BCS rankings out.....I call BS

[BoiseStateFan27]

I'd rather see Houston in the championship then see a rematch of any game for the championship.

 

[Tubbs1518]

Amen to that.

 

[CrimsonFan]

Well too bad the bcs isnt about what you want
It's not about what anyone wants
Its about what the comitee wants
If you don't want to see a rematch you better hope Stanford and okie t and everyone takes care of business
If they don't, then no bitching about it my god.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

So if osu and Stanford lose they deserve a chance?

If OSU,Stanford or Boise go unbeaten it should be their shot if not it should at the least be 2 conference champions playing preferably not a rematch

 

[starbigd]

So if osu and Stanford lose they deserve a chance?

Bama deserves a chance if everyone else loses. It's in no one's best interest for a rematch of the most boring game of the century.

Bama may actually be the best 1 loss team, but they still have 1 loss. Until all other unbeatens lose, Bama doesn't have a legit argument.

 

[HighTide]

Lets be honest then, Georgia isn't a good team either...so Boise really hasn't beaten anybody either...do they deserve their ranking? Does Houston? Does Stanford? Does anybody?

Fuck these stupid arguments.

 

[HighTide]

And just so everybody is clear, Bama lost and they shouldn't have a rematch, in my opinion.

 

[starbigd]

Lets be honest then, Georgia isn't a good team either...so Boise really hasn't beaten anybody either...do they deserve their ranking? Does Houston? Does Stanford? Does anybody?

Fuck these stupid arguments.

The arguments are pretty simple.

Bama is not undefeated. They won't be a conference champ. So they can't reasonably argue they are more deserving.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

And just so everybody is clear, Bama lost and they shouldn't have a rematch, in my opinion.

Rep for not being a homer

 

[CrimsonFan]

If OSU,Stanford or Boise go unbeaten it should be their shot if not it should at the least be 2 conference champions playing preferably not a rematch

So if they both lost every undefeated team loses except for lsu
Alabama doesn't deserve to go because you prefer it not to be a rematch? Not because you don't think they aren't the best 1 loss but it's just your preference?

 

[starbigd]

So if they both lost every undefeated team loses except for lsu
Alabama doesn't deserve to go because you prefer it not to be a rematch? Not because you don't think they aren't the best 1 loss but it's just your preference?

The other one loss teams will have something Bama does not.....a conference title.

 

[Tubbs1518]

Did Oregon lose at home or on the road?

 

[TheRobotDevil]

So if they both lost every undefeated team loses except for lsu
Alabama doesn't deserve to go because you prefer it not to be a rematch? Not because you don't think they aren't the best 1 loss but it's just your preference?

No because they would not both be conference champions .

 

[uncfan103]

Well too bad the bcs isnt about what you want
It's not about what anyone wants
Its about what the comitee wants
If you don't want to see a rematch you better hope Stanford and okie t and everyone takes care of business
If they don't, then no bitching about it my god.

I would much rather see one of those one loss teams instead of one loss Bama or Oregon.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Did Oregon lose at home or on the road?

game was at dallas i believe but considered a home game

 

[HighTide]

The arguments are pretty simple.

Bama is not undefeated. They won't be a conference champ. So they can't reasonably argue they are more deserving.

Edit my bad, I didn't quote in this topic.

It was in response to the Boise fan's post about SEc teams not playing anyone.

 

[Tubbs1518]

Ok well alabama lost at home. Oregon did not. I'd put Oregon over Alabama still.

 

[uncfan103]

What can Bama possibly argue. We arent the best team in our own conference but because we think we are better than you we should still have a chance at becoming national champions? thats absurd. if you cant win your conference you cant complain when you are left out of a title game.

 

[CrimsonFan]

What can Bama possibly argue. We arent the best team in our own conference but because we think we are better than you we should still have a chance at becoming national champions? thats absurd. if you cant win your conference you cant complain when you are left out of a title game.

We still have a shot at winning our conference.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

What can Bama possibly argue. We arent the best team in our own conference but because we think we are better than you we should still have a chance at becoming national champions? thats absurd. if you cant win your conference you cant complain when you are left out of a title game.

They're definately running the wrong route to the NCG but I',m guessing they Saban will cry " But the comittee wants us here"