Ask Milk: would he veto that trade

[MilkSpiller22]

This thread is for you guys to ask me if I would veto that trade...

Use real trades, or trades that you are thinking about offering...

or if you really want to, make up a trade...

WILL MILK VETO????!!! that is the question... and i know, YOU ALLL WANT TO KNOW!!!!

 

[Robotech]

Can you reverse the trade I made for George Kittle wherein I sent Keenan Allen, Joshua Kelley, and Evan Engram? I'd like Keenan Allen back on my roster. LOL.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Contending team gets CMC
Rebuilding team gets 2021 pick 1.01 and a 2022 1st

Veto or accept?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Contending team gets CMC
Rebuilding team gets 2021 pick 1.01 and a 2022 1st

Veto or accept?

that's an easy veto... the contending team is not going to give a good pick, and the rebuilding team is giving up on a top 5 pick in a redraft...

and 2022 is too much of an unknown to help...


..also- the opposite of veto is not accept... dont think there is an opposite of veto... veto is a hard core reject...

 

[SmokingMonkey]

that's an easy veto... the contending team is not going to give a good pick, and the rebuilding team is giving up on a top 5 pick in a redraft...

and 2022 is too much of an unknown to help...


..also- the opposite of veto is not accept... dont think there is an opposite of veto... veto is a hard core reject...

hmmm, feel like we went down this path already on that other thread, but at what point does a team that isn't contending for a playoff spot, let alone a title run, cut bait on assets and pile up picks for a rebuild?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

hmmm, feel like we went down this path already on that other thread, but at what point does a team that isn't contending for a playoff spot, let alone a title run, cut bait on assets and pile up picks for a rebuild?

rebuilding is one thing, but trading your best player for unequal pieces is not rebuilding... I mean, if you have a redraft next year, where would McCaffrey be drafted, where would the low end first round rookie be drafted?? if it was a top pick, then sure, take the risk... but its not, its a contenders pick...

 

[SmokingMonkey]

rebuilding is one thing, but trading your best player for unequal pieces is not rebuilding... I mean, if you have a redraft next year, where would McCaffrey be drafted, where would the low end first round rookie be drafted?? if it was a top pick, then sure, take the risk... but its not, its a contenders pick...

in my scenario it is the 1.01 in next year's draft, so the rebuilding team would be getting the 1.01 in the draft, not the contender's pick. the 2022 would be the contender's pick though

 

[MilkSpiller22]

in my scenario it is the 1.01 in next year's draft, so the rebuilding team would be getting the 1.01 in the draft, not the contender's pick. the 2022 would be the contender's pick though

And that is my bad for not reading. Lol.

 

[averagejoe]

Can call this "Between Two Gallons"

Anyway...

12 team PPR dynasty. I am loaded at WR and currently the #1 seed. A non-playoff owner expressed an interest in Lockett. At the end of the season, would you trade Lockwood for Mixon?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Can call this "Between Two Gallons"

Anyway...

12 team PPR dynasty. I am loaded at WR and currently the #1 seed. A non-playoff owner expressed an interest in Lockett. At the end of the season, would you trade Lockwood for Mixon?

a little confused by the question... I would rather have locket this season, but Mixon for next... No matter who is on my team...

so if you are waiting until end of season, I think it is a pretty bad trade for the Lockett owner... Not a veto- level bad... but just a bad trade...

If you are making the deal NOW... I would probably not do the trade if I was to be giving away locket, and I was the playoff contender... as locket has much more value IMO...

and I am unsure why the non competivie team would trade Mixon for lockett…

But either way this is not a veto-able trade... Just a weird one IMO for the non competive team to be giving the better value player, at a more lucrative position...


and if you are going to wait until the end, then why wouldnt the Mixon owner wait for the off-season, when mixon's value will come back to where it was before this season... probably actually would increase since Burrow will be back, and now we all know he is pretty awsome...

 

[TKOSpikes]

Can call this "Between Two Gallons"

Anyway...

12 team PPR dynasty. I am loaded at WR and currently the #1 seed. A non-playoff owner expressed an interest in Lockett. At the end of the season, would you trade Lockwood for Mixon?

Yes I would. And also right now.

But I'm also puzzled at why the non competitive team would want Lockett over Mixon in 2021... though that is not of my concern. Jump on it now I say.

 

[averagejoe]

Yes I would. And also right now.

But I'm also puzzled at why the non competitive team would want Lockett over Mixon in 2021... though that is not of my concern. Jump on it now I say.

I don't know if he would trade Mixon. All i know is that he expressed an interest in Lockett. I should add that this owner tends to overpay for players he targets. After the season Mixon had, i'm hoping he sours on him for next season. And to be honest, he has no one else of value i would consider offering Lockett for.

 

[Payton]

And that is my bad for not reading. Lol.

So say that 1.1 is Etienne on say, the Texans or Steelers?

 

[cwalke3408]

Happened week 1 this year in my Clemson homer dynasty league.

Mike Williams for Tyler Lockett

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Happened week 1 this year in my Clemson homer dynasty league.

Mike Williams for Tyler Lockett

stupid trade. But nowhere near vetoable or even questioned.