gordontrue
Bandwagoner
Rose was (from his MVP season) and still a superstar. He never be as dominating as before but he will always be a household name. Where as Kyrie is a star who may become a superstar. We already seen him on team by himself and wasn't pretty and you have to be more than just the 2nd best player on the #2 seed in the East to be a superstar.
Give me a player in the last 15 years - not named LeBron - that was on a team by himself and it was pretty.
Durant's teams averaged 22 wins per year until Westbrook, Harden, and Ibaka came along.
Judging Irving by his team's record in his first few years is a pretty steep criteria.