WizardHawk
Release the Kraken - Fuck the Canucks
He is mediocre. His rating benefits substantially from an awesome run game and is as inflated by your playing style as his cumulative stats are deflated, if not more.
While I agree calling him one of the best in the NFL right now is a bit over the top by my fellow hawks fans, he is above average for sure. There are many ways of measuring QB's and not all of them are based on stats. Late game come backs driven and carried by the QB matter. Finding ways of winning games when you have NO line help in the passing game AT ALL counts. He has 17 TD's and 6 picks with half of those coming off tipped balls. I think only two can really be credited to him as just terrible passes.
What makes him above average is his ability to escape from trouble and make plays out of broken plays and/or make the right decision on when to throw it away. Decision making is huge in the modern game and he excels at it. Also his attitude and the work he puts in really does keep the entire team fighting harder even when they are down by 21 points. The whole team carries his never say die and never get too up/too down personality and that isn't something you can teach. The team would do anything for him and believe in his ability to carry the team to victory 100%. There are plenty of 'stat' QB's that don't have that.
Wilson's height does create problems for him. He has missed wide open receivers he probably couldn't see and he does at time get a tipped ball that a taller QB wouldn't have. I wouldn't say he has the deepest passing game in the league, but he has been able to hit open receivers down field in those rare occasions one actually gets open.
I can name a few QB's I'd take over him in the league, but not that many. A healthy Rogers, Manning, and maybe even Luck (debatable, but possibly) and if he wasn't on the tail end of his career throw in Brady just for his experience in the playoffs. Who else would we take over him? If I can only think of 3-4 that would make our team better how can we say he is mediocre at best?