Calling @dirt all 12s and Eli lovers

[DirtDirtDirt]

Understood, and I won't throw a fit when he's elected to the Hall, but you cannot deny, he has two of the luckiest SB wins

Oh yeah, I could deny that pretty easily.......If those were "lucky", so are most Super Bowl winners

Shutting down an all world offense twice

Leading 2 game winning SB Drives

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Because there are a LOT of dumb NY fans. It's pretty easy to understand for most of the civiized population.

Hey, in your shoes, Id still be pretty bitter also

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

He's certainly not one of the worst QB's in the era. He's basically been average, but any HOF mention certainly etches Manning as overrated. He really shouldn't even be in consideration for Canton, but I believe he'll eventually get in.

Totally fair.......HOF is a stat driven and ring driven accolade, and he checks all the boxes......But even as a die hard Giants fan, I dont see a HOF QB every Sunday....But yeah, in an era loaded with awful QB's, to call him "one of the worst in the era" is one of the dumber statements you will ever read

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Oh yeah, I could deny that pretty easily.......If those were "lucky", so are most Super Bowl winners

Shutting down an all world offense twice

Leading 2 game winning SB Drives

Eli was great on D and STs.

 

[LetsGoPats]

Eli has his moments and makes some pretty sweet throws, but he's just too inconsistent.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Eli was great on D and STs.

How many times can I say that about your hero in big games?

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Totally fair.......HOF is a stat driven and ring driven accolade, and he checks all the boxes......But even as a die hard Giants fan, I dont see a HOF QB every Sunday....But yeah, in an era loaded with awful QB's, to call him "one of the worst in the era" is one of the dumber statements you will ever read

It's hard to argue his stats are right up there with Vinny Testaverde and John Brodie.
What's the o/u he's top 10 in INTs by years end? Top 5 before he retires?

 

[NWPATSFAN]

How many times can I say that about your hero in big games?

I'm trying to figure that out. You and the other haters bring it up all the time so this may take a few minutes.

Just strange you never seem to bring it up with mouth breather.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

It's hard to argue his stats are right up there with Vinny Testaverde and John Brodie.
What's the o/u he's top 10 in INTs by years end? Top 5 before he retires?

Safe to say he will finish 6th all time in yards passing, behind some guys named

Peyton
Favre
Brees
Brady and Marino

he should probably finish with around 100 less Int's than that Favre fella

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

I'm trying to figure that out. You and the other haters bring it up all the time so this may take a few minutes.

Just strange you never seem to bring it up with mouth breather.

We've already established you ignore the bad and only discuss the good

 

[Carnzo]

We've already established you ignore the bad and only discuss the good

No that's me. It's all rainbows & gum drops in Patriots Nation.
LOL

 

[NWPATSFAN]

We've already established you ignore the bad and only discuss the good

Kettle meet black

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Kettle meet black

Ive stated he isnt a HOF QB to me

But based on history, he is probably a lock

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Safe to say he will finish 6th all time in yards passing, behind some guys named

Peyton
Favre
Brees
Brady and Marino

he should probably finish with around 100 less Int's than that Favre fella

Good a bunch of passing yards which accounts for nothing. Except he threw a bunch. Doesn't equate to wins, losses, TDs...
Bad o/u on top 5/10 for INTs. No mention. Crickets, crickets, crickets. Kettle=Black

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Ive stated he isnt a HOF QB to me

But based on history, he is probably a lock

Well at least you got that right

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Good a bunch of passing yards which accounts for nothing. Except he threw a bunch. Doesn't equate to wins, losses, TDs...
Bad o/u on top 5/10 for INTs. No mention. Crickets, crickets, crickets. Kettle=Black

He's on a short list of QB's with multiple rings, in history

he's only behind some of the greatest QB's in the history of the NFL, but for some reason passing yards mean nothing for him

 

[Judge Fudge]

Eli has his moments and makes some pretty sweet throws, but he's just too inconsistent.

So wildly WILDLY inconsistent

 

[Judge Fudge]

Safe to say he will finish 6th all time in yards passing, behind some guys named

Peyton
Favre
Brees
Brady and Marino

he should probably finish with around 100 less Int's than that Favre fella

So your saying he is the same class as those listed above and better than that Farve fella.

Talk about delusional

 

[Carnzo]

Ive stated he isnt a HOF QB to me

But based on history, he is probably a lock

I think Tom Coughlin is far more deserving, I won't like it but it is a possibility that Eli get's a mention but not a place in the hall.

 

[soxfan1468927]

I think Tom Coughlin is far more deserving, I won't like it but it is a possibility that Eli get's a mention but not a place in the hall.

Eli's getting in, I'm pretty confident in that.