Timmeh had a similar arc. He has a 7.9 / 7.5 before falling off the cliff. No way does he belong on any of these lists, though. While I do tend to value peaks, you have to have SOME longevity to go along with it. Otherwise you get the opportunities that SHOULD go to others that you end up squandering, thus detracting from your overall value. Timmeh's career WAR is 22.9. In his 2 big seasons, he had 15.4.