July 5th trade

[The Foot]

Hey guys if you are getting sick of these questions let me know and I will slow it down. I really am having a ball asking these and it is helping me tremendously to accomplish a trade. All your guys thoughts are a great advantage cause like Treff said I do have trading problem and can get caught up in a bad trade because of needing a trade fix and sometime just to do a deal to do a deal. Your advice at least protects me from myself so I don't do something stupid. I will never stop trading but at least I have you great guys to tell me when to pump the breaks on a deal or to let it ride. Which brings me to my next question.

Who would you rather have in this deal?

Kaeps
Ebron
Hyde
Latimore

or

Rodgers
and a second round pick in next years 2015 draft?

Keep in mind it is a full keeper forever.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

if i was to trade rodgers, there would be 2 scenarios.

1. you plan on a rebuilding year

2. I am getting current value to help me now win!!!

this trade does not qualify for number 2. Is number one true??

If this is not a rebuilding season then i would not make this deal!!!

 

[TKOSpikes]

Not even close. Rodgers is still your stud. I know you're high on Kaeps, so if he and Ebron are in your sights, then try and work something out, but like milk said, trading Rodgers would be very extreme.

Just curious, are people (seems like only one or two) coming after Aaron, or did you put him on the block?

 

[SteelersPride]

NOOOO

 

[The Foot]

yea TKO a few people are really coming after him. I did not put him on the block.

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

Fantasy FB has become about the stud QB as the foundation of a team. In a keeper league, I would not trade Rodgers, Peyton or Brees unless I get back a combo of two stud RBs/WRs. Probably not going to get that trade so I probably don't trade the QB.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Rodgers is a known quantity and the players you are getting in return aren't. Seems very risky, imo. I would just have to be getting at least 1 hands down stud + young prospects (not just a bunch of young prospects) to let go of Rodgers.
What are you, the Miami Marlins of your fantasy football league?

People are coming after him in hopes that you are down on him due to his injury last season. I wouldn't be too quick to let him go. Obviously the guys making you offers would want to have Rodgers as their QB for the next 5-8 seasons, so why shouldn't you?

 

[TKOSpikes]

Well if they are coming after him, remind them who they're chasing! Probably the best QB to have over the next five years. The offers coming in seem to be for 2017 Aaron Rodgers.

I would not be giving any picks back (maybe last round picks if they have to be in there). Example, I don't think I would trade him for Kaeps, Ebron and a high pick... you might since you love Kaeps, but my point is, it would take a massive haul.

 

[Barilko]

Well if they are coming after him, remind them who they're chasing! Probably the best QB to have over the next five years. The offers coming in seem to be for 2017 Aaron Rodgers.

I would not be giving any picks back (maybe last round picks if they have to be in there). Example, I don't think I would trade him for Kaeps, Ebron and a high pick... you might since you love Kaeps, but my point is, it would take a massive haul.

Perfect TKO Foot dont do it....

i think we all agree that Rodgers/Brees/Manning are the big 3 and even at that in this type of league Manning isnt around for ever....

so is the next best in this scenario a Ryan/Luck/...i wouldnt deal unless i got back at least a Qb that we feel is par to Ryan/Luck and of course 2 or more studs in other positions...

in otherwords keep Rodgers....

 

[SteelersPride]

i traded rodgers in a keeper league this year, but its 1 keeper, and redraft everyone else.........and a ppr league, and got Calvin back

 

[SmokingMonkey]

i traded rodgers in a keeper league this year, but its 1 keeper, and redraft everyone else.........and a ppr league, and got Calvin back

exactly - don't move Rodgers unless you are getting a stud in return!