Which side do you want?

[SmokingMonkey]

16tm full ppr

Not sure those 2nd round picks carry enough swagger to land McVay's WR1.

Figure 1.06 will be Tet McMillian or one of the Ohio St RBs, I'm 95% sure that Jeanty, Hampton, Hunter will be top 3 but not sure if the next 2 draft picks will keep the RB train rolling

 

[MilkSpiller22]

16tm full ppr

Not sure those 2nd round picks carry enough swagger to land McVay's WR1.

Figure 1.06 will be Tet McMillian or one of the Ohio St RBs, I'm 95% sure that Jeanty, Hampton, Hunter will be top 3 but not sure if the next 2 draft picks will keep the RB train rolling

what is the minimum amount of WRs you are allowed to start?? and who are your other WRs...


if it is a 2 WR + flex league, id probably want the picks...


if it a 3 WR + flex league, i probably would rather have puka

 

[TREFF]

Do you have Achane? if so it's worth considering, if not, it's a hard pass IMHO

either way I'd probably still pass. A #2 can jsut as easily be a guy you cut as one who can be a staple of your lineups..if that #1 isn't in the top 3, can't deal an elite/elite adjacent WR

 

[SmokingMonkey]

2 WR + 2 Flex

WR depth isn't good, bunch of WR2/3s behind Puka, but serviceable options to play matchups in flex spots

I do have Achane which is why I'm considering

 

[MilkSpiller22]

2 WR + 2 Flex

WR depth isn't good, bunch of WR2/3s behind Puka, but serviceable options to play matchups in flex spots

I do have Achane which is why I'm considering

so Puka is your #1 and you dont have a real potential #1 to take over??

then i would not trade Puka here... I am not high on Puka, but sounds like the downgrade is going to be too much...

 

[Shanemansj13]

That 6th draft spot is up in the air...maybe you get a "tier 2 RB" or Mcmillan...I would probably do the trade if you knew Hunter was there at 6 but I don't see that happening. The other picks are just roster fillers and question marks. TBH I think Mcmillan is a question mark too, I am not a huge fan

I take the Nacua side of this trade

 

[SmokingMonkey]

That 6th draft spot is up in the air...maybe you get a "tier 2 RB" or Mcmillan...I would probably do the trade if you knew Hunter was there at 6 but I don't see that happening. The other picks are just roster fillers and question marks. TBH I think Mcmillan is a question mark too, I am not a huge fan

I take the Nacua side of this trade

Same guy has a pick before 1.06 and is taking hunter

 

[MilkSpiller22]

2 WR + 2 Flex

WR depth isn't good, bunch of WR2/3s behind Puka, but serviceable options to play matchups in flex spots

I do have Achane which is why I'm considering

can you trade achane instead of Nakua?? not for the same deal... but it seems like nakua is better for your team than achane... especially with the potential Dolphin collapse... bad O-line, weird WR situation, and a QB in even a weirder position...

 

[Chef99]

I'm a big Puka fan.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

can you trade achane instead of Nakua?? not for the same deal... but it seems like nakua is better for your team than achane... especially with the potential Dolphin collapse... bad O-line, weird WR situation, and a QB in even a weirder position...

That's an interesting angle, Achane is a ppr machine. That uncertainty at WR prob gives him more targets, Miami didn't really do anything to upgrade receiving weapons either besides bringing in NWI

 

[MilkSpiller22]

That's an interesting angle, Achane is a ppr machine. That uncertainty at WR prob gives him more targets, Miami didn't really do anything to upgrade receiving weapons either besides bringing in NWI

Sure but that usage is going to hurt the small bodied Achane. Do you really think he can handle even a bigger workload?? And efficiency is going to be worse if they are that much worse of an offense.

Personally I would rather trade Achane while his value is so high than to trade puka.

 

[Chef99]

Sure but that usage is going to hurt the small bodied Achane. Do you really think he can handle even a bigger workload?? And efficiency is going to be worse if they are that much worse of an offense.

Personally I would rather trade Achane while his value is so high than to trade puka.

Damn, MIlk, you're making a very good point here.

 

[TREFF]

That's an interesting angle, Achane is a ppr machine. That uncertainty at WR prob gives him more targets, Miami didn't really do anything to upgrade receiving weapons either besides bringing in NWI

One would think that between Waddle and Reek there wouldn't need to be much else

 

[Chef99]

One would think that between Waddle and Reek there wouldn't need to be much else

@MilkSpiller22 has a very good point, tho.

Dolphins are declining and, I think, a rebuild is already beginning.

Achane just might be the poster boy for "Sell High!" right now.

Not to mention the Dolphins have a QB that is one step away from having his brains possibly scrambled.

 

[TREFF]

@MilkSpiller22 has a very good point, tho.

Dolphins are declining and, I think, a rebuild is already beginning.

Achane just might be the poster boy for "Sell High!" right now.

Oh fer sure, I ain't arguing agianst it..just saying, I'm a little shocked that Waddle and Reek don't get MORE targets than they do. I mean why is Jonnu Smith getting 100+ targets?

Ohhh yeah..the QB ..nevermind..lol

 

[Chef99]

Oh fer sure, I ain't arguing agianst it..just saying, I'm a little shocked that Waddle and Reek don't get MORE targets than they do. I mean why is Jonnu Smith getting 100+ targets?

Ohhh yeah..the QB ..nevermind..lol

I just edited my previous post to include him.

 

[TREFF]

I just edited my previous post to include him.

I think a rational case can be made that they already have been scrambled hard

 

[Chef99]

I think a rational case can be made that they already have been scrambled hard

Yes. Dude is already set for life, time to walk away.

But...we all make our choices.

 

[SteelersPride]

I'm a big Puka fan.

Puka should have kupp like numbers for at least the next 2-3 years if healthy and gaudy numbers for some time….stafford effects this though. If he retires…that whole offense changes.

 

[SteelersPride]

Sure but that usage is going to hurt the small bodied Achane. Do you really think he can handle even a bigger workload?? And efficiency is going to be worse if they are that much worse of an offense.

Personally I would rather trade Achane while his value is so high than to trade puka.

Super valid point. Miami knows this too. Hence them never letting going committee