Division best

[Sharkonabicycle]

which is why the hawks should stop the steal, AND I'm the furthest thing a Texan can be from a Texas A&M fan.

BUT

For a good portion of my live the aggies won 5 for or less games but were always there in droves acting the part....smiles on their faces cause they got to kiss twice in 55-14 lose.

say what you want about Texas A&M University but they know all about the 12th man.

Seattle already settled that lawsuit... and the Aggies sold out like little bitches.

 

[PDay8810]

Seattle already settled that lawsuit... and the Aggies sold out like little bitches.

ok
point still stands

you have a good day Shark
lol

 

[ericd7633]

shock value draws attention. I'll just say towards #2. pun intended

should any of the other three win a super bowl, your boy is looking up.

clown show must stay outta the way and say as little as possible to win.

There isn't a close 2nd, at the moment. Yes, if someone in the division wins a SB, that would obviously change things. Quinn has had a good career, I'll admit that. Daboll has been terrible with the Giants, and Schottenheimer was fired in his two previous stops prior to coming to Dallas.

 

[Battlelyon]

I can generally agree with this.

Although I dunno about Seattle best fans at this point... the 12th man is not what it was during the early Carroll years. I think Seattle is starting to get more restrictive about secondary market resale of tickets, but there have been home games over the last couple years where the away team has more color in the stands than Seattle... and the false start counter is gone now. I know they raise the 12th man flag but it means nothing anymore.

Course it might just be by default. Cali (LA/San Fag) and Zona isn't any better lol.


Only other I might disagree with:

Best offensive player: I think CMAC is cooked. Yes he's great when healthy but he's now almost 30. I'd prob. still take Kittle because it's so hard to replace and I think JSN or Williams may just take that spot in 2025.

I might give the 9ers unis a nod also over the Rams but I have always liked the royal blue/gold. But the classic Niners red/gold is good too. Seattle MIGHT be able to get in the discussion if they ditched that dumbass lime green. Their retro jerseys are amazing.

LA and San Fran have too many phony fans, Cards fans are mostly nonexistent. So that leaves Seattle. Of course, San Fran has the most fans.

 

[PDay8810]

Schottenheimer was fired in his two previous stops prior to coming to Dallas.

assistant coaches get fired.
Kellen Moore twice as an example.

 

[ericd7633]

assistant coaches get fired.
Kellen Moore twice as an example.

Sure. So you think Schottenheimer is a better head coach than Sirianni? And Quinn and Daboll as well?

 

[jarntt]

1. Who is the best team in your division?

Eagles

2. Who is the best coach in your division?

Sirianni - not a particularly close 2nd

3. Who is the best offensive player in your division?

Saquon

4, Who is the best defensive player in your division?

Jalen Carter

5. Who has the best uniform in the division?

Eagles

6. Who has the best stadium in the division?

Eagles

7. Who has the best fans in your division?

Eagles

nvm @Xeliou66 you've just lost your "homer" crown. As expected from the morning line...an Eagles fan...

 

[ericd7633]

nvm @Xeliou66 you've just lost your "homer" crown. As expected from the morning line...an Eagles fan...

You're calling me the homer and think Schottenheimer is the best head coach in the division? Okay.

I'm open to discussion.

 

[jarntt]

You're calling me the homer and think Schottenheimer is the best head coach in the division? Okay.

I'm open to discussion.

There could have been 30 questions and you would have picked the Eagles for all 30. Your team wanted to fire your HC not long ago who you picked as the best coach. Best motivator? I'd give him that one. But, a Chimp could have gotten the Eagles team into the playoffs last year by pressing random decision buttons. Two years ago you had one of the biggest collapses in NFL history and he had a front row seat. He is not the strongest part of your team. He seems to have proven to be a good coach when he has good coordinators under him to do the X's and O's part.

Is Schotty the best? Who knows. It was more by default. We will see in the next couple of years. He could be the worst, he could be the best.

 

[ericd7633]

There could have been 30 questions and you would have picked the Eagles for all 30. Your team wanted to fire your HC not long ago who you picked as the best coach. Best motivator? I'd give him that one. But, a Chimp could have gotten the Eagles team into the playoffs last year by pressing random decision buttons. Two years ago you had one of the biggest collapses in NFL history and he had a front row seat. He is not the strongest part of your team. He seems to have proven to be a good coach when he has good coordinators under him to do the X's and O's part.

Is Schotty the best? Who knows. It was more by default. We will see in the next couple of years. He could be the worst, he could be the best.

That's definitely not true about 30 different questions. All those questions, when answered, so happen to be Eagles players. The last 3 are preference.

Sirianni is without a doubt the best coach in the division. Does he have a talented roster, yes that's obvious. But the numbers speak for themselves. I would agree he's not the strongest part of the Eagles. But we're comparing him to a first time HC, a HC one game over .500 and a coach 14 games under .500.

It is funny I get called a homer for picking the coach who's been to the playoffs every year he's been a HC, gone to the SB twice and won it. Yet you pick the coach who was probably Plan E as the best coach.

 

[jarntt]

That's definitely not true about 30 different questions. All those questions, when answered, so happen to be Eagles players. The last 3 are preference.

Sirianni is without a doubt the best coach in the division. Does he have a talented roster, yes that's obvious. But the numbers speak for themselves. I would agree he's not the strongest part of the Eagles. But we're comparing him to a first time HC, a HC one game over .500 and a coach 14 games under .500.

It is funny I get called a homer for picking the coach who's been to the playoffs every year he's been a HC, gone to the SB twice and won it. Yet you pick the coach who was probably Plan E as the best coach.

Yes, you are a homer. It wasn't a one question survey

 

[ericd7633]

Yes, you are a homer. It wasn't a one question survey

If me picking the coach who's been to two SB's and has won one, then yep, I guess I am. Let me know what else I went homer mode on.

 

[jarntt]

If me picking the coach who's been to two SB's and has won one, then yep, I guess I am. Let me know what else I went homer mode on.

It's the aggregate. Carter is better than Micah? Dexter Lawrence? Maybe eventually, but not yet
Eagles fans are the best? Probably one of the worst in the league even according to many Eagles fans who talk about how they totally trash the team when things are going poorly. How they act towards opposing fans?
Stadium? Uniform? You'd probably have voted for best chair angle or stadium temperature if those were categories without even thinking

 

[ericd7633]

It's the aggregate. Carter is better than Micah? Dexter Lawrence? Maybe eventually, but not yet
Eagles fans are the best? Probably one of the worst in the league even according t many Eagles fans who talk about how they trash the team when things are going poorly.
Stadium? Uniform? You'd probably have voted for best chair angle or stadium temperature if those were categories without even thinking

Carter was a 2nd team All-Pro last year. Micah was not. Lawrence is a good call. I'd be open to him replacing Carter, at least for now.

All the fanbases in the NFC East are shitty. They're all obnoxious. Lol.

And yes, an Eagles fan thinking we have the best uniforms and stadium. Wow. MetLife, from what I've read, and FedEx from having been there multiple times are shit. Jerry's world is obviously a good stadium but I've heard it doesn't get all that loud.

 

[Tainthappening]

And yes, an Eagles fan thinking we have the best uniforms and stadium. Wow. MetLife, from what I've read, and FedEx from having been there multiple times are shit. Jerry's world is obviously a good stadium but I've heard it doesn't get all that loud.

Eagles fans are notorious for being worst fans... can almost always be assured in Top 5 on lists of worst fans (if Eagles fan did perform the list).

 

[PDay8810]

Sure. So you think Schottenheimer is a better head coach than Sirianni? And Quinn and Daboll as well?

tbd
it's not a mountain, more like bump.

 

[ericd7633]

tbd
it's not a mountain, more like bump.

But we're ranking at this moment. Sirianni could win 2 more SB's if we're playing the hypothetical game.

 

[PDay8810]

But we're ranking at this moment. Sirianni could win 2 more SB's if we're playing the hypothetical game.

i keep responding and you move the goal post.

Sirianni might to the worst SB winning coach ever. We'll see...good luck pumping up this guy.

 

[ericd7633]

i keep responding and you move the goal post.

Sirianni might to the worst SB winning coach ever. We'll see...good luck pumping up this guy.

???

I'm moving the goal posts? Your initial response said if any of the other 3 win a SB, he'll be looking up at them. I'm just playing the hypothetical game you started and keep playing.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Eagles
Schottenheimer (just wait and see)
Barkley
Parsons
Cowboys
Cowboys
Cowboys