Game Thread: AFC Championship Bills @ Chiefs

[Schmoopy1000]

you're a Cowboys fan so you should sit this one out

why?
Having no dog in this fight probably makes me more objective than either side.

 

[Clayton]

the real difference was.
Brady was on a Championship caliber team. Manning was the Colts. So brady owned Manning early on.

Yeah, when Brady got injured the Pats won 4 or 5 fewer games. When Manning got injured, the Colts got the #1 pick

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

I won’t call Allen overrated but I’m sick of the “Mahomes vs Allen is the new Manning vs Brady” thing, Allen isn’t on the same level as Mahomes and it’s stupid to act like he is when he’s lost to him all 4 times they’ve met in the playoffs.

Allen is on par with Maholmes. Not his fault Bills defense can't make a critical stop.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Yeah, when Brady got injured the Pats won 4 or 5 fewer games. When Manning got injured, the Colts got the #1 pick

bingo.
When Brady got hurt they still won double digit games, When Manning got hurt, Colts were toast.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

 

[Xeliou66]

Allen is on par with Maholmes. Not his fault Bills defense can't make a critical stop.

No he isn’t. He’s made zero Super Bowls, Mahomes has made 5. No active QB is on par with Mahomes

 

[TheGoodMan19]

No he isn’t. He’s made zero Super Bowls, Mahomes has made 5. No active QB is on par with Mahomes

So, to put this onto baseball, Ted Williams Ty Cobb, Ernie Banks was not on a par with Charlie Silvera?

Football is a team game, it isn't tennis. Q is very important but not the all

 

[msgkings322]

So, to put this onto baseball, Ted Williams Ty Cobb, Ernie Banks was not on a par with Charlie Silvera?

Football is a team game, it isn't tennis. Q is very important but not the all

I 100% agree with this but it doesn't change the Mahomes = GOAT argument (it undermines the Brady as GOAT argument actually)

And it doesn't mean Allen is = Mahomes either. Allen is elite, top 3 QB in the game right now. But no one is putting him in a GOAT conversation without some Super Bowl action.

 

[Xeliou66]

So, to put this onto baseball, Ted Williams Ty Cobb, Ernie Banks was not on a par with Charlie Silvera?

Football is a team game, it isn't tennis. Q is very important but not the all

Mahomes is one of the greatest QBs of all time and has been the key to the Chiefs 3 Super Bowl wins. He’s not some nobody who’s being compared to a great. No QB in the NFL is on the same level as him.

 

[Think McFly Think]

I 100% agree with this but it doesn't change the Mahomes = GOAT argument (it undermines the Brady as GOAT argument actually)

And it doesn't mean Allen is = Mahomes either. Allen is elite, top 3 QB in the game right now. But no one is putting him in a GOAT conversation without some Super Bowl action.

I agree but I always find it interesting to ponder if Reid had Lamar, Allen or even Burrow for instance are they in the same position as they are under the Chiefs’ structure (coaching, support cast O and D) from the last few years?

Are the Ravens, Bills and Bengals going to the SB with Mahomes?

Hard to say for sure but interesting to think about.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

No he isn’t. He’s made zero Super Bowls, Mahomes has made 5. No active QB is on par with Mahomes

Bills scored 29 gave up 32
Bills scored 24 gave up 38
Bills score 36 gave up 42 (ot) Allen never got on the field in ot.

Let me know when Josh Allen plays defense.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

I agree but I always find it interesting to ponder if Reid had Lamar, Allen or even Burrow for instance are they in the same position as they are under the Chiefs’ structure (coaching, support cast O and D) from the last few years?

Are the Ravens, Bills and Bengals going to the SB with Mahomes?

Hard to say for sure but interesting to think about.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Bills scored 29 gave up 32
Bills scored 24 gave up 38
Bills score 36 gave up 42 (ot) Allen never got on the field in ot.

Let me know when Josh Allen plays defense.

but Josh Allen does play Defense

 

[ElPatron1]

No he isn’t. He’s made zero Super Bowls, Mahomes has made 5. No active QB is on par with Mahomes

No active QB has that many refs

 

[Clayton]

Let me know when Josh Allen plays defense.

 

[Think McFly Think]

I agree with the Bengals perhaps being the exception. Lol

 

[Schmoopy1000]

I agree with the Bengals perhaps being the exception. Lol

hell you could probably argue all three of those teams might go to a Superbowl if Mahomes were in the NFC.

 

[Think McFly Think]

hell you could probably argue all three of those teams might go to a Superbowl if Mahomes were in the NFC.

Also a good point

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

I agree but I always find it interesting to ponder if Reid had Lamar, Allen or even Burrow for instance are they in the same position as they are under the Chiefs’ structure (coaching, support cast O and D) from the last few years?

Are the Ravens, Bills and Bengals going to the SB with Mahomes?

Hard to say for sure but interesting to think about.

All 3 are better than Mcnabb so yes I think he wins with all 3 of those QB.

 

[TheGoodMan19]

Mahomes is one of the greatest QBs of all time and has been the key to the Chiefs 3 Super Bowl wins. He’s not some nobody who’s being compared to a great. No QB in the NFL is on the same level as him.

Who has/had the better receivers? Allen never had a target like Kelce or Tyreek Hill. Better offensive line, Chiefs. Better defense, Chiefs again. Send State Farm Boy to the Giants and see how he does.