3 years to judge a draft pick?

[LoftonPack80]

You are proving my point. Anderson's good year? His first. Sidney Rice's great first year? Also, his first. Rodgers did suck when he had his chances, he wasn't just so-so, he was terrible.

Rice took three years and his only good year was with Favre and all the other weapons they had on that team.

 

[LoftonPack80]

What about him?

He was hot garbage his first three years in the league. Went on to become one of the top safeties over his next three before the injury. Thats what.

 

[JDM]

I actually mostly agree with noon on this. Not factoring in people simply not being on the radar or not having enough reps to really see them in action, you can get a good read on most people fairly quickly. There are some who have the physical tools but mentality is debatable, but it's rare for a guy to look like he doesn't have the skill set to magically put it together and make it work.

 

[noonthirtyjoe]

(you can get a good read on most people fairly quickly) Exactly.

 

[leomaz]

WRONG....

After seeing them play just a few snaps. Shea good situational pass rusher, will never be a every down DE. Long HOF monster. Bostic will be very good, not BU good. AJ top 10 WR to be.

Shea is not a good situational anything...........and I said that the moment they drafted him

 

[anotheridiot]

the only think going for us with Shea is they didnt go all mark anderson and have him gain weight to get to 280 to stop the run better.