1phlapdown
Well-Known Member
And no runs in the 1st for a change.I didn't know a Giants starter was allowed to give up zero runs.
And no runs in the 1st for a change.I didn't know a Giants starter was allowed to give up zero runs.
If they dfa him (which would be the alternative, once he has to come off the dl) that would be stupid. They need a backup middle infielder and he was swinging the bat well when he got injured. I think some of you are stuck on the Giants having to carry 13 pitchers. I think they will cut it down to 12. Suarez, Stratton, Blach, Johnson, Moronta, Rodriguez all have options. Only Moronta, Stratton and maybe Rodriguez deserve to stay up.There are just soooo many moving parts in the roster construction this week, I am making no assumptions.
The only assumptions I am making are...
Pence up tomorrow
Phalic starts on Sunday
Bum up and starts on Tuesday
That’s it. Hanson coming up is not a given (though he SHOULD be up).
I think this is a good situation for him. But it needs to be made clear that Strick is the closer. It is HIS job to lose.Strick is the closer, but would it be smart to bring in Melancon here? If not to get comfortable in the 9th? Or do you wait for a blowout?
Now maybe Blanco is already gone and Jackson goes on the dl for Hanson to be activated but I doubt it. I'm sticking with 12 pitchers this time next week (barring some unforeseen injury to a position player).I don't even know who's healthy anymore.
Bum
Stratton
Holland
Suarez
Rodriguez
Strick
Watson
Dyson
Smith
Moronta
Melancon
Gearrin
Blach
So you're saying one of these 13 has to go down for Hanson?
I think this is a good situation for him. But it needs to be made clear that Strick is the closer. It is HIS job to lose.
Now maybe Blanco is already gone and Jackson goes on the dl for Hanson to be activated but I doubt it. I'm sticking with 12 pitchers this time next week (barring some unforeseen injury to a position player).
My bad. I thought he had an option. He doesn’t.If they dfa him (which would be the alternative, once he has to come off the dl) that would be stupid. They need a backup middle infielder and he was swinging the bat well when he got injured. I think some of you are stuck on the Giants having to carry 13 pitchers. I think they will cut it down to 12. Suarez, Stratton, Blach, Johnson, Moronta, Rodriguez all have options. Only Moronta, Stratton and maybe Rodriguez deserve to stay up.
Yeah, nice call...On second thought, I like Strick here to the middle of the Phillies' order
This inning isn't starting well. Bad night for Strickland to implode when Melancon just got activated.On second thought, I like Strick here to the middle of the Phillies' order
Yeah, nice call...
It is possible that is exactly why he is struggling.This inning isn't starting well. Bad night for Strickland to implode when Melancon just got activated.