Who are the five most overrated QB's/Teams in the NFL?

[JDM]

I understand that but its not like he ever had Aaron Rodgers capability and than starting playing worse and worse. He was a mediocre QB from the beginning with a lot of talent and still is a mediocre QB with a lot of talent. You cant be overrated if you were never supposed to be the best or one of the best.

I don't consider him top 15 even. He gets talked about like he's borderline top 10.

If you agree he is mediocre, that's fine. I respect a reasonable view on your QB. I don't think the rest of your fan base or even some others share that viewpoint.

 

[DaBearsShowPride]

I don't consider him top 15 even. He gets talked about like he's borderline top 10.

If you agree he is mediocre, that's fine. I respect a reasonable view on your QB. I don't think the rest of your fan base or even some others share that viewpoint.

I personally would rank Cutler just where he is now at 14, 15, 16 and Qb's in that range normally stay there throughout their career meaning there not really overrated/underrated, they are just mediocre.

 

[NinerSickness]

Most Underrated:
Teams: Bears, Rams, Bucs, Colts, Chiefs

Players: Matt Forte, Jimmy Graham, NaVarro Bowman, Cameron Wake, Brandon Pettigrew

How are Bowman, Graham & Wake underrated? Most people have them all in the top 3 or so players in the NFL at their respective positions.

 

[Dude]

Pats are very overrated, they have not won diddly in years. Patriots suck!

 

[Shanemansj13]

How is Brees even considered in this topic??

 

[USCDoom]

Pats are very overrated, they have not won diddly in years. Patriots suck!

Dude...

 

[Clayton]

Haters make up anything to discredit Manning success. Now the QB he plays against is not good enough, .

Dude, Grossman was garbage

 

[jayviabay]

How is Brees even considered in this topic??

im confused as well

 

[BoP]

YOU DISCUSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1: Ravens
2: Redskins
3: Seahawks
4: Cowboys
5: Steelers

 

[JDM]

How is Brees even considered in this topic??

He's treated like he is elite or an all time great and he is not. He's better than a lot of QBs in the NFL, but he isn't elite, and he certainly doesn't belong near an all-time discussion.

 

[DaBearsShowPride]

1: Ravens
2: Redskins
3: Seahawks
4: Cowboys
5: Steelers

Whoever thinks the Cowboys are a good team in the first place are a little crazy in the head.

 

[DaBearsShowPride]

He's treated like he is elite or an all time great and he is not. He's better than a lot of QBs in the NFL, but he isn't elite, and he certainly doesn't belong near an all-time discussion.

Curious on why you dont think he is Elite? I'm there with you and think he slightly falls short of it just interested on your thoughts.

 

[JDM]

He's just not on the level of Brady, Peyton, and Aaron Rodgers. It's not any one thing, but the difference between the the three of them is massive compared to the difference among the three. He's solidly near the top of the next tier, but I just can't put him on the elite level.

 

[DaBearsShowPride]

He's just not on the level of Brady, Peyton, and Aaron Rodgers. It's not any one thing, but the difference between the the three of them is massive compared to the difference among the three. He's solidly near the top of the next tier, but I just can't put him on the elite level.

I would also add his arm is not nearly as strong as those 3 and not strong enough to be considered elite. If I wanted to run a true West Coast scheme then Brees would be my number one or two pick. Considering his arm strength, accuracy, touch, height, etc the WC is perfect for him and thats why he has excelled so well in this league.

 

[RoboticDreams]

SF and Ravens have the 2 best rosters in the NFL going into 2013?

SF doesn't even have the best roster in their division.

Yes they do, but your team has the second best in the division and in the league.

Trying being rational.

 

[JDM]

I would also add his arm is not nearly as strong as those 3 and not strong enough to be considered elite. If I wanted to run a true West Coast scheme then Brees would be my number one or two pick. Considering his arm strength, accuracy, touch, height, etc the WC is perfect for him and thats why he has excelled so well in this league.

I think any of the elite three I mentioned would do far better in every single scheme (including west coast. All are accurate) than Brees could.

 

[DaBearsShowPride]

Yes they do, but your team has the second best in the division and in the league.

Trying being rational.

I would agree and say the 49ers have the best roster in their division.

 

[DaBearsShowPride]

I think any of the elite three I mentioned would do far better in every single scheme (including west coast. All are accurate) than Brees could.

They would do very good as well but something about Brees's touch on the ball and footwork take it over those 3 guys for me. I think Brady and Rodgers throw with too much zing on the ball and wouldnt be accurate enough every down. Manning would be great too but he is the type of qb that likes to take more time to read the defense and you gotta be quick in the wc system.

 

[DaBoltsNIsles]

Haters make up anything to discredit Manning success. Now the QB he plays against is not good enough, when the Bears had one of the best defense and the Colts still score 30+. Just ignore the comeback Peyton lead against the Pats 2 wks before. Ppl seem to forget football is a team sport and not a 1 on 1 against QBs.

Did you watch the game? Grossman had a hard time taking the ball from Center without fumbling it, let alone throwing it. I imagine Bear fans CRINGED every time he threw the ball. The Bears D did all they could. Grossman made to many mistakes for them to overcome.

 

[DaBoltsNIsles]

Teams

1.Cowboys Make the playoffs then we'll talk. Then again Romo is the QB. The playoffs are, but a dream.:
2.Texans I'm not sold on Schaub. Their D could be good when healthy, but Rodgers & Brady showed they have a lot of work to do.
3.Redskins Their QB needs to stay upright. Their D needs a lot of help. I'm not sold.
4.Falcons Come playoff time this team simply can't get it done. I don't like their D either.
5.NY JETS I have to put them here simply because Disney won't stop talking about them. Disney needs to realize something, THE JETS ARE GOING TO SUCK THIS YEAR. There are 32 teams in the NFL. If somebody who didn't know much about football watched Disney they would probably believe the Jets were the best team in the league with all the coverage they get.