weeks.

But kamara is so much safer than walker. That I just feel more confident with him.

If I were you I would try to trade one of your QBs to upgrade your flex.

Both mayfield and Daniels are at peak value right now. And I am sure if you are losing it is because you have picked the wrong qb multiple times this season already.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

See if he'll trade you Walker and Robinson for Kamara, you need more RBs

 

[redseat]

See if he'll trade you Walker and Robinson for Kamara, you need more RBs

Hmm... That's interesting.. Wonder if he would do it

 

[leftypower]

6 Team League
PPR
I TRADE:
Alvin Kamara (bye 12)

I GET:
Kenneth Walker III (bye 10)
Deebo Samuel SR (bye 9)

MY CURRENT TEAM:

QB - Daniels (bye 14), Mayfield (bye 11), Richardson (bye 14)
RB - Kamara, B Robinson (bye 12) , Etienne Jr (bye 12), Najee (bye 9)
WR - Devonta Smith, St. Brown , Jefferson , Harrison Jr, Olave

Since the values are pretty equal, I'd consider the bye weeks as a tie-breaker. You are in good shape with WRs (Smith, St. Brown, Jefferson) are good rest of the season, Harrison (11) and Olave (12) do not share the same bye.. As it stands, Week 12 is going to be a big problem for you at RB. As Monkey stated I'd make the move for Walker/Robinson. You need no help at WR. To make room, I'd personally drop Richardson since he shares the same bye as Daniels (can't see you starting him over Daniels anyway.) Maybe move Richardson in that deal.
Making it - Richardson/Kamara for Walker/Robinson or perhaps a 3 for 3 by including Olave for Deebo.

 

[redseat]

Since the values are pretty equal, I'd consider the bye weeks as a tie-breaker. You are in good shape with WRs (Smith, St. Brown, Jefferson) are good rest of the season, Harrison (11) and Olave (12) do not share the same bye.. As it stands, Week 12 is going to be a big problem for you at RB. As Monkey stated I'd make the move for Walker/Robinson. You need no help at WR. To make room, I'd personally drop Richardson since he shares the same bye as Daniels (can't see you starting him over Daniels anyway.) Maybe move Richardson in that deal.
Making it - Richardson/Kamara for Walker/Robinson or perhaps a 3 for 3 by including Olave for Deebo.

Shit I'm FUCKED week 14 since we have to start 2 QBs

 

[leftypower]

Shit I'm FUCKED week 14 since we have to start 2 QBs

So this is superflex ??
If so, who does he have at QB - maybe instead of WR's as the third piece make it a QB swap.

 

[redseat]

So this is superflex ??
If so, who does he have at QB - maybe instead of WR's as the third piece make it a QB swap.

Jackson, Love and Murray